VTS Mafia Mafia Legacy Year 2 (Night 3/Day 3)

[Local Hero]

With Jon's post, I'm thinking

Tubby mad bomber

Alu
Fool
Shortkut
Smacktard
Zell

Are Mafia suspects.

 

[Smacktard]

With Jon's post, I'm thinking

Tubby mad bomber

Alu
Fool
Shortkut
Smacktard
Zell

Are Mafia suspects.

You're not endearing yourself to the jury right now

 

[Local Hero]

lol

I'm just throwing in every one who's role I don't know. Sorry love

 

[Jon]

To be fair my personal assumption as of this time is shortkut MIGHT be the bomber

 

[Jon]

lol

I'm just throwing in every one who's role I don't know. Sorry love

So you are indicating you know my role

Please pray tell

 

[Fool's Requiem]

So you are indicating you know my role

Please pray tell

You are...

[Rolls dice]

THE WITCH!

Wait...

 

[A Punched Face]

I've done nothing to indicate what my role is yet, so it's fine to show up on lists of "don't know"

I'm on board to vote for Tubby for tomorrow. Busy day today though. Will be back to examine more later.

 

[A Punched Face]

Also RNG giving me jury twice in a row here. Looks like I'm forever gonna be on trial duty.

 

[Local Hero]

So you are indicating you know my role

Please pray tell

Oh yeah, you're right.

Jon is Mafia

 

[Jon]

Oh yeah, you're right.

Jon is Mafia

Wait you are kidding right

Oh and one more thing I have observed

The only role I can see Tommy being based on what is out there is Gypsy

All the roles that reveal clues he did not or does not meet the criteria

 

[Local Hero]

Wait you are kidding right

Yes

 

[shortkut]

This strikes me as odd behavior

Reserving the right to change later I am going to submit my arrest request for shortkut

How is that odd? Local essentially said he was a seer and Zell was guilty. Why do we accept that as gospel in wolf but are skeptical during mafia?

 

[shortkut]

With Jon's post, I'm thinking

Tubby mad bomber

Alu
Fool
Shortkut
Smacktard
Zell

Are Mafia suspects.

Would my tell be marvel snap? I think I posted more about that than anything day 1

 

[Jon]

How is that odd? Local essentially said he was a seer and Zell was guilty. Why do we accept that as gospel in wolf but are skeptical during mafia?

First I have not played wolf YET

Second it just strikes me as odd that you would be so eager to convict Zell

This tells me you are not mafia because you should know the other mafia peeps and you would not vote so quickly against your own

And you know very well how this game is played so if you were a citizen you would know that putting Zell on the stand now is not beneficial when citizens have lost as many as we have

Even if he is a mafia the goal right now has to be rooting out the bomber

Convicting and killing another mafia member now gets the bomber one step closer to winning

So in my eyes unless you are the bomber rooting out another mafia member right now on trial is not beneficial to us as a whole and I would rather KNOW and IDENTIFY other roles to get the bomber

In other words only the bomber benefits from immediately putting Zell on trial

Hence my current vote to arrest you but I am fine being wrong

 

[Local Hero]

How is that odd? Local essentially said he was a seer and Zell was guilty. Why do we accept that as gospel in wolf but are skeptical during mafia?

 

[Tubby23]

And just like Gerald, you're trolling?

 

[Tommy Boy]

I'm not 100% if it's multiple posts (1 animal per post x2 = two animals) or two animals in one post.

I think as long as two animals are mentioned.

The tell includes the name of the mafioso, so once Tommy gets here, he'll confirm the name, which was Jimmy Zoos.

I could not possibly know this without being the snitch and getting a genuine clue.

I can confirm. I called Zell "Jimmy" yesterday when he refuted the animal claims.

 

[Tommy Boy]

Mafia Legacy Year Two (Night 2/Day 2)

All these kangaroo badges Totally glad I didn't get one *ahem*

gwforums.com

 

[Local Hero]

I can confirm. I called Zell "Jimmy" yesterday when he refuted the animal claims.

Do you have any reason to question/dispute fool's claim of peeping Tom?

 

[Tommy Boy]

Do you have any reason to question/dispute fool's claim of peeping Tom?

I'm still not sold on it, I think the food tells were pretty obvious both days. At the same time, I think your alcohol tells were pretty obvious both days, also. Very easy to claim snitch after being arrested. It doesn't make sense for you to throw Zell under the bus yet, but at the same time, there's no other way you could have known the name Jimmy Zoos without getting a clue from Vash or knowing him yourself.

I gotta think about this.

 

[Local Hero]

I'm still not sold on it, I think the food tells were pretty obvious both days. At the same time, I think your alcohol tells were pretty obvious both days, also. Very easy to claim snitch after being arrested. It doesn't make sense for you to throw Zell under the bus yet, but at the same time, there's no other way you could have known the name Jimmy Zoos without getting a clue from Vash or knowing him yourself.

I gotta think about this.

My only other defense is not using any (blank) tells.

If Zell and I were mafia, I'd be selling him out to save myself and then killing myself by not meeting tell requirements.

 

[Jon]

But maybe redacting your tell is a tell

 

[Tommy Boy]

My only other defense is not using any (blank) tells.

If Zell and I were mafia, I'd be selling him out to save myself and then killing myself by not meeting tell requirements.

Tell me then, truthfully, what the point of mentioning alcohol in your posts multiple times was. If you were conned you would have said that by now, so I won't believe that. I can't think of any other reason why you would so blatantly talk about alcohol and FR would so blatantly talk about food.

 

[Local Hero]

Tell me then, truthfully, what the point of mentioning alcohol in your posts multiple times was. If you were conned you would have said that by now, so I won't believe that. I can't think of any other reason why you would so blatantly talk about alcohol and FR would so blatantly talk about food.

I'm the snitch. I purposely used what I thought would be an obvious tell to get on trial. I will now make zero references to [blank] from here on out.

As I said, I posted obvious tells to expedite my arrest (but no so desperate that Mafia killed me before I could communicate the clue).

Day one would have been best but day two was still good. Unfortunately it was the same clue as yours

 

[canadaguy]

So we all agree though finding the bomber has to be priority 1?

 

[Zell 17]

If I was too obvious, then I ran risk of being killed at night. Not getting the opportunity to share my clue

You’d have been jailed and unkillable

 

[Local Hero]

You’d have been jailed and unkillable

 

[Zell 17]

How is that odd? Local essentially said he was a seer and Zell was guilty. Why do we accept that as gospel in wolf but are skeptical during mafia?

Local doesn’t have any info different from Tommy. He’s fingering me because he thinks I’m the only person that’s said an animal.

I think he can’t read good

 

[Local Hero]

Local doesn’t have any info different from Tommy. He’s fingering me because he thinks I’m the only person that’s said an animal.

I think he can’t read good

 

[Local Hero]

Local doesn’t have any info different from Tommy. He’s fingering me because he thinks I’m the only person that’s said an animal.

I think he can’t read good

I do have different info than Tommy. I provided the full name (Jimmy Zoo), which Tommy confirmed.

Do you have a different person who has posted two animals names the first two days?

 

[Local Hero]

Mafia Legacy Year Two (Night 2/Day 2)

All these kangaroo badges Totally glad I didn't get one *ahem*

gwforums.com

As Tommy compiled (thanks ), you were the only person to post two animal names on both days.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

So we all agree though finding the bomber has to be priority 1?

yarp

 

[Fool's Requiem]

btw, I'm not going to be super active today. Need to make my home presentable to company coming tomorrow, and my lazy butt has a lot of work to do. I'll check in here and there.

 

[Smacktard]

My only other defense is not using any (blank) tells.

If Zell and I were mafia, I'd be selling him out to save myself and then killing myself by not meeting tell requirements.

Wh... isn't that what you're doing right now?

 

[Local Hero]

Wh... isn't that what you're doing right now?

What? No? I'm not Mafia. So I'm not seeing him out. I'm revealing who he (likely) is.

Further, since I'm not Mafia, I'm not killing myself for not using my (fake) tells

 

[Local Hero]

I know I'm a dunce, but this is too far. Smacktard and Zell are top Mafia suspects.

 

[Smacktard]

What? No? I'm not Mafia. So I'm not seeing him out. I'm revealing who he (likely) is.

Further, since I'm not Mafia, I'm not killing myself for not using my (fake) tells

So let's recap:
1. You know the tell's name, which indicates you are either mafia or the snitch, as you claim
2. You posted about alcohol first thread and second thread, but not this thread (so far)
3. You say that, if you were mafia, you would sell Zell out, who you also claim is mafia, and not complete your tell for today, which is exactly what has been happening so far

At this point it really seems like either you or Zell or both are mafia. I think if we take out a mafioso today and the bomber tomorrow, we're in good shape. But I don't know that we have any leads on the bomber, and I'm not going to commit to voting you just yet, as f***y as you sound. I hope everyone else is watching Zell's posts as closely as I am

 

[Local Hero]

3. You say that, if you were mafia, you would sell Zell out, who you also claim is mafia, and not complete your tell for today, which is exactly what has been happening so far

I might not have been clear. What I mean is, if this was what I was doing (as you describe in the attached quote) it would be stupid

 

[shortkut]

I know I'm a dunce, but this is too far. Smacktard and Zell are top Mafia suspects.

I was wondering what Kelly’s tell could be to make you suspicious, so I went back and looked at his posts (thankfully less than 10 each day). He has had at least 2 posts each day, including today, where he asks a question. Just worth keeping note of

 

[Local Hero]

I was wondering what Kelly’s tell could be to make you suspicious, so I went back and looked at his posts (thankfully less than 10 each day). He has had at least 2 posts each day, including today, where he asks a question. Just worth keeping note of

Good observation

 

[Smacktard]

I might not have been clear. What I mean is, if this was what I was doing (as you describe in the attached quote) it would be stupid

Is it? If you get spared tonight, mafia gets another kill and wastes one more day of our time, which is in short supply at this point.

I was wondering what Kelly’s tell could be to make you suspicious, so I went back and looked at his posts (thankfully less than 10 each day). He has had at least 2 posts each day, including today, where he asks a question. Just worth keeping note of

I can avoid asking any more questions, no problem. I'll just use imperatives from now on.

 

[Local Hero]

Is it? If you get spared tonight, mafia gets another kill and wastes one more day of our time, which is in short supply at this point.

Yes, it would be stupid. Because I would die tonight if I don't perform a tell. (Or I do it very last second), but either way, that would be two confirmed Mafia members revealed. Super risky when I could just not do that.

 

[shortkut]

Is it? If you get spared tonight, mafia gets another kill and wastes one more day of our time, which is in short supply at this point.

I can avoid asking any more questions, no problem. I'll just use imperatives from now on.

You’ve made more than two posts with questions already this day, so we would need to see how you post tomorrow. Right now you are less suspicious than Zell or tubby so you have time to dispel our suspicions

 

[Jon]

I still think we are being led in a direction away from the bomber and that would be a detriment to mafia and citizen alike

I agree with the phrase either local or zell or both are mafia

I think it is just Zell but great let us move on and identify the bomber and keep who the mafia are in our pocket elsewise

Stop worrying about putting another mafia on trial tomorrow and let us find the bomber

 

[A Punched Face]

With Jon's post, I'm thinking

Tubby mad bomber

Alu
Fool
Shortkut
Smacktard
Zell

Are Mafia suspects.

Okay, jumping back to this now that I'm done running errands and haven't yet started the days unpacking. Do you have any thoughts on tells for the people on this list?

Fool = food?
Zell = animals?
Kelly = ...questions?

Not sure what you'd be thinking for myself or kut, would like to hear it though.

The Kelly one is...interesting...in a game where we're trying to find out information.

 

[Local Hero]

I think tubby is bomber

 

[Local Hero]

Not sure what you'd be thinking for myself or kut, would like to hear it though.

I clarified after the post you quoted, is more so I don't know your roles, and are therefore suspects

 

[A Punched Face]

I think tubby is bomber

Yes, I'm asking about myself and kut. I can see why tubby being bomber is a good suspicion at this point.

Also, as to @Jon - he's claiming to know there's a conman in the game, but no one else is claiming that. Jon's tell is almost certainly seems to be that every new sentence needs to be a new paragraph, or something about not being allowed to use punctuation to separate sentences. I haven't seen any posts where he has actual punctuation.

 

[A Punched Face]

I clarified after the post you quoted, is more so I don't know your roles, and are therefore suspects

Right, yes, but all mafia members should have tells. If you suspect someone, you should take a look to see what you can find to try and back it up.

 

[Local Hero]

Right, yes, but all mafia members should have tells. If you suspect someone, you should take a look to see what you can find to try and back it up.

It takes a village