• Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Zell Wolf Not Zell Wolf 3 Day 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
12,872
You're just one person though, but you're probably thinking 10 rounded down equals 1.
Ok, Elsa.

let it go GIF
 

Aluse Cannon

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
13,797
Man, work gets in the way here.

Ben claimed flagger for anyone who missed it. I missed whatever it was local claimed.

I'm unsure as why the red lady would visit a confirmed townie at all rather than just not using a power, but at this point if we don't have a talk with the dead role then the only way the red lady can give us a read on an evil person is by announcing who they're visiting before the day phase ends.
 
Man, work gets in the way here.

Ben claimed flagger for anyone who missed it. I missed whatever it was local claimed.

I'm unsure as why the red lady would visit a confirmed townie at all rather than just not using a power, but at this point if we don't have a talk with the dead role then the only way the red lady can give us a read on an evil person is by announcing who they're visiting before the day phase ends.
season 4 doctor GIF
 

Aluse Cannon

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
13,797
Here's the thing though:

If everything goes poorly we could have a wolf kill, a black potion, and then a red to either myself or kat. If all of those target townies, then that's 3 deaths.

Unless we can guarantee we're going to hit an evil with a lynch we're going to help the evils kill off a 4th (we're going to need to coordinate in plain view and they could easily jump on whatever incorrect target we choose).


We also have the solo voter out there, which could easily be something like Jon with a target of me (just going on harping that I could be the alchemist for a bit there, but good also doesn't mean much considering he's not claiming a role that has knowledge and is just tossing ideas out there to get discussion going). It could obviously also be a fool or a headhunter with any target really. Cupid would still be fun to have pop up.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
12,872
I actually got Bell Ringer in the past. Also, got an actual useless role in the game Kat hosted.
I don't think Bell Ringer is as useless as people say it is. I know it's a meme with us, but when you guess right, it's got power.

That said, I don't like roles that have so much luck behind them but are restricted by usage. If you guess right on low percentage odds, you deserve to be able to use it again. Just put a restriction on something like "can't use it with less than 8 players left" or something to not make it super simple. Or let them use it twice because most of the time they are lucky hitting once.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
12,872
So if our seers are check each other tonight, what happens when you both say red tomorrow? There are no more shaman wolves to hid behind and we are stuck with you 2 point fingers at each other?
At that point, I lean Alu because at least he's had other collaborative information.

That said checking each other is silly in my opinion. Announcing you're checking each other is even sillier.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
18,305
At that point, I lean Alu because at least he's had other collaborative information.

That said checking each other is silly in my opinion. Announcing you're checking each other is even sillier.
I know I wasn’t serious, and I don’t think Alu was either
 

Aluse Cannon

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
13,797
Was there confirmation that not voting would outweigh a vote?
There's a requirement of 5 for a lynch and the wolves can only get to 4 by themselves.

Unless they have a cupided wolf paired with a townie they can't get to 5 if no one else votes with them (either by accident or by discussing it in public and following through on it). If none of the townies vote, it relies on the wolves and solos somehow coordinating on a target. If there's a non-wolf arguing for someone who also happens to be a non-wolf I'd be weary of that person being a headhunter at this point.
 

shortkut

idea man
Cuterator
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
18,305
There's a requirement of 5 for a lynch and the wolves can only get to 4 by themselves.

Unless they have a cupided wolf paired with a townie they can't get to 5 if no one else votes with them (either by accident or by discussing it in public and following through on it). If none of the townies vote, it relies on the wolves and solos somehow coordinating on a target. If there's a non-wolf arguing for someone who also happens to be a non-wolf I'd be weary of that person being a headhunter at this point.
I like it. I’ll no vote too
 

Kat

Orangekat
Kat
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
5,693
I would love for you to visit me and prove my innocents but I had this scandal with the gunner and I'm now with child and I worry that has made me a bigger target.
You.. uh, what?
We are also now under shadow and a wolf died of a black potion. You have the red then, so don't fear dropping died just yet.
Sounds like the wolf was Tommy and somebody said "can't hide behind a shaman anymore" so I assume we know all the wolf roles now? What was he?

That also being said Kat. One more potion and you are dead anyways, so maybe calling your shot and hopefully proving something would be a better way to die than by potion.
Hmm, this is true. I'm not much of a bonus target if I'm doomed to die tomorrow anyway (which seems likely).

I’m thinking you’re headhunter and your target is already dead
Wouldn't somebody just admit that? They win with the town in that case, right?

From the red lady description: "Cannot be attacked directly and killed at night by wolves/solo if they are visiting"

I assume this means alchemist potion is still delivered, since it is not a direct/kill at night
If not then @Benzine @Ants! please give my potion back to the alchemist. :tease

I’m willing to vote someone other than jawneh tonight because he made a good point about not being able to talk to Vash last night. I will await his updated gif tomorrow
Lmao, I would hope he learned that lesson. You know he's not seriously claiming ritualist though, right?

I'm unsure as why the red lady would visit a confirmed townie at all rather than just not using a power, but at this point if we don't have a talk with the dead role then the only way the red lady can give us a read on an evil person is by announcing who they're visiting before the day phase ends.
This is a fair point. In retrospect, visiting Fools was probably riskier than not visiting anybody. It's not like the wolves were likely to target me. My only justifications are 1) using abilities is more fun than not using them and 2) this post-covid fatigue and brain fog is killing me. That's also why I haven't been posting much this game.

Does not voting anybody really make sense? Can't we just out vote the wolves if they only have four votes? (It's hard for me to tell how many people are alive with no poll, so apologies if the math actually isn't in our favor).
 

Aluse Cannon

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
13,797
Does not voting anybody really make sense? Can't we just out vote the wolves if they only have four votes? (It's hard for me to tell how many people are alive with no poll, so apologies if the math actually isn't in our favor)
Do you know for certain that someone is a wolf/the alchemist/solo but not fool?

That's the problem with voting, if a single person votes for a townie that the wolves go for, the townie is lynched. If we don't know for sure who to target, we'd still need at least 5 people to agree and 0 people to agree with the wolves (purposely or not)
 

Fool's Requiem

Anyone want a popsicle?
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
11,444
Does not voting anybody really make sense? Can't we just out vote the wolves if they only have four votes? (It's hard for me to tell how many people are alive with no poll, so apologies if the math actually isn't in our favor).
sure, let's just lynch at random, hope we hit a wolf, and hope that everyone actually votes for them. There are 4 people who would likely love for us to accidentally lynch a townie. We could have more depending on if we have a Cupid and who they paired. Advocating for anything but a no-vote and not skipping is a very wolf like attitude.

We currently have a number advantage. If even one of us votes in favor of the wolves, we could very well be down 3 townies by next mid-day.
 

canadaguy

That time we turned shortkut into pineapple pizza
Moderator
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
6,025
Do you know for certain that someone is a wolf/the alchemist/solo but not fool?

That's the problem with voting, if a single person votes for a townie that the wolves go for, the townie is lynched. If we don't know for sure who to target, we'd still need at least 5 people to agree and 0 people to agree with the wolves (purposely or not)
We are also VERY at risk if we don't hit the alchemist or a wolf with the lynch. We are looking at a potential triple townie kill tonight (wolf plus alchemist black potion and a second red to someone), so giving them a free 4th one would be bad.
 

Jon

Diplomatic Immunity
T-Bone
10K Post Club
Moderator
Executive
GW Elder
Wolf Players
Messages
12,872
Sounds like the wolf was Tommy and somebody said "can't hide behind a shaman anymore" so I assume we know all the wolf roles now? What was he?
He was a second Shaman. All 4 wolf roles have been revealed and they have no powers left. Dimmerwit and Tommy were Shamans and there is a Berserker and Shadow now with both powers used.

Hmm, this is true. I'm not much of a bonus target if I'm doomed to die tomorrow anyway (which seems likely).
Alu also has a red on him. If I'm the alchemist, I'd think he's a bigger issue than you at this point. You may not be guaranteed dead tonight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom