• Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Zell Wolf GWF Zell Wolf Version XI Day 3

Who should the villagers lynch? (5 votes required)

  • Ben

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dean

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kat

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Raine

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • TD

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Tommy Boy

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Tubby23

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
I think if we were to follow this idea at all, I should convict Dean as I suspect he's a big fibber about the seer role. If I'm wrong and he's telling the truth, I get a new necktie but it'll prove Dean to be legit and he'll stay alive. We're still potentially going to lose a villager, but it seems a safer way to confirm it.

That then leaves you, claiming the Loudmouth, to pick someone else to rat out if you're killed by the wolves. Anyone with a seer role could check you tonight, and there's a chance the wolves won't want to pick you as a kill since you'd possibly give them away, somewhat providing protection.
But if you successfully kill a wolf tomorrow with your ability (which is more likely with the additional info), that makes you a confirmed townie who is still alive. If you die confirming him, then the town still won't be sure about me or Raine.

Your plan is better if you're right about Dean, though. I'm not convinced he's a wolf, but if most people think he is, then we can have you do your thing instead. I should pick a new target in that case, though.
 

Benzine

Senior Member
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
7,157
Wait What Wtf GIF by TLC Europe
what's the problem?

i'm actually gonna start getting ruder, i say things and get reactions like this. vash being hella dumb last few pages afai am concerned.
 

TD

ES COO Shitposting Dept. of GWF
10K Post Club
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
16,940
I'd argue that TDs original plan of killing FR is a better play.

He has already claimed to be relatively worthless, role-wise. Good chance of outing the Lovers situation. And a chance to keep a seer if Dean is legit and uncoupled.
Wait.

Are you thinking what we thought Dean was a couple games ago?
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
I'm down for whatever, as long as it doesn't involve killing Fool's Requiem or me, obviously. If you guys have a way to sniff it out, just let me know. I'm wrapping gifts and working on a video but checking regularly for now.
So you are coupled or a wolf.

If you were truly just a Seer and have FR saying his role is useless townie than a lynch of him shouldn't worry you
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
I'm a seer and Fool's is the only verified good townie (besides me and the dead ones).

If you guys are 100% set on killing FR, I've already explained why that is stupid.
I get you say that, but we have only your word to go on. No other hard evidence.

Your seer checks could all be seen as convenient. FR to protect a wolf or your couple, Jon to throw suspicion on a player who has been relatively uninvolved and then shortkut when he's already dead and role proven.
 

VashTheStampede

Dumdum McGee
Mr. Queen of the Dead
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
15,941
@VashTheStampede
You spent time with FR in jail. I know at the time you didn't want to swing. Have any of these thoughts changed?
I feel LESS sure about not swinging but I probably still wouldn't swing.

Note that if I was wrong, I would have died
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
What were the possible reasons Tommy gave for choosing his couple? Can one apply to FR and Dean?
  • One is a new player and one is experienced - not applicable
  • It's strategic, they're likely to win - ehh sorry guys, going to say no to this one
  • It'd be funny - IMO not applicable, I can think of much funnier pairings
He gave a fourth possibility but I don't remember it. Does anyone else?
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
@Zell 17 can you confirm if a Cupid is in the game, the couple's win condition is to be the last two alive or do they win as part of the town? Or does their win condition override the towns and if there are no baddies left the couple wins?
He already said if the town meets their win condition, the town wins, even if the couple is both still alive.
 

Ben

(ง •̀_•́)ง
Administrator
Dadministrator
Moderator
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
10,247
I'm a seer and Fool's is the only verified good townie (besides me and the dead ones).

If you guys are 100% set on killing FR, I've already explained why that is stupid.
Read; "a seer". I feel if I had the Aura Seer role or something else specific, I'd be inclined to state that and not just "a seer".
 

Ben

(ง •̀_•́)ง
Administrator
Dadministrator
Moderator
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
10,247
He has been specific. He's given aura readings over and over. There's no ambiguity. It's weird to suggest there is.
Wolf Seer would be just as capable of checking someone's role directly, then only providing their alignment out of the dictionary. Just because he stated people are "unknown" or "good", doesn't necessarily prove it.

I do get the maybe just getting tired of stating it fully every time, but I still feel suspicious. 🤷🏻‍♂️
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
I still think Dean is legit. He's understandably frustrated that he has what should be a useful role and he's struggling to get anybody to believe him. The one useful read he has is being used as a justification to kill a townie. I'd be annoyed too!

And realistically, even if we do kill FR and he is good, it doesn't clear Dean. Dean could be a wolf seer, picked an actually good person for the first read as cover, picked the alpha wolf for his second read since it'd check out but not give anything away, then picked a dead guy for his third. So if we kill FR and he's a townie, what do we really get out of it? Nothing imo.

Shortkut was a reasonable choice. The warden found him suspicious enough to give a wolf a weapon to kill him with. I had him as my target until he was killed.

The only dangerous situation is if they're coupled and FR is a wolf. If they're both townies and coupled, that's even less reason to kill either of them.
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
Wolf Seer would be just as capable of checking someone's role directly, then only providing their alignment out of the dictionary. Just because he stated people are "unknown" or "good", doesn't necessarily prove it.

I do get the maybe just getting tired of stating it fully every time, but I still feel suspicious. 🤷🏻‍♂️
I'm not saying he's definitely what he's claiming. I'm saying his claim is specifically aura seer and there's no room to say he's been ambiguous in his claim.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
I still think Dean is legit. He's understandably frustrated that he has what should be a useful role and he's struggling to get anybody to believe him. The one useful read he has is being used as a justification to kill a townie. I'd be annoyed too!

And realistically, even if we do kill FR and he is good, it doesn't clear Dean. Dean could be a wolf seer, picked an actually good person for the first read as cover, picked the alpha wolf for his second read since it'd check out but not give anything away, then picked a dead guy for his third. So if we kill FR and he's a townie, what do we really get out of it? Nothing imo.

Shortkut was a reasonable choice. The warden found him suspicious enough to give a wolf a weapon to kill him with. I had him as my target until he was killed.

The only dangerous situation is if they're coupled and FR is a wolf. If they're both townies and coupled, that's even less reason to kill either of them.
Yes but if they are coupled and Dean is the Wolf Seer (ETA: or any other wolf) tean Fool's "useless role" is worth the sacrifice
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
Yes but if they are coupled and Dean is the Wolf Seer (ETA: or any other wolf) tean Fool's "useless role" is worth the sacrifice
It's a big if. If he's not then it's a completely wasted lynch and we're down a townie for no reason.

We also have Raine who can check if someone is evil without killing them. Although we should be careful with that because the wolves can go for the two for one.

@Fool's Requiem, you said your role is mostly useless. Is there any way we can arrange a situation where your role is helpful?
 

Ben

(ง •̀_•́)ง
Administrator
Dadministrator
Moderator
Executive
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
10,247
We also have Raine who can check if someone is evil without killing them. Although we should be careful with that because the wolves can go for the two for one.
If Raine actually is the Red Lady, if they check someone evil then they themselves die. That's not a foolproof way to validate someone.

Raine is certainly welcome to visit ME tonight as the only thing I have to hide is my delicious fudge.

Judge Fudge.

judge-fudge-drawn-together.gif

EDIT: Although unnecessary if I get to use my loud hammer on some wolfman nards.
 
Last edited:

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
If Raine actually is the Red Lady, if they check someone evil then they themselves die. That's not a foolproof way to validate someone.
Yeah I know, but that way if we lose a townie, we also find a wolf. It's better than killing a townie to confirm they're a townie.

With all that said...

The town has lynched evil people I wasn't strongly suspicious of two days in a row. If you all really feel that strongly about FR, I'll go along with it, despite my reservations.
 

Tubby23

CFO of Shitposting, Head of Data & Insights
Executive
GW Elder
Messages
5,584
Yeah I know, but that way if we lose a townie, we also find a wolf. It's better than killing a townie to confirm they're a townie.

With all that said...

The town has lynched evil people I wasn't strongly suspicious of two days in a row. If you all really feel that strongly about FR, I'll go along with it, despite my reservations.
I don't feel strongly that Fool is a wolf, to be clear I feel strongly that he is coupled with Dean who is the wolf
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom