A lame dead thread

[A Punched Face]

Just vote until everyone is dead

 

[canadaguy]

Well that was not what I expected

 

[Zell 17]

Hello to @GwJumpman

 

[GwJumpman]

lol hi

 

[A Punched Face]

I feel like the Serial Killer has a decent shot at this game compared to most times for the RK role.

 

[canadaguy]

I am pretty sure I am not actually good at these games.

Like I can figure out 1 wolf, maybe 2 per game, but sussing out the whole team? No way Jose

 

[shortkut]

Fools is the SK then

I really thought he and Kelly were wolves together, but I think there is only 1 left

 

[A Punched Face]

2-3 evils to not evils.

If there's no lynch today of one of the two, that seals it up as a second consecutive town loss, right? Well I mean unless the SK decides to kill off the last wolf in the ensuing night phase.

 

[Zell 17]

@Jon and @Kat are here

 

[Zell 17]

For those wondering, Kat had Benzine marked when she went offline. I'm guessing she would have suicided the night everyone died had she been online.

 

[canadaguy]

So Jon being Bodyguard should mean Kelly is doomed this lynch yeah?

 

[A Punched Face]

I wonder if her doing that would have changed the calculus at all for anyone, having another confirmed townie there.

 

[Zell 17]

Let's play it out. Village votes out Kelly. Fools gets killed off at night.

Local decides between Tommy and dimmerwit?

 

[Zell 17]

I wonder if her doing that would have changed the calculus at all for anyone, having another confirmed townie there.

Benzine would have still died the same night

 

[canadaguy]

Benzine would have still died the same night

I think he's saying it tightens the range of who could be a wolf. Like during yesterday's day phase, was anyone considering her to be a wolf?

 

[A Punched Face]

So Jon being Bodyguard should mean Kelly is doomed this lynch yeah?

Unless people are weird.

Let's play it out. Village votes out Kelly. Fool's gets killed off at night.

Local decides between Tommy and dimmerwit?

Give Local more bullets.

 

[A Punched Face]

I think he's saying it tightens the range of who could be a wolf. Like during yesterday's day phase, was anyone considering her to be a wolf?

Yeah, that was my point there.

 

[canadaguy]

Unless people are weird.

Give Local more bullets.

I mean, if it plays out like Zell is suggesting, essentially Local does get a reload on the last day

 

[Jon]

So, wait, did the SK have me marked too? How'd I die?

 

[canadaguy]

I think townies should lay everything out on the table today.

 

[Zell 17]

So, wait, did the SK have me marked too? How'd I die?

Yep, you got hit by the SK and the wolves.

 

[shortkut]

@Zell 17 , if you want to manually adjust the RNG so I get a daytime kill role, I will kill someone with my first post in that game, even if I am the first poster of the game

 

[A Punched Face]

So, wait, did the SK have me marked too? How'd I die?

Teamwork makes the dream work.

Also it kills Jon.

 

[Jon]

Yep, you got hit by the SK and the wolves.

Didn't the SK kill last night? How'd they have time to queue up two more names? I is confused methinks

 

[Jon]

Teamwork makes the dream work.

Also it kills Jon.

Jon does a good job of this on his own.

 

[Jon]

Was I right at least? FR is the last wolf and Kelly is the SK?

 

[Zell 17]

Didn't the SK kill last night? How'd they have time to queue up two more names? I is confused methinks

Night 1: No kill (stack)
Night 2: No kill (2 kills available, stacks)
Night 3: Two kills (1 kill remaining, stacks)
Night 4: Two kills (none remaining)

 

[canadaguy]

Was I right at least? FR is the last wolf and Kelly is the SK?

rk had deleted a post that outed Kelly as a wolf, but who knows that may have been subterfuge. Although it would only be tricking people already dead and unable to come back to life

 

[Jon]

Night 1: No kill (stack)
Night 2: No kill (2 kills available, stacks)
Night 3: Two kills (1 kill remaining, stacks)
Night 4: Two kills (none remaining)

OIC, I misunderstood how the stacks work is all. Okie dokey.

 

[shortkut]

rk had deleted a post that outed Kelly as a wolf, but who knows that may have been subterfuge. Although it would only be tricking people already dead and unable to come back to life

Also it was deleted, so that seems like it was an accident

 

[Jon]

rk had deleted a post that outed Kelly as a wolf, but who knows that may have been subterfuge. Although it would only be tricking people already dead and unable to come back to life

Yeah, didn't see it. Even if he's not the SK, I have him and FR as bad. Interested in how FR survived lynch then...

 

[canadaguy]

Also it was deleted, so that seems like it was an accident

I just assumed they deleted it to hide the evidence.


Evidence that only dead people could use

 

[shortkut]

I just assumed they deleted it to hide the evidence.


Evidence that only dead people could use

 

[canadaguy]

Yeah, didn't see it. Even if he's not the SK, I have him and FR as bad. Interested in how FR survived lynch then...

Yeah I was convinced FR and Kelly were the wolves and all the back and forth was just to create deniability if one died.

 

[A Punched Face]

Yeah, didn't see it. Even if he's not the SK, I have him and FR as bad. Interested in how FR survived lynch then...

A mysterious force prevented him from being lynched.

 

[canadaguy]

Ok so what confuses me.

If Kelly is the last wolf, why would he target Jon? His big claim was that Jon was "Unknown", so killing Jon and proving that wrong implicates himself.

 

[Zell 17]

@VashTheStampede we miss you

 

[Jon]

Yeah I was convinced FR and Kelly were the wolves and all the back and forth was just to create deniability if one died.

Yeah, I had questions about FR from the beginning. But as soon as Kelly read me as neutral, he was my prime SK candidate.

A mysterious force prevented him from being lynched.

lol, smartass.

This isn't Fallout, I wanna know the mysterious figure if he's not the guardian wolf.

 

[Jon]

Ok so what confuses me.

If Kelly is the last wolf, why would he target Jon? His big claim was that Jon was "Unknown", so killing Jon and proving that wrong implicates himself.

This is why I figured I was safe at least tonight but would be targeted by the SK. Figured I'd out my role once my "extra" life was used up and go from there. Getting pegged by both the wolves and SK was a little shocking to me. Kelly would want me alive and FR had me focusing on Kelly (which means I wasn't in on him yet). So, I'm definitely missing something here.

 

[A Punched Face]

Ok so what confuses me.

If Kelly is the last wolf, why would he target Jon? His big claim was that Jon was "Unknown", so killing Jon and proving that wrong implicates himself.

Jon was also pretty clearly saying he was either the TG or Bodyguard earlier when he said he thought he'd be notified of being hit by an illusionist. I'm not sure why either the wolves or SK would target him with the odds of Tough Guy being there.

Also Jon, did I actually answer your question you had about that earlier when I said Zell pointed out in the last game that TG/Body Guard wouldn't be notified of the Illusionist attack until he tried to actually kill him, and not just the disguise?

 

[VashTheStampede]

@VashTheStampede we miss you

Sorry I haven't been super active, got temporarily transferred to another store that basically hit an iceberg a month ago so I don't have near as much time to goof off on my phone.

Plus my commute has been doubled in length.

 

[A Punched Face]

Sorry I haven't been super active, got temporarily transferred to another store that basically hit an iceberg a month ago so I don't have near as much time to goof off on my phone.

Plus my commute has been doubled in length.

I'm glad your commute didn't involve an iceberg

 

[shortkut]

Sorry I haven't been super active, got temporarily transferred to another store that basically hit an iceberg a month ago so I don't have near as much time to goof off on my phone.

Plus my commute has been doubled in length.

Shut down the store and return to your normal store. Problem solved

 

[VashTheStampede]

I'm glad your commute didn't involve an iceberg

yeah its a little hot out this way

Kinda troubling that they found one to hit really

 

[canadaguy]

Also Jon, did I actually answer your question you had about that earlier when I said Zell pointed out in the last game that TG/Body Guard wouldn't be notified of the Illusionist attack until he tried to actually kill him, and not just the disguise?

Ahhhh yes that old beast lol

 

[VashTheStampede]

Shut down the store and return to your normal store. Problem solved

so yeah I think that's the actual plan but it's gonna take at least a few months

I'll post about it in my blog thing soonish

 

[Jon]

Also Jon, did I actually answer your question you had about that earlier when I said Zell pointed out in the last game that TG/Body Guard wouldn't be notified of the Illusionist attack until he tried to actually kill him, and not just the disguise?

Yes, a little.

I feel as if the wording SHOULD notify the BG if he's attacked by the illusionist. The wording says "Disguising is treated as a "normal solo killer attack" for the purposes of being blocked."

Which by my understanding would notify the BG that he's blocked an attack. Or taken an attack. Not that it was an illusionist or anything, but I feel they SHOULD be told based on that.

 

[A Punched Face]

Ahhhh yes that old beast lol

The one you're most familiar with.

 

[canadaguy]

A few years back we went to Newfoundland and took a boat tour and got to see an iceberg up close. Shit's pretty cool

 

[Jon]

Jon was also pretty clearly saying he was either the TG or Bodyguard earlier when he said he thought he'd be notified of being hit by an illusionist. I'm not sure why either the wolves or SK would target him with the odds of Tough Guy being there.

Also... this is a good point. It feels like the SK and last wolf are working together. It was INCREDIBLY lucky that the last wolf had the SK attack me too.