You knew it couldn't last

[Zell 17]

Welcome to the doldrums

 

[Zell 17]

Hi @A Challenger Approaches

 

[A Punched Face]

Oh man. Kill off a peaceful flower child why don't you.

 

[A Punched Face]

At least every day I was alive resulted in no lynches. That's a real flower child right there.

 

[Zell 17]

There is a medium, so you may not be dead forever. We'll see.

 

[A Punched Face]

Oh fun. Maybe, but I'd only be important in that I'm a confirmed townie at this point.

 

[A Punched Face]

I feel like this was just typed wrong (meant Dead Body), but it's funny to me:

I think that's correct (I'm new to this) but seems like jailer always dies and it could either be from a player or natural causes?

What a fun role that would be. You get assigned jailer, if the wolves don't kill you, you always die anyway. Game Over.

 

[Zell 17]

I havent let the medium in here yet cause I didn't want anyone to go insane all by themselves.

You don't get a choice.

 

[A Punched Face]

I mean that seems fair. Do I get to know who the medium is before the next night phase or do I have to wait?

 

[Zell 17]

It's rktaker

 

[A Punched Face]

Got it. A medium bully.

 

[Zell 17]

@Jawneh is here too. Playmates!

 

[A Punched Face]

Hello Librarian. You probably shouldn't tell people you're the librarian if you want to live.

Enjoy the ride!

 

[Jawneh]

I'll most likely play my cards the same way next time lol. Just to confuse everyone.

 

[Jawneh]

I havent let the medium in here yet cause I didn't want anyone to go insane all by themselves.

You don't get a choice.

Booo! That's half the charm of the place!

 

[A Punched Face]

Booo! That's half the charm of the place!

Therefore it was charming until you got here.

 

[Jawneh]

So Kat is the bully and rk medium. Canadabro could still be bodyguard, which would work nicely for Kat.

Tommy is then a wolf or solo then. Considering Kat is a townie, I feel Kelly is also a wolf, or Tommy a wolf and found Kelly being the solo. Not really sure about any other folks yet. A whole load of nothing concrete.

 

[A Punched Face]

Oh man all the friends to come!

 

[A Punched Face]

So 3 illusionists. What is your actual role?

Someone was loudmouth. For sure. Quagmire likely the actual illusionist since he otherwise would have been killed with the other two otherwise I think. And not enough night phases to get a third.

 

[rktaker]

well then didn’t see that coming

 

[canadaguy]

Hi

 

[A Punched Face]

Rktaker, unfortunately you only have two of us to choose from (currently) to revive. The people with their roles hidden are not eligible. It also unfortunately seems like everyone was a townie (unless cg was lying about providing protection for Jon).

 

[canadaguy]

I was bodyguard

 

[Zell 17]

@Quagmire
@Benzine
Too

 

[rktaker]

Rktaker, unfortunately you only have two of us to choose from (currently) to revive. The people with their roles hidden are not eligible. It also unfortunately seems like everyone was a townie (unless cg was lying about providing protection for Jon).

yeah things are not looking good for me next day phase. probably a dumb question but I’m still kind of new to this so idk when i role claim (cause i have a feeling I’m gonna have to real soon) am i allowed to say things from in here like if one of the “illusionists” was a wolf or everyone killed by the illusionists is town or something or is it whatever’s said in here stays in here?

 

[Zell 17]

You can say whatever you want. I'd rather you not copy and paste wholesale from here, but you are free to convey anything told here to the larger group. Of course, someone else can fake being here and the people that ARE here may not be truthful.

 

[A Punched Face]

You can do whatever you want with the information you find in here. You can also lie if you really want to for some reason (probably not a good plan).

Also it seems pretty obvious who was what, again, unless cg was lying (which is still technically possible). So it's not likely that people will be fooled or confused as to what's happening. But at this point we probably have 4 dead townies and likely another one after tonight. Getting pretty close to a clean sweep for the wolves. Jawneh could help prevent someone from voting (not in the day phase you revive him before) and I could prevent a lynch one time if the town is going down the wrong direction. Either could be good, either could be bad. We don't have the information to go off of to make sure we get it right.

 

[A Punched Face]

Also Jawneh can use his power as often as he wants. I have one use in mine.

 

[rktaker]

You can do whatever you want with the information you find in here. You can also lie if you really want to for some reason (probably not a good plan).

Also it seems pretty obvious who was what, again, unless cg was lying (which is still technically possible). So it's not likely that people will be fooled or confused as to what's happening. But at this point we probably have 4 dead townies and likely another one after tonight. Getting pretty close to a clean sweep for the wolves. Jawneh could help prevent someone from voting (not in the day phase you revive him before) and I could prevent a lynch one time if the town is going down the wrong direction. Either could be good, either could be bad. We don't have the information to go off of to make sure we get it right.

yeah i feel like if i were to revive you you could prevent a lynch on me if it goes that way and confirm that I’m good but you’ll probably be dead again the next night phase

 

[A Punched Face]

yeah i feel like if i were to revive you you could prevent a lynch on me if it goes that way and confirm that I’m good but you’ll probably be dead again the next night phase

Yeah that's the risk of reviving me OR Jawneh. However, it does give numbers, which is a plus.

If there's a protector out there, it would also make sense for that person to protect whoever is revived, since that would prevent a likely target (since that person would be the only confirmed good person). It's your choice in how you want to play it, but I personally feel Jawneh's power would be more useful. Either of us could prevent your lynch just by saying you're the medium if it comes down to it. He could also silence someone and prevent them from voting (thus making it easier to have one less wolf vote if he can figure that out). I could prevent someone else's lynch with my power if need be, but same problem with Jawneh would be that I'd need to guess right on who it would be.

Personally, among us, I would say he'd be the better revive. Smacktard being revealed as the Avenger likely means they don't target him for fear of him having one of them in their sights. That also would give you, him, and whomever you revive (if you do it tonight) a group of 3 as a voting bloc.

 

[rktaker]

that’s a very good point

 

[rktaker]

feel like i have to make a revive this day phase if nothing else, makes the wolves work a bit harder, anyway how’s everyone doing?

 

[A Punched Face]

The revival becomes a good idea when there's a decent chance you could be killed at night or lynched the next day phase. If you don't get it out then it's useless.

If you think you have time you can wait though.

I'm doing fine. Still dead and expecting to stay that way.

 

[canadaguy]

I'm fine as well.

Not sure if my protect on Jon saved him, or if I ended up being the target that night, but I'm sure that'll all come out eventually

 

[A Punched Face]

I'm fine as well.

Not sure if my protect on Jon saved him, or if I ended up being the target that night, but I'm sure that'll all come out eventually

We'll know for sure when everyone is dead

 

[canadaguy]

We'll know for sure when everyone is dead

And if I actually am the bodyguard.

(I am)



(or am I?)



(I am)

 

[Jawneh]

I got no qualms going back. Alu already did a good run down of powers.

The only concrete piece of info we got is that Tommy is a wolf. Kat is the Bully, rk is medium, jailer is dead. We got to hope there's one more protector there for Kat as it doesn't look good for her tonight.

So many people are being quiet. Hard to gleam much info off of them. Currently, I'd probably say Jon, dimmerwit, and Fool. Good chance one or two of those are wolves, but wouldn't bet on all three.

 

[Quagmire]

Maybe it's because I'm new to all of this, but I'm surprised there wasn't more people going for kat in the lynching, or they just waiting to do that at night

 

[rktaker]

Maybe it's because I'm new to all of this, but I'm surprised there wasn't more people going for kat in the lynching, or they just waiting to do that at night

Kat is the bully we know she is town so it wouldn't make sense to lynch her

 

[A Punched Face]

Oh right Kat is also town.

So Smacktard, rk, Kat, and potentially Jawneh if revived would be a pretty solid voting bloc. Smacktard is likely safe due to being avenger. Kat may not be (would be a good target if we're being real.

 

[A Punched Face]

The only concrete piece of info we got is that Tommy is a wolf

Is this confirmed? Kelly said so, but then backed off on that later because he thought you were partnered with Tommy (to let him know in advance that you were muted).

Maybe I missed something else though. Benzine saying Quagmire should be voted and feeling confident about it tends to scream "wolf trying to kill off the RK" a bit.

 

[rktaker]

right now I think the question marks are FR, Vaash, and Shortkut, am I missing anyone?

 

[Jawneh]

Is this confirmed? Kelly said so, but then backed off on that later because he thought you were partnered with Tommy (to let him know in advance that you were muted).

Maybe I missed something else though. Benzine saying Quagmire should be voted and feeling confident about it tends to scream "wolf trying to kill off the RK" a bit.

Tommy is saying he's the witch, but we already know three strong villagers. The dead body sadly ate one of then. And idk if it was only me who grasped onto Tommy like I did when he came forward saying he's the witch in a very forceful and defensive way when nothing had yet really happened on day 2.

And yeah. Benzine could have had a cold read on quagmire or he just did his usual bit of swaying the hearts of the people with his sweet and velvety kiwi calls. But also easily could be a wolf wanting thr illusionist killed.

Edit: I already forgot again that benzine is dead and the loudmouth lol.

 

[canadaguy]

Witch is listed as a regular villager

 

[Jawneh]

right now I think the question marks are FR, Vaash, and Shortkut, am I missing anyone?

We got FR, Vash, kut, Local, dimmerwit, Jon, and Tommy for the wolf pack.

Witch is listed as a regular villager

Goddammit. I've been infected by the shortkut. Sigh.

 

[A Punched Face]

7 people for up to 5 wolf slots (if they find a fan). More likely 4.

There are potentially 4 safe people tomorrow if no one dies and Jawneh is brought back to life.

If the wolves attack Kat and she's saved, that likely gives a 5th person as town, potentially Tommy. That would be best case scenario. Worst case is there's a berserk wolf and they take out a protected Kat.

 

[rktaker]

the worst case scenario is if the wolves attack someone who's not Kat if Kat is protected, makes me really want to revive Jawneh now like said before more numbers would be good of course there might not be 4 wolves, I don't think there has been 4 wolves since I started playing here but I could be misremembering

 

[Quagmire]

Kat is the bully we know she is town so it wouldn't make sense to lynch her

Which means if someone voted to Lynch her then it would be obvious who is a wolf?

 

[A Punched Face]

the worst case scenario is if the wolves attack someone who's not Kat if Kat is protected, makes me really want to revive Jawneh now like said before more numbers would be good of course there might not be 4 wolves, I don't think there has been 4 wolves since I started playing here but I could be misremembering

The wolves attacking not kat while kat isn't protected isn't the worst thing. It'll leave you with 4 people (if you revive) who are cleared vs. only 6 who are not.

The worst is berserk, it'll take out two townies at once and end the game (if you don't revive) because it would be 4-4, and that's an automatic wolf win.


In order of best to worst:
You revive, kat is targeted and saved (potentially brings it to 5 known town if the protector can come forward)
You revive, kat is not targeted, wolves kill rando
You revive, kat is killed
You revive, you're killed
You don't revive, rando is killed
You don't revive, kat is killed
You don't revive, you're killed
You revive, kat is killed with berserk
You don't revive, kat is killed with berserk (game over)


This is also while knowing none of the wolf roles.

 

[A Punched Face]

Which means if someone voted to Lynch her then it would be obvious who is a wolf?

Anyone who votes for a confirmed townie is playing in a dumb way, regardless of if they're town or wolf (unless the wolves have enough votes to force a tie or lynch).