Zell Wolf Zell Wolf 20 - Day 2

[Tommy Boy]

For example, if I rerolled my category rather than my role within my category, I would know of a confirmed role that should (potentially) exist on another team because the actual role is not re-rolled, only the team. That sounds like info that shouldn't exist, right?

 

[Kat]

For example, if I rerolled my category rather than my role within my category, I would know of a confirmed role that should (potentially) exist on another team because the actual role is not re-rolled, only the team. That sounds like info that shouldn't exist, right?

I assume if people switch categories that they both get new roles, but Zell would have to say for sure.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Well it totally ruins my immersion, as a former bodyguard who found the Lord

 

[VashTheStampede]

Also I figure if there was an issue, Zell would have said something Day 1 when we were discussing it

 

[Kat]

Updated:
Ben - violinist and says Vash matched dead body
Benzine - definitely good
dimmerwit - sheriff, hasn't been able to get any info
Jawneh - spirit seer, saw blue on Alu and Vash the first night. Alu was later proven town (RIP). Saw red on Local and dimmerwit the second night.
Kat - priest, will prove today
Local Hero - bodyguard
shortkut - witch, will prove tonight
Smacktard - marksman, will prove tonight if possible
Tommy Boy - definitely not a wolf (was watered), no claim
Vash - preacher

 

[VashTheStampede]

 

[Kat]

I honestly have no idea. Even the people saying they will prove tonight could be full of nonsense. If the wolves lynch the SK and get me to suicide, they win before the night even starts. If I were a wolf this game, I'd probably claim something like witch or marksman.

 

[VashTheStampede]

On the plus side, target rich environment

 

[Tommy Boy]

Also I figure if there was an issue, Zell would have said something Day 1 when we were discussing it

OK, just wanted to make sure it wasn't gunna muck anything up.

I rolled Alpha Wolf first, and opted to re-roll my category entirely. The wording was very specific how the category would be re-rolled, not the role (because it was dependent on someone else also opting to reroll cat), so I'm going to take this as an Alpha Wolf definitely exists, and I got whoever's role opted to do a cat re-roll.

 

[shortkut]

I honestly have no idea. Even the people saying they will prove tonight could be full of nonsense. If the wolves lynch the SK and get me to suicide, they win before the night even starts. If I were a wolf this game, I'd probably claim something like witch or marksman.

You keep implying and suggesting I’m not what I say I am. Either water me and realize your mistake or get someone else

 

[Local Hero]

@Ben @Local Hero @dimmerwit did you start with your current role or did you reroll? If you rerolled, what was your original role and are you happier with the new role? If you didn't, why not?

I was seer apprentice. Rerolled into bodyguard

 

[Kat]

Even Jawneh could easily be evil. Claim two townies are red and we're nearly guaranteed to help them win. If it doesn't check out, it'll be too late to do anything in retribution.

1. Ben
2. dimmerwit
3. Jawneh
4. Local Hero
5. shortkut
6. Smacktard

 

[Smacktard]

I was seer apprentice. Rerolled into bodyguard

Hey, I was seer apprentice too!

 

[shortkut]

I did not reroll because there were too many words to read about the various reroll options

 

[Kat]

I did not reroll because there were too many words to read about the various reroll options

Witch is one of the best roles anyway.

 

[Ben]

Even Jawneh could easily be evil. Claim two townies are red and we're nearly guaranteed to help them win. If it doesn't check out, it'll be too late to do anything in retribution.

1. Ben
2. dimmerwit
3. Jawneh
4. Local Hero
5. shortkut
6. Smacktard

What is this -3 modifier crap? Trying to favor your 3 other wolf friends?!

I demand the DM read the rules.

 

[Jawneh]

I rarely ever get to be a seer role so I stuck with mine. Rolled Vash instead for the lulz.

I don't count meme or meta game roles as proper. Especially last meta game as seer stuff was inherently working against you.

 

[Kat]

What is this -3 modifier crap? Trying to favor your 3 other wolf friends?!

I demand the DM read the rules.

It was so the sum doesn't spoil the results!

 

[Ben]

It was so the sum doesn't spoil the results!

...Fair enough. I still don't like your dice, though.

And I said in my first post I rerolled and regret it, 'cause I had Gunner.

 

[Kat]

What?! Why would you reroll if you originally had gunner? What were you hoping for?

 

[Smacktard]

What?! Why would you reroll if you originally had gunner? What were you hoping for?

I think he's hoping to be watered right now

 

[Kat]

I think he's hoping to be watered right now

Are you saying he's the SK baiting me or that I should water him?

 

[Smacktard]

Are you saying he's the SK baiting me or that I should water him?

It seems like bait to me. But it seems like such obvious bait that it could be anti-bait.

 

[Smacktard]

I say trust your instincts. They're usually spot-on.

 

[Ben]

Fuck me. I misspoke trying to post before a team meeting.

I meant I tried to keep my role and rerole Jon, but got rerolled. That's what I managed to say clearly yesterday.

Edit: I DID want gunner, but lost it.

The "regret it" was assuming I got rerolled because I did it to Jon.

 

[Kat]

@Zell 17 how much of the mechanics around rerolling are you willing to share? Or should we not be using it to determine anything in the game?

 

[Zell 17]

I'm wondering if this type of question is game breaking or not?

I'm okay with it

 

[Zell 17]

I probably won't go into the mechanics until after this game, besides what is in the instructions that everyone received

 

[Local Hero]

 

[dimmerwit]

I also didn’t reroll. There are some better regular village roles but some worse, and I figured nobody with a strong role would swap and I didn’t fancy solo/wolf this time.

 

[Local Hero]

I also didn’t reroll. There are some better regular village roles but some worse, and I figured nobody with a strong role would swap and I didn’t fancy solo/wolf this time.

So either Jawneh or you are lying about everything. Just to bump this info

 

[Kat]

I also didn’t reroll. There are some better regular village roles but some worse, and I figured nobody with a strong role would swap and I didn’t fancy solo/wolf this time.

If Ben is to be believed, you missed your chance!

 

[Local Hero]

Katamari Damacy Reroll

What timing!!! I literally just got a notification that this went on sale on Steam. From 30 to 10 dollars

 

[Kat]

I don't really believe Ben, but it does feel like bait. So rolling again.

 

[Local Hero]

Even Jawneh could easily be evil. Claim two townies are red and we're nearly guaranteed to help them win. If it doesn't check out, it'll be too late to do anything in retribution.

1. Ben
2. dimmerwit
3. Jawneh
4. Local Hero
5. shortkut
6. Smacktard

That's Kelly

 

[Local Hero]

Coincidentally, my "reroll" that I linked also landed on Kelly

 

[VashTheStampede]

We're being guided by a higher power

 

[Smacktard]

I don't really believe Ben, but it does feel like bait. So rolling again.

I take back what I said about your instincts.

 

[Local Hero]

 

[Kat]

I take back what I said about your instincts.

Haha, I figured you wouldn't like that.

Who do you have targeted?

 

[Smacktard]

Haha, I figured you wouldn't like that.

Who do you have targeted?

I know this is going to sound stupid, but I don't want to say.

If you water them and they die, I'll have to retarget and I don't want the wolves knowing that.
If you water someone ELSE and commit sudoku, I have them lined up for a night kill.

 

[Smacktard]

All I will say is that it's someone between Local, dimmerwit, shortkut, and Ben.

 

[Ben]

I'm not sure I follow Tommy's assumption that the roles we had were swapped if we didn't keep them. It said we rerolled someone else so I figured it was randomized again entirely. The only thing I assumed was fixed was the number of players on each team.

Also do we really think Tommy would give up being the alpha wolf? That feels like a weird bait to me, and in my experience Tommy is always some kind of fairy wren solo killer.

All I will say is that it's someone between Local, dimmerwit, shortkut, and Ben.

My crime is trying to bring you ungrateful folks some classic music, when all you want to do is listen to Skrillex.

 

[Local Hero]

Also do we really think Tommy would give up being the alpha wolf?

100%. Tommy hates being a wolf haha

 

[Ben]

 

[Kat]

Also do we really think Tommy would give up being the alpha wolf? That feels like a weird bait to me, and in my experience Tommy is always some kind of fairy wren solo killer.

Well he's definitely not an alpha wolf or any other wolf, so unless you think he's the SK, then yeah?

 

[Kat]

Time to get a badge.

Kat waters dimmerwit.

 

[Local Hero]

Time to get a badge.

Kat waters dimmerwit.

 

[Kat]

@Zell 17 see above

 

[Zell 17]

Time to get a badge.

Kat waters dimmerwit.

Kat is the Priest.

dimmerwit is dead. dimmerwit was the Shadow Wolf