- Messages
- 3,898
Like the others have said, the little things.
Something they didn't mention was the timing. Benzine had 36~48 hours, ostensibly, to get to around 3/4 of the way down Page 2 of Day 1 and see Raposa's role claim. Radio silence. I'm actually going to go over and browse whatever Benzine did post in a moment, should've done that already, but dinner and I write too goddamn much and I'm always fucking behind.
Radio silence is fine on its own, maybe. But I was thinking Benzine was a wolf when he came flying in with a second bodyguard claim after the wolves ostensibly made no kill on a Confusion Wolf night. And, y'know, he still might be. We'll know for sure tomorrow if enough of us are still alive pending this lynch and whatever happens overnight.
I can't overlook this repeated use of Arsonist, though. It doesn't necessarily make him the Random Killer, not quite to the extent that I think Ryan was the Random-Nightmare Wolf at least, but it sure as fuck triggers my pedantic ass and he must die all the same!
If you put two wolves into the Warden's protection, they (can) kill her. If you definitively know that there are only 2 wolves, and you know who those wolves are, and you put them in there, presumably you can stop their nightly kill. We don't know if there are 2 wolves, there could be anywhere from 1 to 4 right now. Simply not knowing who she's imprisoning has a higher likelihood of stopping their nightly kill.
Your counter to this is just having her broadcast who she puts in, so if the wolves kill her we know... and in which case, if my theory is correct, they Nightmare her - or they know they don't need to, and can do it to you, to Kat, to whomever, and score a more guaranteed kill. And, again, nothing productive is being done. Plus they can still not kill her and then, presumably, they have an alibi for half of the known alleged Seer players.
The Warden is also a Protector. If we're using it on suspected wolves, we're not using it on pro-town players (preferably those without night actions, as noted by yourself and others previously), and that's also bad if we kill Raposa and he's not the Random Killer. I mean, absolutely nothing stops the Arsonist's ignition it seems, but if it's the Serial Killer then Holly/Warden can help minimize damage.
In all scenarios she has to send her PM to Zell before today's lynch results are known. It's risky when it doesn't need to be. It's reminiscent of something Ryan suggested on Day 1, and at least some of us are still certain he was, at best, not a Good Guy™.
I mean aside from Ms. Writesnovels here, I think the other 3 are pretty chatty? I'm not sure what you're wanting, exactly.
All of my guesses are not super favorable...
This doesn't jive with what happened last game. You have complete vindication from Zell, you're legit, I'm not questioning it. And yet... this is not what happened last game.
@aura seer died Night 0, but was resurrected Night 1 and had knowledge of his attempt. It was used as part of a complete annihilation of the wolves. What gives?
@Zell 17 can chime in if he hasn't already.
