Acolytes Day 3

[Kat]

So, must be outlaw.

I think it's possible there is also a witch.

Ohh, I didn't read the acolyte roles yet. That would be sneaky! But what're the chances he bought and used an item overnight? Seems kinda unlikely.

 

[Kat]

Fair point.

@Ants! - Can you confirm if the wanted poster would be public knowledge, or can it be done quietly?

He already said it's posted publicly during the day.

 

[Local Hero]

"What type of story won't take long to tell?"

A short story?
...shortkut?
...cut throat?
...deep throat?
...deep cut?
...short cut

...oh a short story!?

 

[Jon]

So, must be outlaw.


Ohh, I didn't read the acolyte roles yet. That would be sneaky! But what're the chances he bought and used an item overnight? Seems kinda unlikely.

I don't think it's that unlikely. Poison a common item, someone buys it and uses it. Doesn't seem too far fetched. It doesn't target a player, but an item. Not saying there is for sure, but it's another explanation. But Ants was essentially confirming that Ben was killed by the SK. Which would mean an outlaw got crit happy.

And shortkut did buy a ton of luck potions... and I couldn't clear him as village, only not acolyte... so...

He already said it's posted publicly during the day.

Gotcha, I missed it, sorry.

That said, if I'm not wrong, Kut would be a target of the acolytes because they win if they kill him via witch hunt.

 

[Jon]

Assuming acolytes need him dead. That's not in this win conditions.

 

[Local Hero]

3 town. 4 acolytes. 1 SK.

Sheet

 

[Kat]

I don't think it's that unlikely. Poison a common item, someone buys it and uses it. Doesn't seem too far fetched. It doesn't target a player, but an item. Not saying there is for sure, but it's another explanation. But Ants was essentially confirming that Ben was killed by the SK. Which would mean an outlaw got crit happy.

And shortkut did buy a ton of luck potions... and I couldn't clear him as village, only not acolyte... so...


Gotcha, I missed it, sorry.

That said, if I'm not wrong, Kut would be a target of the acolytes because they win if they kill him via witch hunt.

Yeah Ben was SK, but what about Benzine?

@Ants! If Benzine died by visiting an evil person, would you have said that's how he died? Or would you just say he died?

 

[Ants!]

...deep throat?

we don't care what you do on weekends.

 

[Kat]

Assuming acolytes need him dead. That's not in this win conditions.

Wait what

WIN CONDITIONS: Villagers kill all Acolytes and the solo killer (if there is one in the game). Acolytes equal at least 50% of the players remaining alive. Solo killer is the last alive. Non-violent solo achieves their specific winning condition (may or may not end the game for the town, depending on their role).

Sure enough!

 

[Ants!]

Yeah Ben was SK, but what about Benzine?

@Ants! If Benzine died by visiting an evil person, would you have said that's how he died? Or would you just say he died?

I thought about just outright saying, but I think it's better if I leave it vague like that.

 

[Jon]

Sure enough!

Right, so town needs SK dead to win. In most of these games, evils need to kill the SK too. That's not in Ants version according to win conditions. So I don't know if they need the SK dead too. @Ants! can answer that.

I still think Benzine visited the wrong person. And I think he may have really visited Jawneh... and Jawneh would be bad.

Does anyone remember Benzine saying who he visited night 1? Was it Jawneh?

 

[Ants!]

Acolytes do not need SK dead.

 

[Kat]

I thought about just outright saying, but I think it's better if I leave it vague like that.

Totally fair, I don't mind you making us think, just checking.

I still think Benzine visited the wrong person. And I think he may have really visited Jawneh... and Jawneh would be bad.

Does anyone remember Benzine saying who he visited night 1? Was it Jawneh?

I don't think he said. Nobody really claimed anything day one.

 

[Kat]

I mean .. it's got to be visiting Jawneh that got him killed, right? What item would Benzine bother to use at night as an orphan?

Gonna go read the other acolyte roles to see if there's another explanation.

 

[Kat]

I don't see any other possibilities. So unless one of you killed him with a townie ability and want to cop to it, I'm voting Jawneh.

 

[Jon]

@Ants! - I would like to purchase a loud voice potion and the luck potion, please.

 

[Ants!]

Shop has been updated.

 

[Jon]

@shortkut @dimmerwit and @Quagmire have not yet posted.

Kut and dimmer have seen the thread.

We may have a Warlock.

 

[Ants!]

shortkut has been injured.

At the edge of town, people
Could see a bunch of Level 1 Sprites carrying shortkuts body out of the Dark Forest and dumping him in the street. People passing recognized his face from past muggings.

He was the Outlaw.

 

[Ants!]

Dead shortkut wants you all to know that he only lost because he's bad at dice.

 

[Jon]

Dead shortkut wants you all to know that he only lost because he's bad at dice.

 

[Ants!]

You hush. He had you vouching for him lol.

 

[Jon]

Welp, this essentially eliminates the town.

 

[Jon]

You hush. He had you vouching for him lol.

I never vouched for him. I simply ever said he was not an acolyte and distinctly said multiple times, even correcting people, that he could be solo.

I picked, randomly, the SK and vampire to stalk. I'm good at this hunter thing.

 

[Jon]

If there is a silence, the town can't win that I can see, ftr.

 

[Local Hero]

Isn't that 3 Town to 4 acolytes?

I may not be good at countin...but...no follow-up

 

[Jon]

3 acolytes, 3 town, 1 solo non violent.

If the town doesn't lynch an acolyte here, they will lose tonight.

I have met my win condition.

 

[Jon]

If you want my assumptions to this point...

Kat, Tommy and Jawneh are the acolytes.

 

[Local Hero]

If you want my assumptions to this point...

Kat, Tommy and Jawneh are the acolytes.

Jawneh isn't acolyte. He would have made his opening post about it lol.

All you need to do is look at who voted for Benzine. They weren't subtle.

 

[Jon]

Jawneh isn't acolyte. He would have made his opening post about it lol.

All you need to do is look at who voted for Benzine. They weren't subtle.

I have been on Tommy since yesterday. I'm literally the tie breaking vote since I've already met my win condition. No one else is proven one way or another. So when I see 3 and 3 on the votes, I guess I'll know.

Of course, if Quagmire IS silenced the best you can do is tie it.

 

[Local Hero]

I'll join you in Tommy

 

[Kat]

All you need to do is look at who voted for Benzine. They weren't subtle.

Lol now voting for somebody on day two is suspicious? I normally push for a lynch on day one, there's no way I was going to go two days without a serious attempt to witch hunt. It's not like there was much to go on, you can't blame me for it not working out.

If shortkut was the outlaw then seriously wtf happened to Benzine? The witch thing seems like the only possibility but what item would Benzine buy and use at night?? There was no healing stuff, he didn't have rolls to use luck for, he was immune to attacks so no need for the lantern. But what else could have killed him? It must've been a townie after all, after a different townie saved him?! (There doesn't seem to be an evil version of that role in this game.) Lol wild. ...Unless you can get poisoned while questing?

 

[Kat]

I'm voting Local for now because he's weirdly hell-bent on throwing suspicion over a random vote that nobody opposed. I'll give it some more thought later and make a final vote after sleeping though.

 

[Local Hero]

So weird to vote for the acolytes, I know

 

[finlandguy]

I think it's possible there is also a witch. Which would explain Ben. Benzine either visited an acolyte, which immediately makes Jawneh sus, or he visited Ben/Alu and was killed with them.

If Benzine visited an evil person then Jawneh is lying and probably evil.

I'm kind of confused on how whatever Benzine decided to do in drunken haze last night makes me an acolyte? Not to mention, since I didn't before lolol, I'm the mysterious, gorgeous, and most definitely indestructible  hero who saved the poor wretched orphan from being mauled by you savages yesterday. If only i had the power of seeing the future, i could warned the little cunt about who to go begging next from. Sigh.

Also, might everyone tell their occupation at this portion of the game, perchance? To try to raise our chances of glorious victory!

 

[Jon]

Lol now voting for somebody on day two is suspicious?

I think he was saying it more about WHO you voted for than the fact you did. Benzine turned out to be good, which the acolytes would know, and they are less likely to go questing. So it makes it sus who didn't quest day 2 and who they voted for.

and most definitely indestructible  hero who saved the poor wretched orphan from being mauled by you savages yesterday

So let me confirm what you're saying: Benzine visited you NIGHT 1, revealed he was the orphan to you, and you used your hero power to save him from witch hunt in DAY 2. He did NOT visit you again NIGHT 2. Is that what you're saying?

Also, might everyone tell their occupation at this portion of the game, perchance? To try to raise our chances of glorious victory!

I've been pretty open about being the vampire hunter. No one else has claimed a solo non violent role, and I found vampire Christina (STILL WHAT ARE THE FUCKING ODDS!?) and she was killed, which SHOULD confirm my claim unless you're all heathens.

You're now claiming hero and I don't know if anyone else has made a claim that is still alive. The myriad of death taking out 3 town and 1 acolyte last night is going to be tough to overcome. There is 3 town, 3 acolytes and the solo non-violent left.

If you're really the hero, and this does fit and no one else is claiming they saved Benzine, then it stands to reason the acolytes are Kat, Tommy and dimmerwit. The remaining town would then be you, Quagmire and Local. And I'm the solo.

 

[Local Hero]

Vampire Christina (STILL WHAT ARE THE FUCKING ODDS!?)

 

[Quagmire]

@shortkut @dimmerwit and @Quagmire have not yet posted.

Kut and dimmer have seen the thread.

We may have a Warlock.

I'm here!

 

[Quagmire]

Two pages is way too much to read , why are we voting tommy?

If no one wants to enable my laziness I'll browse back when I get home and I'm not on my phone

 

[Local Hero]

Two pages is way too much to read , why are we voting tommy?

If no one wants to enable my laziness I'll browse back when I get home and I'm not on my phone

I think Tommy, Kat, and dimmer are evil. Jon, who claims non violent solo, wants to vote Tommy.

I was on dimmer before but switched to satisfy Jon. Any dead acolyte is a good acolyte.

 

[Jon]

I think Tommy, Kat, and dimmer are evil. Jon, who claims non violent solo, wants to vote Tommy.

I was on dimmer before but switched to satisfy Jon. Any dead acolyte is a good acolyte.

Don't vote to satisfy me. I've already met my win condition lol.

Technically I'm the kingmaker. I just haven't had a reason to go against the town, but in reality, I don't care who wins lol. I'm simply providing my opinions. You townies should be conversing to find acolytes and convincing me to vote with you.

 

[finlandguy]

So let me confirm what you're saying: Benzine visited you NIGHT 1, revealed he was the orphan to you, and you used your hero power to save him from witch hunt in DAY 2. He did NOT visit you again NIGHT 2. Is that what you're saying?

Night 1 I just got a filthy little orphan visit me and I booted him in the face and told to screw off. I didn't want to spend my hard earned gold then. Night 2, after making money questing, I could spare the 3 gold. And on the metagame side I figured it was him, but better safe than sorry. Considering his drunken rambling yesterday he would've come bug me again for sure if I didn't lmao.

I've been pretty open about being the vampire hunter. No one else has claimed a solo non violent role, and I found vampire Christina (STILL WHAT ARE THE FUCKING ODDS!?) and she was killed, which SHOULD confirm my claim unless you're all heathens.

You're now claiming hero and I don't know if anyone else has made a claim that is still alive. The myriad of death taking out 3 town and 1 acolyte last night is going to be tough to overcome. There is 3 town, 3 acolytes and the solo non-violent left.

If you're really the hero, and this does fit and no one else is claiming they saved Benzine, then it stands to reason the acolytes are Kat, Tommy and dimmerwit. The remaining town would then be you, Quagmire and Local. And I'm the solo.

I skipped most of day 1 as I was busy and also forgot twice that this game had started. So anything said then I got no memory of.

Was there anything said or show that proves Quagmire and Local? Feels wise, I'm currently leaning towards believing Local, but that's about as much as I got. I saw the mention of the three vote block trying to off Benzine. Is that the main thing? For today I feel it's a good bet unless anyone has anything else.

 

[Local Hero]

Believe your eyes. Everyone went questing yesterday except the acolytes so they could vote for benzine. I didn't think they would be so bold so soon.

 

[Tommy Boy]

Believe your eyes. Everyone went questing yesterday except the acolytes so they could vote for benzine. I didn't think they would be so bold so soon.

Yeah but since I haven't gone questing, I made my reasoning clear on both days and was the first to provide that explanation. It shouldn't automatically make me guilty just because I was the first one to vote for Benzine, literally telling the village I got nothin to go off of and don't mind switching to someone else. Hell, I thought I was the only one that didn't quest to even have a say. Either way, the vote failed because someone protected him, which worked out. But the SK killed Benzine - not me, or my vote for him.

I cannot do much other than hide - I have always been clear about this. There's just no way to prove my role. Out of everyone who has been asked to role claim, people were awfully quiet to step up and reveal. I wasn't - what do I have to lose? When I'm a baddie I tend to shut down and fuck myself over, acting as a subconscious passenger. I don't really think that's been the case this game. I've wanted to participate in voting which should NOT make me look suspicious as that's our actual objective - to remove the acolytes. I refrained from questing to prevent injury and to be able to vote - essentially acting as a legacy player to avoid losing a town vote and also losing my life.

But we have what, two or three people alive that can just stumble in, radda radda radda, were muted all day, don't really have to go out of their way to engage? But just because I was the only one to stay back and vote, a vote that DIDN'T EVEN GO THROUGH, I am guilty??????

Not for nothing, but I hid/protected you last night because I am under the impression that you have a power that is useful to the town. Wondering if I made a mistake now.

 

[Ants!]

Don't vote to satisfy me. I've already met my win condition lol.

Technically I'm the kingmaker. I just haven't had a reason to go against the town, but in reality, I don't care who wins lol. I'm simply providing my opinions. You townies should be conversing to find acolytes and convincing me to vote with you.

I figured this went without saying, but you also have to survive to the end to meet that winning condition.

 

[Jon]

I figured this went without saying, but you also have to survive to the end to meet that winning condition.

I assumed as much based on the wording. But I don't expect to live, just via spite. Meeting my win condition means I can win WITH either team. I do not hinder or help either of their win conditions.

In reality, both sides should want me alive for the same reason, numbers.

But I suspect I'll get killed in a "fuck you" manner lol. So I just count myself as a moral victory that I met my win condition and helped both sides.

The dice can fall however they will. If someone wants to convince me to vote otherwise, I won't stop them.

 

[Local Hero]

All non acolytes are voting for Tommy.

Skip

 

[Jon]

I'm going to move to no vote for now. I'd like to see where everything goes before putting a vote down. I have no qualms voting for anyone.

 

[Local Hero]

I have no qualms voting for anyone.

Then why were you against voting for dimmer when I first suggested it?

 

[Jon]

Then why were you against voting for dimmer when I first suggested it?

Did I say I was against it? I seriously don't recall, lol.