• Celebrating One Year of Revival!

    Come and join us in celebrating one year of GW's revival as GWF, share in some statistics and help us push towards the next twenty years! CLICK HERE

    We're also looking for suggestions for another community event we can put together that we can all enjoy! Come and give us some suggestions HERE
  • Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

GWF Zell Wolf Version XII - Day 2

Who should the villagers lynch? (4 votes required)

  • Alu

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Benzine

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Fool’s Requiem

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jawneh

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • shortkut

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12
  • Poll closed .

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
Tubby was too dead by that time. Spirit seer gets info after all the kills have been dealt. Look at the action list.

Voting Jon

Yup, he was.

And this was our plan. To see who would catch the action list.

I really am who I say I am. I was working with Tubby. He really did check Jump... and... shit I forget the other. Can check tonight again and actually notate it in my spreadsheet. But I don't have access to the thread in the day. He did not get the actual read because he was killed.

That said, the plan was to see who would say what until the action timing was picked up on.

You can vote me, but you'll be killing a strong role and doing the wolf job for them.
 

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
4,482
I really am who I say I am. I was working with Tubby. He really did check Jump... and... shit I forget the other. Can check tonight again and actually notate it in my spreadsheet. But I don't have access to the thread in the day. He did not get the actual read because he was killed.
So, the other big piece of information, which is who the other potential killer could be, you two just decided to leave out?

Uh huh.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
So, the other big piece of information, which is who the other potential killer could be, you two just decided to leave out?

Uh huh.
Tubby, like me, was sus of Jump from yesterday. He didn't get to check it. What other info would ANYONE have? Vash was the warden and didn't have info. Other than that I'm talking with Tubby, who I planned with, TD and Christina. There wasn't a whole lot to do other than make a play to find info.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
I guess it's possible for both Tubby and Jumpy forget to target two people in the same game.
No, he targeted two people.

I just cannot remember the other name. And I no longer have access to the thread (it's day phase). But Tubby did NOT forget to check two people. He was just dead.
 

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
4,482
Tubby, like me, was sus of Jump from yesterday. He didn't get to check it. What other info would ANYONE have? Vash was the warden and didn't have info. Other than that I'm talking with Tubby, who I planned with, TD and Christina. There wasn't a whole lot to do other than make a play to find info.
That's true. Ballsy play, but why invent information and present it also in a way that is objectively wrong as well?

I just cannot remember the other name. And I no longer have access to the thread (it's day phase). But Tubby did NOT forget to check two people. He was just dead.
If you did get info from him, that other person could also be a killer. Convenient to leave that person out and single out Jumpy without letting us all discuss it. That's the whole point of SS. Two suspects. One or two killers when they are red.


If we were to trust you to be a conjurer/medium/ritualist, why come up with that play? We were already considering Jumpy. If your info was true, then yes it would be more damning against him. But then we also have the other person who could also be the actual killer or a second one. That's very important information as well that we might not ever get to know if you die. Even if we don't lynch you, you're now a target for the wolves and dick.

I just don't buy it. This is Local prime numbers again. Half-assed information and blackmailing.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
That's true. Ballsy play, but why invent information and present it also in a way that is objectively wrong as well?
It wasn't really "invented." I simply forget the other name. Had I remembered, I would have said "one of them" killed. I was sus of Jump, so was Tubby, so I just mentioned him so I could gauge reactions. And I got the ones I needed for myself.

If you did get info from him, that other person could also be a killer. Convenient to leave that person out and single out Jumpy without letting us all discuss it. That's the whole point of SS. Two suspects. One or two killers when they are red.
It's not convenient. If I had to GUESS on memory, I think he said the other he checked was Local. The whole thing is irrelevant. He didn't get real info. So the other name is not relevant either.

Even if we don't lynch you, you're now a target for the wolves and dick.
Why I told Benzine I didn't want to out another strong role. But I'm not surviving the night without protection anyway I don't think. I'd like to clear another townie during this day phase preferably, and then I don't care if I die.

But either way, do with this info as you please. Just trying to find baddies.
 

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
4,482
It wasn't really "invented." I simply forget the other name. Had I remembered, I would have said "one of them" killed. I was sus of Jump, so was Tubby, so I just mentioned him so I could gauge reactions. And I got the ones I needed for myself.
But you didn't. You didn't lead with "I forgot who the other one was, but one of them was Jumpy" or anything similar. You could've also chosen to keep your role hidden longer and just go along with just your feels for Jumpy as we were already starting to vote for him.

It's not convenient. If I had to GUESS on memory, I think he said the other he checked was Local. The whole thing is irrelevant. He didn't get real info. So the other name is not relevant either.
If this is true, then Jumpy might not even be a wolf or the dick. Local was wolf. So you're still going after Jumpy by saying you had evidence on him beyond just feels. Though now you're saying it was just your and Tubby's feels.


In the end, you blew your trust in the way you presented everything. At best, if you are actually getting early-access to Christina's cookies, then we can consider revisiting Jumpy tomorrow.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
In the end, you blew your trust in the way you presented everything. At best, if you are actually getting early-access to Christina's cookies, then we can consider revisiting Jumpy tomorrow.
Do whatever you want. Honestly. You're gonna feel pretty stupid if you lynch me, but it is what it is.
 
Messages
5,489
Thanks @Jon. Remind me, have you stated specifically which role you are, or just one of the dead talking ones? Don't feel pressured to say it at this point if you haven't already. I'm sure we'd have seen something more if it was anything but ritualist - but ritualist also still can help if they are killed. Just something for me to weigh up when I have to make a decision on what hurts the least to lose.

For the scoreboard, there's GwJ in as a seer's apprentice, going into spirit seer from Tubby's death, who looked at one person, but didn't realise he could look at many. Totally fine in my mind. And he is suspected for this by some, and this plus slightly more for a reaction to Jon's ploy by Jon.

Jon has claimed he's made a ploy after commenting that someone gave him info in deadland and that info is GwJ is bad. Reads in order than Jon could've been caught out, but really this tracks totally fine to me too, Jon is in the midst of trying new things, and Tubby is an awful human who'd have told him to lie in the dead thread.

@shortkut what role are you? The Bully's shenanigans sounds like you to me.

@Tommy Boy when you say no info today do you think there'll ever be info? Do you need help?
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
Thanks @Jon. Remind me, have you stated specifically which role you are, or just one of the dead talking ones? Don't feel pressured to say it at this point if you haven't already. I'm sure we'd have seen something more if it was anything but ritualist - but ritualist also still can help if they are killed. Just something for me to weigh up when I have to make a decision on what hurts the least to lose.
It doesn't matter anymore, really, but yes, Ritualist. Hence my saying I'd like to have a confirmed townie by end of phase.

If I were the bully, I would throw all my rocks day 1
As Benzine alluded to, you couldn't :p
 
Messages
5,489
It doesn't matter anymore, really, but yes, Ritualist. Hence my saying I'd like to have a confirmed townie by end of phase.


As Benzine alluded to, you couldn't :p
The only way to confirm a townie for sure is for something like a priest to kill. You are going to have to try your best and make a huge play. If you knew the roles earlier you'd have been able to make a better judgment imo. Try and res someone who can help the town as much as possible.

If you're good, of course.

I have no idea who to vote for. I want to hear @Tommy Boy
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,190
The only way to confirm a townie for sure is for something like a priest to kill. You are going to have to try your best and make a huge play. If you knew the roles earlier you'd have been able to make a better judgment imo. Try and res someone who can help the town as much as possible.
For now I have it on the person whom I put it on night 1. There has been no better target to this point, so it's staying there. Who that is I'm not going to say for now. It's just not me, obviously.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
13,527
For now I have it on the person whom I put it on night 1. There has been no better target to this point, so it's staying there. Who that is I'm not going to say for now. It's just not me, obviously.

Excited Season 3 GIF by The Simpsons
 
Back
Top Bottom