• Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Zell Wolf GWF Wolf - Zell's Version Night + Day 1

Fool's Requiem

Anyone want a popsicle?
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
10,916
and I very much hope you feel like the role you wish you had when you realize every word I've said HAS been truth, and that I am 100% the witch.
Then vote to lynch me. If you are truly townies, you'd lynch me instead of using up your one time usage abilities on me. I am 100% not the Fool.

I've already stated that I prefer you guys lynch me. It's the smart play. Giving up your kill abilities on a person you can easily lynch is silly.

Put your money where your mouth is and lynch me.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
Was going to edit then remembered to not do that.

The first statement is about if you're inexperienced and see players make a statement that dooms them, just to be clear (that's the damned if you do part). The second part is that being quiet will definitely draw suspicious suspicion if there's no reason for you to be quiet (like my bad timing that I called out during the sign up thread).
Yep I got you :)

That's my plan too. Funnily enough I'm more likely to be more active during the work week with downtime etc than during the weekend.

At the moment if I take everything on face value, Ants! Is almost certainly dead tonight and more likely than not a bad guy.

kut and Cole have either pulled off a very great ruse or are exactly what they say they are. I have no real reason not to believe them.

Ryan! has twice thrown suspicion on me when from what I have read (all 30 pages of joy) not one other player has mentioned my name which definitely makes me feel he is in league with Ants! as a wolf.

Holly inadvertently confirming both hers and Coles roles was the most important thing that happened yesterday (helped by Zell's note). If it hadn't have been for the note I could believe that three strong players from the wolf team (Cole, kut and Holly) got their story together and bamboozled us all. However, that isn't the case and as such leaves me with Ants! and Ryan! as leading wolf subjects.

As for their third and fourth I think we are looking at someone who hasn't posted or has remained quiet given their team has potentially already exposed 2 of their number
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
17,667
Then vote to lynch me. If you are truly townies, you'd lynch me instead of using up your one time usage abilities on me. I am 100% not the Fool.

I've already stated that I prefer you guys lynch me. It's the smart play. Giving up your kill abilities on a person you can easily lynch is silly.

Put your money where your mouth is and lynch me.
Why don’t you just ask the gunner to kill you instead?
 
@shortkut what's your level of certainty on Ants being a wolf
His reading only determined that I’m not on the same team as Coleman.

So if he and Coleman are both telling the truth about their roles, then I am either wolf, the fool, or the solo killer.

So it’s up to you to guess.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
17,667

Cole


Coleministrator
S-Mod
GW Elder
Messages
3,772
Then vote to lynch me. If you are truly townies, you'd lynch me instead of using up your one time usage abilities on me. I am 100% not the Fool.

I've already stated that I prefer you guys lynch me. It's the smart play. Giving up your kill abilities on a person you can easily lynch is silly.

Put your money where your mouth is and lynch me.
this post is... wow.

next level gameplay here. I don't know how anyone ever suspected you this game.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
Fuck it, this probably is a blunder but I think it potentially helps make things clearer with 13 hours left until the night phase starts.

If I die as a result of this and it turns out Cole, kut and Holly are in league as wolves, ggs.
If it works and I kill a wolf at least I got to use my power for good.

Priest uses their water on Fool's Requiem
 

Ryan!

Mew is a fkn cat
GW Elder
Messages
732
Yep I got you :)

That's my plan too. Funnily enough I'm more likely to be more active during the work week with downtime etc than during the weekend.

At the moment if I take everything on face value, Ants! Is almost certainly dead tonight and more likely than not a bad guy.

kut and Cole have either pulled off a very great ruse or are exactly what they say they are. I have no real reason not to believe them.

Ryan! has twice thrown suspicion on me when from what I have read (all 30 pages of joy) not one other player has mentioned my name which definitely makes me feel he is in league with Ants! as a wolf.

Holly inadvertently confirming both hers and Coles roles was the most important thing that happened yesterday (helped by Zell's note). If it hadn't have been for the note I could believe that three strong players from the wolf team (Cole, kut and Holly) got their story together and bamboozled us all. However, that isn't the case and as such leaves me with Ants! and Ryan! as leading wolf subjects.

As for their third and fourth I think we are looking at someone who hasn't posted or has remained quiet given their team has potentially already exposed 2 of their number
I only got suspicious of you for the occasional activity and keeping a mostly low profile. And it isn't really suspicion, more just something I found interesting. Now that Ants is for sure dead you're trying to pin suspicion on me when I'm just pointing out what you've done to highlight it. I didn't say you were a wolf. I didn't say I thought you were a wolf. I merely planted the seed for odd behavior that could be checked later.

And now you're immediately trying to get people to look at me as being Ants's partner. Congrats, I'm now fully suspicious of you.

Do anything interesting during the night?
 

Fool's Requiem

Anyone want a popsicle?
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
10,916
this post is... wow.

next level gameplay here. I don't know how anyone ever suspected you this game.
What do you expect me to do? I've told you my role. The only thing left is either for me to hope you're full of shit, or I play for the townies.

You are consistently and needlessly antagonistic.
 

Cole


Coleministrator
S-Mod
GW Elder
Messages
3,772
Fuck it, this probably is a blunder but I think it potentially helps make things clearer with 13 hours left until the night phase starts.

If I die as a result of this and it turns out Cole, kut and Holly are in league as wolves, ggs.
If it works and I kill a wolf at least I got to use my power for good.

Priest uses their water on Fool's Requiem
yeah you definitely should have waited for clarification, man.

we don't know that he is a wolf. he claims serial killer, and we know he's not on the side of the town. but your ability is specifically anti werewolf, and I don't know if thats gonna work out for you, or us.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
I only got suspicious of you for the occasional activity and keeping a mostly low profile. And it isn't really suspicion, more just something I found interesting. Now that Ants is for sure dead you're trying to pin suspicion on me when I'm just pointing out what you've done to highlight it. I didn't say you were a wolf. I didn't say I thought you were a wolf. I merely planted the seed for odd behavior that could be checked later.

And now you're immediately trying to get people to look at me as being Ants's partner. Congrats, I'm now fully suspicious of you.

Do anything interesting during the night?
No but I do do something interesting during the day, see above
 

Ryan!

Mew is a fkn cat
GW Elder
Messages
732
Fuck it, this probably is a blunder but I think it potentially helps make things clearer with 13 hours left until the night phase starts.

If I die as a result of this and it turns out Cole, kut and Holly are in league as wolves, ggs.
If it works and I kill a wolf at least I got to use my power for good.

Priest uses their water on Fool's Requiem
Oh. Well now I feel like a dick. Sorry, my dude.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
yeah you definitely should have waited for clarification, man.

we don't know that he is a wolf. he claims serial killer, and we know he's not on the side of the town. but your ability is specifically anti werewolf, and I don't know if thats gonna work out for you, or us.
Probably but I saw a way to at least cause a little bit of movement on this argument.
Was also concerned with being dead overnight or not ever having the information to make a guaranteed right choice.
 

Cole


Coleministrator
S-Mod
GW Elder
Messages
3,772
Probably but I saw a way to at least cause a little bit of movement on this argument.
Was also concerned with being dead overnight or not ever having the information to make a guaranteed right choice.
but we didn't need movement, man. and instead I think you just lost us a townie and a priest.

Fools claimed he is the serial killer.

ants is either fool or wolf.

this isn't a worthy gamble anymore than lynching him would be when we already had a sure fire plan to eliminate both problems and begin anew tomorrow.

this was WELL in control, irrespective of fools incoherent babbling about "helping the town"
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
but we didn't need movement, man. and instead I think you just lost us a townie and a priest.

Fools claimed he is the serial killer.

ants is either fool or wolf.

this isn't a worthy gamble anymore than lynching him would be when we already had a sure fire plan to eliminate both problems and begin anew tomorrow.

this was WELL in control, irrespective of fools incoherent babbling about "helping the town"
It probably feels a lot more in control for you given you're a far superior player to me.

As I saw it this ship felt a bit rudderless and drifting off course, we seemed lost in the weeds and I wanted to bring some movement back to the right course.

I could potentially be 100% wrong and if I am I live and learn for next game I play. I'm rusty as hell.
 

Cole


Coleministrator
S-Mod
GW Elder
Messages
3,772
Looking back at the wording of the priest role, Tubby will only confirm for you that he’s not the fool if he is indeed wolf. If he’s solo killer like he claims, or a townie role, then I guess he and Tubby live and we only learn that he isn’t wolf.
no, he dies if fools isn't a wolf.
It probably feels a lot more in control for you given you're a far superior player to me.

As I saw it this ship felt a bit rudderless and drifting off course, we seemed lost in the weeds and I wanted to bring some movement back to the right course.

I could potentially be 100% wrong and if I am I live and learn for next game I play. I'm rusty as hell.
yes but you didn't just take a healthy risk. you've basically killed yourself. and since we don't even know if we have ANY wolves tagged yet, were down a man already, for free. it hurts the town.
Disagree. We had a firm plan in place and the ship was steady heading to landfall...
this.

tubby I respect you making your own choices and playing your way, but this was the wrong move, and it's gonna negatively affect the town's chances.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
no, he dies if fools isn't a wolf.

yes but you didn't just take a healthy risk. you've basically killed yourself. and since we don't even know if we have ANY wolves tagged yet, were down a man already, for free. it hurts the town.

this.

tubby I respect you making your own choices and playing your way, but this was the wrong move, and it's gonna negatively affect the town's chances.
I accept that and will learn from it
 

Cole


Coleministrator
S-Mod
GW Elder
Messages
3,772
Which with kuts overnight ability should get the town pretty close to an answer pretty soon
...we don't need kuts detective role for that man. we already know ants and fools are both bad guys. it doesn't *matter* what they are, all that matters is we didn't potentially lynch the fool, and didn't unnecessarily lose a townie.

kuts role did its job, it found ants.

ants found us fools.

we were done with this day, the rest was all gathering intel for tomorrow.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
yeah I'm not mad, inexperienced players happen, and there's a lot of content in this thread to sift through, remember, and follow.

it just kinda sucks thst it worked out this way. I feel like tubby felt pressured by "inactivity checks" and felt like he needed to make a move.

Wasn't so much the checks, those I was comfortable with as I knew I always had a way to prove who I was during a day phase if I did look like getting lynched.

I genuinely felt that we were a long way of course, it's probably inexperience but all the arguing back and forth about what Fool did or didn't want to do just felt like we were moving nowhere.

Admittedly I probably jumped at shadows and ruined things for everyone
 
Back
Top Bottom