The Netherealm

[Smacktard]

Kat's doing awesome. I wish more people would listen to her, and pay attention to the wolves trying to smear her

 

[Zell 17]

Kat's doing awesome. I wish more people would listen to her, and pay attention to the wolves trying to smear her

Yeah. I mentioned this in the last thread but I don't think people really took notice. If I was a villager I'd put people in categories.

First, establish if there are any protectors. Strategy changes depending. Jailer/Warden don't count. Beast Hunter WOULD count.

Then I would want my strong villagers to claim. You won't be protected if you don't claim, but the wolves will still find you. Kelly and canadaguy are both proof. Ritualist spell should always go on the Jailer/Warden if they exist, and the Ritualist should claim. Conjuror should not claim. Medium should not claim until after they have revived.

Then I push the regular villagers who didn't claim protector. Are you provable? (Marksman/Witch/Librarian/Judge all provable). Are you a seer that we would expect to have nightly info (Aura Seer, SS, Violinist, Red Lady). If you aren't any of the above, you're on the chopping block. Which is a lot of people in this game! That would be:

shortkut
FR
Benzine
Kat
Jawneh
Vash
GwJumpman

But, FR was good by Aura night 1. So scratch him for now. Honestly, if I saw two seer apprentice claims, I'd probably kill Dean night 1. If he is fake, great. If he is NOT fake, now you suddenly doubled your aura seers AND confirmed for all time that Fool's is good.

 

[Smacktard]

If he is NOT fake, now you suddenly doubled your aura seers AND confirmed for all time that Fool's is good.

I was thinking exactly this. The only thing I didn't realize is that killing the seer wouldake BOTH apprentices seers. I thought one would be randomly selected for promotion and the other would remain an apprentice.

 

[Zell 17]

I was thinking exactly this. The only thing I didn't realize is that killing the seer wouldake BOTH apprentices seers. I thought one would be randomly selected for promotion and the other would remain an apprentice.

Nah, because that would give the "Non-promoted" seer apprentice information. They would see a seer dead, they would know they weren't promoted, so they would know that there must be another seer apprentice out there that's promoted.

 

[Smacktard]

Nah, because that would give the "Non-promoted" seer apprentice information. They would see a seer dead, they would know they weren't promoted, so they would know that there must be another seer apprentice out there that's promoted.

Maybe change the role description to the following to remove any potential clarity issues:

Initially has no powers or abilities. However, if a seer dies, all apprentices will transform into the dead seer's role during the day. The following roles count as “seers” for this ability: Aura Seer, Detective, Sheriff, Spirit Seer, Violinist. If the person the Apprentice transformed into is revived, the Apprentice will revert back to an Apprentice with no powers.

 

[Zell 17]

Yeah I meant for that to say they transform "Immediately" as well.

Can't edit it now midgame though.

 

[Zell 17]

Wolves commented that the game is going slow. It's not often that a game gets to day 3 with double digit players remaining. This looks like it might be a 7 or 8 day game.

 

[shortkut]

So now there are 2 sheriffs?

 

[Zell 17]

So now there are 2 sheriffs?

Yup. Almost as useful as seer apprentice.

 

[Smacktard]

Kat's plan is fuckin fantastic. She's MVP for the town so far IMO. Without her the town would be completely lost

 

[Zell 17]

Kat's plan is fuckin fantastic. She's MVP for the town so far IMO. Without her the town would be completely lost

Downside is it kills her, so they get Dean then they're lost again

 

[Smacktard]

Downside is it kills her, so they get Dean then they're lost again

True, but it does give them a bit more breathing room. Also, Benzine seems keen to go after Jon so they're closing in on the wolves. Still anyone's game tho

 

[shortkut]

Kat's plan is fuckin fantastic. She's MVP for the town so far IMO. Without her the town would be completely lost

I haven’t read a post this day phase yet

 

[shortkut]

I haven’t read a post this day phase yet

(That’s someone’s cue to summarize for me)

 

[Smacktard]

(That’s someone’s cue to summarize for me)

Ben: plan
Kat: plan++
Benzine: bloodthirsty
Wolves: anti-Kat
Everyone else: passengers

 

[shortkut]

Ben: plan
Kat: plan++
Benzine: bloodthirsty
Wolves: anti-Kat
Everyone else: passengers

I wonder if the wolves are anti-Kat because I told TD in jail I was suspicious of her so they think she’s an easy target

 

[Smacktard]

I wonder if the wolves are anti-Kat because I told TD in jail I was suspicious of her so they think she’s an easy target

They've been going after her since day 1 because she is the only one who has attempted to provide a plan so far

 

[Smacktard]

Dean's backstory is starting to fall apart...

 

[Zell 17]

Anyone wanna guess where Tubby's trap is????

 

[Local Hero]

Without looking at the thread, TD?

 

[Local Hero]

Or Rain

 

[Local Hero]

Looking at his last post. I wouldn't be surprised if it was Dean

 

[shortkut]

They've been going after her since day 1 because she is the only one who has attempted to provide a plan so far

That’s how little I’ve paid attention this game

 

[Jawneh]

I'll say Jon. Spread the love.

 

[Zell 17]

I'm disappointed

 

[Jawneh]

I guess up his own butt then.

 

[Local Hero]

Post in thread 'GWF Zell Wolf Version XI Day 3' https://gwforums.com/threads/gwf-zell-wolf-version-xi-day-3.1379/post-81892

 

[Smacktard]

FR is not helping the town at all here.

 

[Zell 17]

I wonder what TD's strategy is here from a couple perspective. He has a real problem in that every other wolf can outvote him for the night kill.

 

[shortkut]

I wonder what TD's strategy is here from a couple perspective. He has a real problem in that every other wolf can outvote him for the night kill.

He probably isn’t used to living this long

 

[shortkut]

FR is not helping the town at all here.

I still haven’t read the thread but he’s a dumdum

Edit: FR, dumdum is a term of endearment

 

[Smacktard]

I wonder what TD's strategy is here from a couple perspective. He has a real problem in that every other wolf can outvote him for the night kill.

I'd say he guides the wolves away from Raine because he can "rein her in" and he suggests one of his wolves sacrifice himself to throw the town off the rest of their scent.

At this rate it honestly looks like the Couple has the best shot at winning here unless the town starts getting its act together.

 

[Zell 17]

If I was TD I would JUMP on the opportunity to have the village vote out Kat with her tagging Dean.

 

[Zell 17]

The sheriffs are dangerous for TD too...again, he's the weakest wolf so they would see him.

 

[Smacktard]

If I'm Ben, I 100% choose the guy who says "don't choose me". I don't even think about it.

If I'm Vash, I say "take me". Hell, whether I'm good or bad I say "take me".

 

[Smacktard]

The sheriffs are dangerous for TD too...again, he's the weakest wolf so they would see him.

So how does the seer apprentice work? I'm still not getting it. I thought if more than one seer was drawn, they would become a seer apprentice. But we have two seers -- sheriff shortkut and and detective Raine. And when Kut died, the two seer apprentices became sheriff.

Why do two seers exist? Is it because one is strong and the other is regular?

If Raine died, would the two seer apprentices become detectives instead?

 

[Smacktard]

Dean going from
"NOOOO FR IS GOOD DONT HURT HIM"
to
"you can lynch FR now lmao"
...and the town going
"yeah that makes sense"

 

[Zell 17]

So how does the seer apprentice work? I'm still not getting it. I thought if more than one seer was drawn, they would become a seer apprentice. But we have two seers -- sheriff shortkut and and detective Raine. And when Kut died, the two seer apprentices became sheriff.

Why do two seers exist? Is it because one is strong and the other is regular?

If Raine died, would the two seer apprentices become detectives instead?

The seers apprentice are randomly drawn. The fact that they exist in the game don't imply that ANY other role exists or any other kind of seer at all.

Yes, if Raine died they would both become Detectives.

 

[Smacktard]

The seers apprentice are randomly drawn. The fact that they exist in the game don't imply that ANY other role exists or any other kind of seer at all.

I thought I remembered reading that any time more than one seer was drawn, they would become a seer apprentice instead for balance purposes

 

[Smacktard]

Town says TD is exempt from the vote because he was an early voter for Jawneh

But now town is going after Benzine who was the first vote for Jawneh

wat.

I kept specifically addressing TD yesterday and the day before. Why did no one pick up on that if they're wondering who'd I trust?

Why are they still even listening to Cupid?

 

[Smacktard]

<3 Benzine

Yes I'm talking to myself, no I don't care

 

[shortkut]

Town says TD is exempt from the vote because he was an early voter for Jawneh

But now town is going after Benzine who was the first vote for Jawneh

wat.

I kept specifically addressing TD yesterday and the day before. Why did no one pick up on that if they're wondering who'd I trust?

Why are they still even listening to Cupid?

At least I was pro-town when I was cupid

 

[shortkut]

<3 Benzine

Yes I'm talking to myself, no I don't care

I would join you but I’ll probably read the thread once the day is over

 

[Jawneh]

Town says TD is exempt from the vote because he was an early voter for Jawneh

But now town is going after Benzine who was the first vote for Jawneh

wat.

I kept specifically addressing TD yesterday and the day before. Why did no one pick up on that if they're wondering who'd I trust?

Why are they still even listening to Cupid?

His vote for me and mine for him are null and void on day 1. Means nothing.

But I'll be glad if that vote is the death of him.

 

[Zell 17]

Welp I see Dean does not have trouble with lying. Love it.

 

[Christina]

Instead of pressing start on my timer I pressed off on the oven. I melted my cookies!

 

[Smacktard]

His vote for me and mine for him are null and void on day 1. Means nothing.

Nah he usually takes your vote for him in stride and kinda ignores it

 

[Christina]

Ok this is not a good recipe. The other ones cooked at the proper temp meltee worse somehow. They are very tasty though.

 

[Local Hero]

Vash will still eat it

 

[Christina]

I made a tasty snickerdoodle cake? Pancake?