• Celebrating One Year of Revival!

    Come and join us in celebrating one year of GW's revival as GWF, share in some statistics and help us push towards the next twenty years! CLICK HERE

    We're also looking for suggestions for another community event we can put together that we can all enjoy! Come and give us some suggestions HERE
  • Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Zell Wolf Zell Wolf Version 18 Day 2

Who should the villagers lynch? (5 votes required)

  • dimmerwit

    Votes: 1 7.1%

  • Fool’s Requiem

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Jon

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Kat

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Local Hero

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Quagmire

    Votes: 7 50.0%

  • rktaker

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • shortkut

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Smacktard

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Tommy Boy

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • VashTheStampede

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • No Vote

    Votes: 6 42.9%
  • Total voters
    14
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Reply to thread
Jon

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GW Elder
Killed Zell Nintendo 64 Diplomatic Immunity Niiiiiice Dice Baymax Emotional Damage
Messages
10,190
Mark said:
That would imply I’ve done something productive around here beyond creating a sub-forum.
Click to expand...
Think Tim Robinson GIF by NETFLIX
 
Jawneh

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Nice Dice Hmm
Messages
4,487
Fool's Requiem said:
A for vote Jawneh is a vote for the Voodoo Wolf.
Click to expand...
I would argue that, unless I'm running a bit where I'm a wolf or a serial arsonist, I wouldn't be actively putting so much heat on me day one, especially with both librarian and voodoo having the same power.

If you just want to kill the dude that can thread ban anyone for a day because that guy is an asshole, I'll whole heartedly agree. Especially since I'm 100% muting someone every chance I get.
 
R

rktaker

Senior Member
Messages
529
btw now that Kelly could talk again he didn't claim to be a bully so we still don't know who, if anyone threw a rock at Jawneh. unless he was messing around. which would seem like a weird thing to joke about
 
Kat

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Priest One Thousand Posts! Witch First Blood
Messages
4,445
Jawneh said:
I for one don't believe Tommy. And Kat being defensive about him is giving me very weird vibes. And I'm definitely not saying Kelly is necessarily off the hook.

Good time to switch Alu with Kat on my list though.
Click to expand...
I don't believe Tommy either, but Kelly isn't exactly being very convincing. Why only one post for the day? Why say Tommy is definitely a wolf without further details? Almost all info roles can be tricked, so even if he's being honest, more information would be good. IMO it's a coin flip whether his info will check out or not. So we can guess which is evil and possibly take out a townie today if we guess wrong, or we can let Tommy prove himself one way or another tonight and definitely get it right tomorrow (or use the lynch on somebody else if Tommy is legit).

I'm open to lynching if somebody else has more info on either of them though.

Anybody else find it pretty interesting that the person who was muted last night only wants to post once today?
 
Tommy Boy

Tommy Boy

noob cannon
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
1 Year Old Poster Minecraft Pro Trader Tubby-Boy Memorial Tommy!
Messages
2,522
Jawneh said:
I would argue that, unless I'm running a bit where I'm a wolf or a serial arsonist, I wouldn't be actively putting so much heat on me day one, especially with both librarian and voodoo having the same power.
Click to expand...
I totally agree with this, which is why I suggested killing you as the honorary "fuck muting roles", but now that we're in day 2 we can't really fuck around and kill townies. My focus is on Kelly and the random, weak claim that isn't backed up.
Jawneh said:
If you just want to kill the dude that can thread ban anyone for a day because that guy is an asshole, I'll whole heartedly agree. Especially since I'm 100% muting someone every chance I get.
Click to expand...
Normally I'd say fuck yeah, but I actually want the town to win and I actually want to get my potions off before dying. So you can keep coming at me for revenge, but if you're a townie and I'm a townie, it's best to call it a truce and focus elsewhere.
 
Tommy Boy

Tommy Boy

noob cannon
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
1 Year Old Poster Minecraft Pro Trader Tubby-Boy Memorial Tommy!
Messages
2,522
Kat said:
So we can guess which is evil and possibly take out a townie today if we guess wrong, or we can let Tommy prove himself one way or another tonight and definitely get it right tomorrow (or use the lynch on somebody else if Tommy is legit).
Click to expand...
I am totally down to use my kill potion on Kelly tonight to prove myself, because if not wolf, some fuckery is going on. There are still the solo roles we can't forget about.
 
Jawneh

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Nice Dice Hmm
Messages
4,487
Kat said:
I don't believe Tommy either, but Kelly isn't exactly being very convincing. Why only one post for the day? Why say Tommy is definitely a wolf without further details? Almost all info roles can be tricked, so even if he's being honest, more information would be good. IMO it's a coin flip whether his info will check out or not. So we can guess which is evil and possibly take out a townie today if we guess wrong, or we can let Tommy prove himself one way or another tonight and definitely get it right tomorrow (or use the lynch on somebody else if Tommy is legit).

I'm open to lynching if somebody else has more info on either of them though.

Anybody else find it pretty interesting that the person who was muted last night only wants to post once today?
Click to expand...
He's not being convincing, which is also why he's still on my list. I threw him there since I muted him day 1 and today he didn't really give anything to convince me to take him off. If Tommy ends up being a wolf that hasn't used any or all abilities yet and isn't avenger, then maybe he has a leg to stand on.

But Tommy though. Day 1, he just did me dirty with the goof. I give that. Today he probably wouldn't have been there if it wasn't for the new story he's trying to spin. It came out way too forceful for my taste. Sounded too defensive for just "hi, I'm the local witch. who wants to sample my creations?"

Tommy Boy said:
I totally agree with this, which is why I suggested killing you as the honorary "fuck muting roles", but now that we're in day 2 we can't really fuck around and kill townies. My focus is on Kelly and the random, weak claim that isn't backed up.

Normally I'd say fuck yeah, but I actually want the town to win and I actually want to get my potions off before dying. So you can keep coming at me for revenge, but if you're a townie and I'm a townie, it's best to call it a truce and focus elsewhere.
Click to expand...
We're both technically in the same crossroads, with one major difference.

Neither of us can really prove who we are. I can say I mute someone and if they don't post, this is me, yes? But what if voodoo? Oh no. And in your case you can say you protect someone, but at least until you say who you're killing and we get a clarification from Zell that a witch killed a person, it's all just words as well.

The difference between us is that I was very forward already yesterday about who I was. Unless there's an aura seer, I can't prove I'm the librarian over voodoo. You on the other hand, came forward today fairly forcefully after a little heat yesterday.

Tommy Boy said:
@Jawneh who did you mute today? I don't remember if you said so already. Or did you get rocked?
Click to expand...
I got rocked. I may be dead at any point, though whether I'm voodoo or librarian, I'm currently disabled anyhow.
 
Local Hero

Local Hero

Senior Member
GW Elder
Pacifist! Zell Wolf Win Solo Killer Rat Electric Chair
Messages
4,775
Kat said:
I don't believe Tommy either, but Kelly isn't exactly being very convincing. Why only one post for the day? Why say Tommy is definitely a wolf without further details? Almost all info roles can be tricked, so even if he's being honest, more information would be good. IMO it's a coin flip whether his info will check out or not. So we can guess which is evil and possibly take out a townie today if we guess wrong, or we can let Tommy prove himself one way or another tonight and definitely get it right tomorrow (or use the lynch on somebody else if Tommy is legit).

I'm open to lynching if somebody else has more info on either of them though.

Anybody else find it pretty interesting that the person who was muted last night only wants to post once today?
Click to expand...
If Kelly and Tommy are both wolves, then waiting to lunch either one is risky.

We could accidentally lynch a townie, then Tommy doesn't potion Kelly, then is two more days to lynch suspected wolves.

I say we should lynch one of the two. Probably Kelly because I don't understand the no posts then one post thing.
 
Local Hero

Local Hero

Senior Member
GW Elder
Pacifist! Zell Wolf Win Solo Killer Rat Electric Chair
Messages
4,775
Jawneh said:
He's not being convincing, which is also why he's still on my list. I threw him there since I muted him day 1 and today he didn't really give anything to convince me to take him off. If Tommy ends up being a wolf that hasn't used any or all abilities yet and isn't avenger, then maybe he has a leg to stand on.

But Tommy though. Day 1, he just did me dirty with the goof. I give that. Today he probably wouldn't have been there if it wasn't for the new story he's trying to spin. It came out way too forceful for my taste. Sounded too defensive for just "hi, I'm the local witch. who wants to sample my creations?"


We're both technically in the same crossroads, with one major difference.

Neither of us can really prove who we are. I can say I mute someone and if they don't post, this is me, yes? But what if voodoo? Oh no. And in your case you can say you protect someone, but at least until you say who you're killing and we get a clarification from Zell that a witch killed a person, it's all just words as well.

The difference between us is that I was very forward already yesterday about who I was. Unless there's an aura seer, I can't prove I'm the librarian over voodoo. You on the other hand, came forward today fairly forcefully after a little heat yesterday.


I got rocked. I may be dead at any point, though whether I'm voodoo or librarian, I'm currently disabled anyhow.
Click to expand...
Or lynch Jawneh for abandoning his schtick.
 
Tommy Boy

Tommy Boy

noob cannon
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
1 Year Old Poster Minecraft Pro Trader Tubby-Boy Memorial Tommy!
Messages
2,522
Jawneh said:
But Tommy though. Day 1, he just did me dirty with the goof. I give that. Today he probably wouldn't have been there if it wasn't for the new story he's trying to spin. It came out way too forceful for my taste. Sounded too defensive for just "hi, I'm the local witch. who wants to sample my creations?"
Click to expand...
In all honesty, voting for the person who can mute is in the same ballpark as voting for benzine. It's definitely a goof and my bad for souring the soup, but it is what it is now. I would have given you the kill potion last night if I thought you were the Voodoo.
Jawneh said:
We're both technically in the same crossroads, with one major difference.

Neither of us can really prove who we are. I can say I mute someone and if they don't post, this is me, yes? But what if voodoo? Oh no. And in your case you can say you protect someone, but at least until you say who you're killing and we get a clarification from Zell that a witch killed a person, it's all just words as well.
Click to expand...
I mean, yes, this is true, but my role can kill once and yours can't. If Kelly doesn't die by the wolves, what are the odds it's anything other than my kill potion? I'm going to use it on him 100% tonight. If my potion doesn't work because someone else intervenes, then I get to keep the potion and try again. You just keep people quiet. I think I can prove myself faster with leaving me alive tonight to use the potion to kill Kelly. If I die from the wolves or any other means, you know I was right.
Jawneh said:
The difference between us is that I was very forward already yesterday about who I was. Unless there's an aura seer, I can't prove I'm the librarian over voodoo. You on the other hand, came forward today fairly forcefully after a little heat yesterday.
Click to expand...
I came forward today because of a direct accusation, and doing anything but directly addressing it right away is suspicious. I did not deflect at all, I was very up front with what I did and what I plan to do. I'm not going to let one post sway the entire town into making an irrational decision.
 
Jawneh

Jawneh

The Ritualist
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Nice Dice Hmm
Messages
4,487
Fool's Requiem said:
There is a SK role that does the silencing, but if you were that, Kelly would deaders.
Click to expand...
Ye. That I probably would try to pull off as the corrupter. Feign being librarian. But alas. He's alive after being silenced.

Local Hero said:
Or lynch Jawneh for abandoning his schtick.
Click to expand...
You're so right though... :sadpanda

Tommy Boy said:
In all honesty, voting for the person who can mute is in the same ballpark as voting for benzine. It's definitely a goof and my bad for souring the soup, but it is what it is now. I would have given you the kill potion last night if I thought you were the Voodoo.

I mean, yes, this is true, but my role can kill once and yours can't. If Kelly doesn't die by the wolves, what are the odds it's anything other than my kill potion? I'm going to use it on him 100% tonight. If my potion doesn't work because someone else intervenes, then I get to keep the potion and try again. You just keep people quiet. I think I can prove myself faster with leaving me alive tonight to use the potion to kill Kelly. If I die from the wolves or any other means, you know I was right.

I came forward today because of a direct accusation, and doing anything but directly addressing it right away is suspicious. I did not deflect at all, I was very up front with what I did and what I plan to do. I'm not going to let one post sway the entire town into making an irrational decision.
Click to expand...
What you did day 1 doesn't matter. What matters is today. And tonight. You've outed yourself as the witch, so if people don't want to lynch you, you have to use your potion tonight as you're a prime suspect for both the wolves and solo. You're a kill role and even after the kill there's one protection.

The bully is also out one kill by throwing a rock at me. They can only kill one person and disrupt another.
Lastly there's whoever is the jailer.

I'm starting to ramble and losing focus of my point lol.

I could be wrong about you for sure. Currently I just don't believe you thanks to the way you presented yourself.


I do have one question Tommy. Why are you so sure about cg being good? I could gleam a small role claim from his posts yesterday, but that would be on the bottom of people needing protection early on.
 
VashTheStampede

VashTheStampede

Sorry Jawneh
Mr. Queen of the Dead
10K Post Club
Executive
Moderator
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Traitor Win Killed Zell Priest Robin Hood Firestarter
Messages
13,418
Ben

Ben

Blind Guardian
Executive
Moderator
GWF Sponsor
Administrator
Badministrator
GW Elder
Dungeon Master PokeyMans Member 100
Messages
6,414
Fool's Requiem said:
blue one is the one we've been using
Click to expand...
Fool's Requiem said:
old man in me asks "why change it"
Click to expand...
Zell 17 said:
IF IT AINT BROKE
Click to expand...
I know the low-res blue one was what was already there, but it's so PIXELATED it hurts me. That's the main reason I suggested a change instead of just putting the old one back as it was.

But I could also use the old guy and just make that one higher resolution, too. :shrug

amongus_big.pngsub-buzz-2279-1603819400-38_png.png

VashTheStampede said:
I kinda like the idea of going with a new one and then when someone eventually gets rid of THAT one we switch to another dude again
Click to expand...
I'm down with having to rotate the dude as many times as you guys want to "OMG YOU KILLED KENNY" him.

If you could come up with a hat/costume trait that fit the game winner, they could always get themselves enshrined in the reaction until next game's won.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Kat
Kat

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Priest One Thousand Posts! Witch First Blood
Messages
4,445
Local Hero said:
Jawneh and Kelly are both on Tommy right now. I think they were trying to stay a band wagon on a strong role.

Voting Jawneh so Tommy can take out Kelly (or else)
Click to expand...
Idk, a witch is somewhat powerful, but even if that ploy worked, it'd out Kelly as a wolf. It's not worth losing a wolf to kill a witch.

Something more is going on, but it's hard to say what. There are a lot of possibilities.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom