Grave Mistakes Were Made

[Ants!]

I’m just am going to ignore how it was pretty unanimous that you all enjoy killing me as much as you do

I don't recall if I said anything like that, but if I did, just know that it was in jest and I think you played really well. It was fun enabling you to steal from the dead lol

 

[Jon]

I was more referencing the “why is Jon still alive” “he’s so killable” “he’s gone a killable face” “it’s usually bad when he’s still alive” comments.

Apparently people like to kill me. I don’t know if I’m honored or horrified.

 

[Jon]

I don't recall if I said anything like that, but if I did, just know that it was in jest and I think you played really well. It was fun enabling you to steal from the dead lol

I know it was lol.

I loved the opportunity to keep going for the procession and getting it

 

[Ben]

I was more referencing the “why is Jon still alive” “he’s so killable” “he’s gone a killable face” “it’s usually bad when he’s still alive” comments.

Apparently people like to kill me. I don’t know if I’m honored or horrified.

Oh, the face thing was just bullshit ribbing on my part. I guess I do know what you look like since you posted a picture now, but still.

 

[Jawneh]

I was more referencing the “why is Jon still alive” “he’s so killable” “he’s gone a killable face” “it’s usually bad when he’s still alive” comments.

Apparently people like to kill me. I don’t know if I’m honored or horrified.

 

[Jon]

Oh, the face thing was just bullshit ribbing on my part. I guess I do know what you look like since you posted a picture now, but still.

It is a punchable face I’ve been told. Killable isn’t far off. Lol

I wish I wasn’t so busy this weekend because in the end there, and no idea if it would have mattered with item shenanigans, but I would have given the other loud potion I pilfered from Ben’s corpse to kut and done my best to convince him to just vote jawneh with me (4votes).

I knew he had the love potion and didn’t really believe he drank the invisibility one because that was an auto loss. He’s too smart for that. I telegraphed I was using my loud voice so it made total sense for him to use it on me. And the ONLY shot we had at winning was killing jawneh. Hindsight. But being busy limited my interaction.

Was super fucking fun though.

 

[Jon]

I also pilfered items that MAY have protected me from an attack if I rolled high enough from Ben I would have used. But it all required voting out jawneh

 

[Jawneh]

I knew he had the love potion and didn’t really believe he drank the invisibility one because that was an auto loss.

It technically wouldn't have been. I could've drank the love pot the next day after finding out who drank a loud pot and then drank my loud pot too to bring the vote even. Then just kill at night.

I thought bluffing drinking the invisi pot was cooler.

 

[Zell 17]

Guys definitely should have killed me on day 2

 

[Jon]

Guys definitely should have killed me on day 2

I stand by day 3. Day two we should have used you to kill a suspected acolyte. Problem was we didn't have one. CG, Jawneh and Tommy didn't have enough heat, though I suspected Tommy most. I didn't have a provable role, so convincing would have been hard for me.

We did get you to kill a target, it just happened to be an avenger that targeted a townie. If Kelly stayed on an acolyte, I'd say the gambit would have paid off. It didn't. But killing you that quickly I stand by being too hasty.

I truly don't remember why we didn't kill you after that.

 

[A Vaguely Ambiguous Username]

I stand by day 3. Day two we should have used you to kill a suspected acolyte. Problem was we didn't have one. CG, Jawneh and Tommy didn't have enough heat, though I suspected Tommy most. I didn't have a provable role, so convincing would have been hard for me.

We did get you to kill a target, it just happened to be an avenger that targeted a townie. If Kelly stayed on an acolyte, I'd say the gambit would have paid off. It didn't. But killing you that quickly I stand by being too hasty.

I truly don't remember why we didn't kill you after that.

If we killed him off the game would have been shorter because the acolytes would have more easily ended up tied numbers wise.

Killing him day 2 would have been better still though, it snowballed into two villagers being killed immediately, and then another was killed right off the bat to start the day phase.

If everything else stayed as it was, Christina and Kelly would have been alive, Christina would have been proved village by me, since I was verified village after reviving FR, and then Kelly likely would have put his avenge back on Tommy. CG still would have been outed, and good shenanigans may have actually paid off that time.

Very interesting what could have happened. But just be happy that the game managed to go even like a day beyond that one lmao

 

[Jon]

If we killed him off the game would have been shorter because the acolytes would have more easily ended up tied numbers wise.

Killing him day 2 would have been better still though, it snowballed into two villagers being killed immediately, and then another was killed right off the bat to start the day phase.

If everything else stayed as it was, Christina and Kelly would have been alive, Christina would have been proved village by me, since I was verified village after reviving FR, and then Kelly likely would have put his avenge back on Tommy. CG still would have been outed, and good shenanigans may have actually paid off that time.

Very interesting what could have happened. But just be happy that the game managed to go even like a day beyond that one lmao

I only really offered keeping him alive to kill acolytes as an option. I don't recall pushing for it in a "you're stupid if you disagree" manner, and I didn't see anyone else advocating exclusively for him to be lynched. I was very open to the idea of lynching him when I ID'd him. It is what it is. But this game shifted because of the town's inevitable desire to kill each other.

Kind makes me glad I DON'T ever get killing roles. I'm not responsible for it lol.

 

[A Vaguely Ambiguous Username]

This was my first revive role I think. And I managed to bring someone back on my first go after getting two good rolls to find out who people were before that.

 

[Ants!]

It makes sense to keep him alive and use him as a weapon if you know who to unleash him on. The problem is that at the time you guys weren't completely sure about anybody so it ended up being a gamble.

 

[Ants!]

Also, on that last round, once zell had been hit by an arrow, it made more sense to Lynch the last acolyte, and then Lynch zell the next day. Because zells kill was disabled, but jawneh's wasn't.

 

[shortkut]

Also, on that last round, once zell had been hit by an arrow, it made more sense to Lynch the last acolyte, and then Lynch zell the next day. Because zells kill was disabled, but jawneh's wasn't.

I assumed they both had items to avoid being lynched. In my mind it made more sense to try to have no kill overnight and then kill Zell with arrows and lynch Jawneh

 

[Jawneh]

Us acolytes should've also just killed Fool's right away instead of Alu, but Alu is a logicwielder. Plus it was afterwards very amusing to see Fool's be confused as hell about everything.

It did make sense to do as we did as Fool's seemed to believe my BS slightly more than Alu. Which was really what we needed.

 

[A Vaguely Ambiguous Username]

I wield my logic like Ben wields a spear Jawneh wields BS.

 

[dimmerwit]

I was planning to track items for my own sake but then I just died and you all bought 6 trillion of them.

 

[Ants!]

Nice. I have a spreadsheet also that's not nearly as pretty but is a bit more comprehensive on the information. I still need to update the last two days of it though when I have time.

 

[Ben]

I don't think I forgot anyone...

EDIT: Trying to shop together like 10 different images was a bugger though, so excuse any shit that doesn't look perfect.

 

[Ants!]

Nice. Which one is merchant benzine? I got everybody else I think.

 

[Ben]

Nice. Which one is merchant benzine? I got everybody else I think.

 

[Ben]

Nice. Which one is merchant benzine? I got everybody else I think.

 

[canadaguy]

View attachment 31170

I don't think I forgot anyone...

EDIT: Trying to shop together like 10 different images was a bugger though, so excuse any shit that doesn't look perfect.

Am I meth guy?

 

[Ben]

Am I meth guy?

Meth-olyte was Jawneh being the winner. I guess you're just the pained acolyte at the bottom. It added an extra person while trying to make Tommy killing dimmerwit, so I just left it.

 

[canadaguy]

Oh so I got the lamest one?

 

[Ben]

Oh so I got the lamest one?

It represents just letting yourself die that day.

 

[Ben]

FYI when I did tell it to make that character look more Canadian, it started giving me the nicest looking people and it didn't really fit, so... Your fault for being a country of decent blokes.

 

[Ben]

Oh so I got the lamest one?

 

[canadaguy]

I think our interpretations of the role may be somewhat different lol

 

[Ben]

I think our interpretations of the role may be somewhat different lol

You aren't the evil Canadian pope?

 

[Ants!]

He is, don't let him fool you.

 

[canadaguy]

I mean clearly I am

But I do not think the fanatic is