Margaritaville

[Quagmire]

animal farm wolf incoming

Some roles are equal, but some roles are more equal

 

[Local Hero]

Up to page 8. @canadaguy the quality of posts really dropped towards the end of page 6 and page 7

His family got sick

 

[Benzine]

Some roles are equal, but some roles are more equal

No one believes more firmly than Benzine that all townspeople are equal. He would be only too happy to let you make your decisions for yourselves. But sometimes you might make the wrong decisions, comrades, and then where should we be?

 

[Benzine]

Some roles are equal, but some roles are more equal

Arsonists/ @dimmerwit serves the interests of no creature except himself.

 

[Quagmire]

Arsonists/ @dimmerwit serves the interests of no creature except himself.

In some games the Arsonist gets to light during the day, really OP! (No worries Ben, shit like this happens)(Ben as in actual Ben and not Benzine)

 

[shortkut]

@shortkut should gave gievn the gun to @Ben

I nearly did, but with all the seers I didn’t think the mob had a chance and decided to try securing my spot for innocence

My main complaint is that I still don't believe you that Christina is vampire just by chance

and that I’m the double agent by chance… otherwise this is the best RNG ever and he should have bought a lottery ticket instead

Anyways, so to make some flavor for the role, they can hear the confessions, but if they release any info, they get excommunicated and lose the power going forward.

brilliant

Jon was another one that died for this reason. It felt super strategic I think to some. Taking out the jail with the guns. But honestly, it was because he was being quiet and not drawing much attention.

fuck you @Jon and @TD , it wasn’t my fault.

Had you chosen to kill Kut, I think you win. He was so adamant about finding the Vampire because it's literally the only way he loses

I doubt it. Once I’m dead, people would stop being stubborn just to resist me and would start to think logically. TD literally was the first to spell out that we had 2 days and more than 2 targets and then refused to vote for either of the targets

We have done it before. I wouldn't let that stop you.

Maybe Vampire gets altered so that they don't actually kill, they just convert and players who are bitten are told they are bitten (maybe even added to a group chat) and when they die, they are announced as a vampire instead of their role. So no one actually knows who the alpha is until too late.

You know, I actually really like that concept. May add this as a solo role in Nexus.

my idea for vampires was that vampire can choose to kill or make a thrall. The thrall would die for the vampire whenever the vampire is attacked but would not count for the number of vampires required to win

 

[shortkut]

What?! Really?!

Oh poor Shortkut worked so hard. Found a vampire and everything.

I knew it was happening before it happened. I was expecting it the previous night, but the mob recently came under new leadership, and the boy wasn’t as understanding as his old man

So why'd they off shortkut? Was it because he was getting too friendly with the agency?

under new management. Local forgot the godfather would show as unknown, so Ben and Tommy swapped roles. Tommy is Italian, Ben is British.

 

[shortkut]

His family got sick

I was blaming more people being added to the thread

 

[Local Hero]

under new management. Local forgot the godfather would show as unknown, so Ben and Tommy swapped roles. Tommy is Italian, Ben is British.

The one mistake I tried to keep secret

 

[Christina]

I knew it was happening before it happened. I was expecting it the previous night, but the mob recently came under new leadership, and the boy wasn’t as understanding as his old man

under new management. Local forgot the godfather would show as unknown, so Ben and Tommy swapped roles. Tommy is Italian, Ben is British.

We need to finish watching the Penguin show....

 

[shortkut]

The one mistake I tried to keep secret

Really? That mistake was a nothing burger. It didn’t really change too much

 

[Benzine]

We need to finish watching the Penguin show....

oh i love pingu

 

[Christina]

oh i love pingu

 

[canadaguy]

 

[Christina]

Who knew it would take this long to kill Ben?!

 

[Quagmire]

Who knew it would take this long to kill Ben?!

 

[canadaguy]

Who knew it would take this long to kill Ben?!

Itd be even funnier if he didn't get ungodfathered

 

[Local Hero]

So I was planning on ending the game after this thread as it's only Tommy left. Alu did his detective stuff and checked Tommy and TD day 2 I think, with a different teams result, but people seem to have forgotten about Tommy altogether?

 

[Benzine]

don't stop the game early unless they give up

 

[Jon]

So I was planning on ending the game after this thread as it's only Tommy left. Alu did his detective stuff and checked Tommy and TD day 2 I think, with a different teams result, but people seem to have forgotten about Tommy altogether?

It's typically at this time that they start skipping phases quickly.

The town seems particularly fond of prolonging this game.

I blame @shortkut really.

 

[Local Hero]

don't stop the game early unless they give up

We had talked about it in mob chat. We knew it was 8 to 2, soon to be 8 to 1, 3 seers and two protectors left.

Plus, Kelly knows it's Tommy, he's just asleep. Didn't want to draw it out unnecessarily

 

[Benzine]

okay so who is hosting next

 

[canadaguy]

If shortkut hadn't been a traitor to la famiglia, things could have been much more interesting

 

[Jon]

okay so who is hosting next

 

[Local Hero]

okay so who is hosting next

Zell came out with new roles. He might

 

[Benzine]

i don't mind doing it and i'll use the new roles. @Zell 17 just let me know if you care if i take the thunder of the first game with new roles or if you wanted to do it or whatever

 

[Christina]

If shortkut hadn't been a traitor to la famiglia, things could have been much more interesting

I tried to warn him...after the fact.

 

[Quagmire]

Zell came out with new roles. He might

 

[Quagmire]

Zell came out with new roles. He might

Also makes sense there were new roles as I have been kicking tires on the game I plan to run later this month and saw some roles I didn't recognize

 

[Local Hero]

Also makes sense there were new roles as I have been kicking tires on the game I plan to run later this month and saw some roles I didn't recognize

Do it please

 

[Quagmire]

Do it please

I plan to! Gonna ask for some feedback on my ideas, just need to type up the actual post

 

[Local Hero]

I plan to! Gonna ask for some feedback on my ideas, just need to type up the actual post

Feedback? You mean host the game and learn from your mistakes?

 

[Local Hero]

Feedback? You mean host the game and learn from your mistakes?

Here's one for free.

Write down all the night actions people want to take before responding to seer results.

What with those pesky jailers and wolf powers

 

[Zell 17]

i don't mind doing it and i'll use the new roles. @Zell 17 just let me know if you care if i take the thunder of the first game with new roles or if you wanted to do it or whatever

Let me take it for a spin first if you don't mind.

Besides, it's not like I can use them all the next game. Still plenty of thunder to take.

 

[Benzine]

i don't and pls reg me

 

[Quagmire]

Feedback? You mean host the game and learn from your mistakes?

I'm planning a few role tweaks or new roles

 

[shortkut]

I blame @shortkut really

If I was left alive I could have ended this

 

[Christina]

If I was left alive I could have ended this

Me too....

 

[canadaguy]

If I was left alive I could have ended this

If you had given the gun to ben

 

[shortkut]

If you had given the gun to ben

I considered it. I already told local that night I really wanted to

 

[shortkut]

It’s a shame… I sowed a lot of confusion once TD and the agency started being hostile to me, and then Tommy takes advantage of the confusion to usurp the family, kill me, and benefit from the agency’s ineptitude

 

[Jon]

If I was left alive I could have ended this

Me too....

Me three...

 

[Christina]

Me three...

Would you have shot me?

 

[Jon]

Would you have shot me?

Probably not.

My first bullet was earmarked for Kut because I felt he gave me away.

The second I would have held onto.

 

[shortkut]

Probably not.

My first bullet was earmarked for Kut because I felt he gave me away.

The second I would have held onto.

If you listened to me, you would have stayed in the shadows and had 2 guns

 

[Jon]

If you listened to me, you would have stayed in the shadows and had 2 guns

If I listened to you, you were setting the agency up. I had suspicions of both you and TD. I did the right thing not dropping the weapon. I KNEW you were the DA the next day.

 

[shortkut]

If I listened to you, you were setting the agency up

No, I was setting up my own win condition, you dolt. I wanted to prove myself independent of TD so there would be no ambiguity that I was the one who gave you the gun. I diverted a mob Hitman kill on you the night I gave you the gun, because I wanted you alive to vouch for me

 

[Jon]

No, I was setting up my own win condition, you dolt. I wanted to prove myself independent of TD so there would be no ambiguity that I was the one who gave you the gun. I diverted a mob Hitman kill on you the night I gave you the gun, because I wanted you alive to vouch for me

Not sure what to tell you, man. You've admitted you went against me because I went against your version of the plan. I felt quickening the pace was better because it felt we had not additional guns. In hindsight, it really did not matter.

 

[shortkut]

Not sure what to tell you, man. You've admitted you went against me because I went against your version of the plan. I felt quickening the pace was better because it felt we had not additional guns. In hindsight, it really did not matter.

No, I had to act the way I did because of how you and TD planned to go. No knew I could influence the mob vote, so you were likely safe there. At the time, they didn’t know I was telling the truth about the gun, so they would think I was just talking shit. With my inside knowledge, I knew the mob was no threat to you no matter how obvious I was

I did not think the vampire would go for you because I figured with me being vocal about a gun you would be protected.

 

[Jon]

No, I had to act the way I did because of how you and TD planned to go. No knew I could influence the mob vote, so you were likely safe there. At the time, they didn’t know I was telling the truth about the gun, so they would think I was just talking shit. With my inside knowledge, I knew the mob was no threat to you no matter how obvious I was

I did not think the vampire would go for you because I figured with me being vocal about a gun you would be protected.

Look, I'm not faulting you. You were playing to your win condition, or what you thought would bring you a win condition. I'm just telling you why I felt the way I did. From my perspective (and TDs), you have to at least see where we were coming from