• Celebrating One Year of Revival!

    Come and join us in celebrating one year of GW's revival as GWF, share in some statistics and help us push towards the next twenty years! CLICK HERE

    We're also looking for suggestions for another community event we can put together that we can all enjoy! Come and give us some suggestions HERE
  • Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Post your pictures

Oh wow, I can't wait to see the results. We upgraded to a pizza stone last year and that was a game changer - this looks even more epic.
I use a stone on my grill and the max temp I can get is 600. It's good but limited. This one goes to 900 for Neapolitan, and 750 for NY style so I had to get it. Trying out tomorrow. If successful there will be photos.
 
I've tried pizza stones before. Was gifted a kit once. I never really got into it. Didn't make the pizza like I wanted to and they were hard to clean. Is the stain that stays no matter how much you try to clean it normal?

If I'm going to do something besides putting the pizza directly on the oven grill, it's going to be a cast iron pizza pan. Gotten pretty good results from those.
 

A PineSol Scent

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
11,768
I've tried pizza stones before. Was gifted a kit once. I never really got into it. Didn't make the pizza like I wanted to and they were hard to clean. Is the stain that stays no matter how much you try to clean it normal?

If I'm going to do something besides putting the pizza directly on the oven grill, it's going to be a cast iron pizza pan. Gotten pretty good results from those.
Cast Iron is a good choice for pizza. We normally will do 2 pizzas if we go homemade, one in the cast iron (my preferred) and one on the pizza stone. It helps to get them heated up in the oven first, and then make sure you flour the stone (oil the cast iron) before putting the dough on it.

Yes, stains will basically stick around, but it's no issue.
 
I'm too lazy to make a pizza from scratch. I only do frozen pizzas... take out/delivery.
The stone changed my frozen pizza game as well. As long as you preheat the stone and flour it like mentioned, there is a noticeable difference. However, totally understandable how the point of frozen pizza is pizza without the hassle - and this method will require more work.
 

A PineSol Scent

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
11,768
The stone changed my frozen pizza game as well. As long as you preheat the stone and flour it like mentioned, there is a noticeable difference. However, totally understandable how the point of frozen pizza is pizza without the hassle - and this method will require more work.
Low Effort: Frozen Pizza
Medium Effort: Frozen Pizza on Stone
High Effort: Pizza from scratch

Although I'd probably say low-medium for frozen on stone. It's still more than just straight heating it up, but not even close to halfway between frozen and from scratch. Much closer level of effort to just plain frozen. It might be worth the effort for the improved results. Certainly worth testing to see if it is.
 

A PineSol Scent

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
11,768
More from scratch recommendations:

If you like a thinner and crispy crust, a stone can be a great choice. If you like thicker crust, cast iron can make that process a bit easier/better for you. If you have a more specialized one you're going for (my thought it always the south shore style I grew up with) it's a low cut pizza pan filled with corn oil, and a thin crust on top.

When I make it at home I tend to do the thicker crust in the cast iron because all my takeout options for GF are basically exclusively thin crust (not even extra breading with flavor around the edge...) and it's my only option to get something like that.
 
I have my dough recipe down so it's easy to do. Now it should cook in 2 minutes instead of 10.

I'm team cornmeal as well. It's the ideal way to get some toasty flavor and it's easy to slide the pizza off the peel.

Alu if you have a gluten free dough recipe let me know. My wife's best friend is GF and we'd like to host a pizza party for them.
 

A PineSol Scent

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
11,768
I have my dough recipe down so it's easy to do. Now it should cook in 2 minutes instead of 10.

I'm team cornmeal as well. It's the ideal way to get some toasty flavor and it's easy to slide the pizza off the peel.

Alu if you have a gluten free dough recipe let me know. My wife's best friend is GF and we'd like to host a pizza party for them.
Bob's Red Mill has a decent recipe for it that's easy. You can also buy one of their mixes at most stores if you want an even easier time.


I tend to pre-bake it a bit before loading toppings on, but that might not be necessary. It just worked to get the crust extra crispy while not burning any ingredients.
 

canadaguy

Ploop Heard
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
4,885
Low Effort: Frozen Pizza
Medium Effort: Frozen Pizza on Stone
High Effort: Pizza from scratch

Although I'd probably say low-medium for frozen on stone. It's still more than just straight heating it up, but not even close to halfway between frozen and from scratch. Much closer level of effort to just plain frozen. It might be worth the effort for the improved results. Certainly worth testing to see if it is.
Highest effort: book a private jet to Italy
 

Mark

Dumbass Progenitor
Administrator
GW Elder
Messages
8,200
Lol, thats awesome. In the summer, sure. When its 40 degrees and raining, I'll wait.

My brother wants me to build a little tiki hut around my grill and pizza oven so we can have pizza and margaritas no matter the weather.

Sounds like your brother needs to grab a shovel and start leveling off some ground.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
15,102
I have my dough recipe down so it's easy to do. Now it should cook in 2 minutes instead of 10.

I'm team cornmeal as well. It's the ideal way to get some toasty flavor and it's easy to slide the pizza off the peel.

Alu if you have a gluten free dough recipe let me know. My wife's best friend is GF and we'd like to host a pizza party for them.
What’s your dough recipe? I haven’t made dough in a few years and hadn’t found a recipe I really liked. Being back in NYC made me just order great pizza instead of making it myself
 
Really simple.

3.25 cups 00 Flour
1.25 cups warm water with yeast mixed in for 5-7 minutes. I know it's stupid but I feel like my well water makes a difference.
1 TBSP sugar
1 TBSP salt

That's really it. I used a stand mixer so it's easy. Mix the dry first and then slowly pour in the yeast mixture. Dough hook for 5 minutes until it unsticks from the bowl. If proofed in a warm area for a few hours, it's foolproof. It is actually not bad without the overnight proof in the refrigerator if I'm low on time.

If I'm feeling frisky, Ill melt butter with minced garlic to brush on the crust before it goes in the oven.
 

A PineSol Scent

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
11,768
Really simple.

3.25 cups 00 Flour
1.25 cups warm water with yeast mixed in for 5-7 minutes. I know it's stupid but I feel like my well water makes a difference.
1 TBSP sugar
1 TBSP salt

That's really it. I used a stand mixer so it's easy. Mix the dry first and then slowly pour in the yeast mixture. Dough hook for 5 minutes until it unsticks from the bowl. If proofed in a warm area for a few hours, it's foolproof. It is actually not bad without the overnight proof in the refrigerator if I'm low on time.

If I'm feeling frisky, Ill melt butter with minced garlic to brush on the crust before it goes in the oven.
FYI you can use this exact recipe with any of the one for one or measure for measure gluten free flours, just also add in a teaspoon or two of Xantham gum.

GF dough is.... Different. It's not stretchy. You kind of need to spread it out with a rubber spatula or wet hands to make it not stick to you.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
15,102
I know it's stupid but I feel like my well water makes a difference.
It might. Part of why NYC pizza is so good is the water. I knew someone whose family owned a pizza shop in New Jersey and they had large jugs of water filled in Brooklyn and shipped to them so they could make their dough
 
Back
Top Bottom