Kat’s Wolf Wolf - fewer roles version - Day 4

[Kat]

Gimme that dead thread

I'll move both this and the dead thread to the game over forum.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Ughhhh this one hurts. I fuckin tried lol

 

[Jon]

@Tommy Boy - I'm sorry I had to deceive you. You have NO idea how much that hurt. I tried to win as a wolf while being... 80% truthful lol.

@VashTheStampede - Kudos on killing two of us.

@Fool's Requiem - If they had listened to you about Tubby, town wins there because there is no chance I get down to a 1v1 with the village. I will say this too... the wolves of wallstreet one of us was COMPLETELY coincidental. I really was looking for a one of us meme.

@shortkut - I'm sorry I had to turn you into a sacrificial lamb.

@Tubby23 - Get well soon, man. We missed you here.

@Jawneh and @canadaguy - Thanks for being my wolves in arms.

@Kat - thank you for running this... and for keeping me a semblance of company in the wolf chat when I was all alone.

@everyone else - thank you for a great game!

Again, I felt very icky about this game.

 

[shortkut]

Man, sure sounds like kut should have helped us kill Tubby after all

Depends, was he a wolf or not?

 

[TD]

Ughhhh this one hurts. I fuckin tried lol

You killed it.

literally and figuratively

 

[Jon]

Depends, was he a wolf or not?

He was, yes

 

[VashTheStampede]

@VashTheStampede - Kudos on killing two of us.

Had a third all lined up and if kut votes with us, I don't convince myself he's in it with him.

Blahhhhh

 

[Kat]

Here's everyone's role:

Name	Number	Role
@Dean	1​	Witch
@canadaguy	2​	Wolf Trickster
@Jon	3​	Berserk Wolf
@Fool's Requiem	4​	Baker
@A Somer Special	5​	Tough Guy
@Raine	6​	Marksman
@Zell 17	7​	Evil Detective
@Benzine	8​	Priest
@Jawneh	9​	Wolf Trickster
@Tubby23	10​	Confusion Wolf
@GwJumpman	11​	Bodyguard
@Tommy Boy	12​	Blacksmith
@Local Hero	13​	School Teacher
@shortkut	14​	Jeweler
@VashTheStampede	15​	Marksman
@Smacktard	16​	Doctor

I let the wolves vote to use Tubby's power. I would've swapped his role with a powerless townie if he were on that team. It seemed like the most fair way to keep it somewhat balanced without giving anything away.

 

[TD]

There were  two tricksters.
Interesting.

Great job hosting Kat!

 

[finlandguy]

Some amusing facts, some of which were already discussed pointed out in the dead thread:

How far can GW townies fall and still nearly win a game of wolf:
- One person be AWOL for the whole game (Tubby)
- One wolf miss the whole night 1 and day 1 (me)
- Wolves miss night 1 kill (hit SK)
- Townie blocking SK kill on a wolf (Jumpy protecting Tubby)
- Town not lynching in at least two days
- Get SK murdered too early
- Have a teamkill count of at least 3 (Alu, Benzine, Raine)
- Not know anything about any actual roles apart from a powerless townie from night 1

 

[Kat]

What did everybody think of not having any seers? Would you want to play a game like that again or would you prefer to have at least one or two seers?

I was thinking for the next game, I'd have a couple seers but also have wolf roles that make them not trustworthy (like wolf shaman and trickster). I think it'd give people more to talk about but still keep things interesting.

 

[finlandguy]

Other things, the random wolf was another trickster wolf. I got Alu trix'd, but weirdly enough, he was killed during confusion and then I was killed during confusion, so in the end, especially without aura seers, it was completely useless lol.

 

[Tommy Boy]

What did everybody think of not having any seers? Would you want to play a game like that again or would you prefer to have at least one or two seers?

I was thinking for the next game, I'd have a couple seers but also have wolf roles that make them not trustworthy (like wolf shaman and trickster). I think it'd give people more to talk about but still keep things interesting.

I liked it, honestly.

I think a game with no active roles shown to the players would be interesting. It would make it impossible to make an accurate chart to check role claims. Anyone can role claim and there's no way to narrow it down.

GG everyone!

 

[TD]

What did everybody think of not having any seers? Would you want to play a game like that again or would you prefer to have at least one or two seers?

I'm fine having no seers but if I'm being honest - I don't think a NO seer approach works great for this group (at least not at this point).

I think having at least one seer is ideal.

Also if there's no seers, definitely need to lower that minimum lynch count.

 

[VashTheStampede]

 

[A Maybe Baker]

What did everybody think of not having any seers? Would you want to play a game like that again or would you prefer to have at least one or two seers?

I was thinking for the next game, I'd have a couple seers but also have wolf roles that make them not trustworthy (like wolf shaman and trickster). I think it'd give people more to talk about but still keep things interesting.

I liked it, definitely added some flavor to it

 

[Kat]

I think a game with no active roles shown to the players would be interesting. It would make it impossible to make an accurate chart to check role claims. Anyone can role claim and there's no way to narrow it down.

Oooh I like this idea.

 

[Zell 17]

But god DAMN that pure lucked into BS about claiming checking CG and me! Better lucky than good!

I really did have NO idea about the spirit seer role though.

I don't know I thought it was pretty clear honestly. I mean, the only people who fight claiming in every game are always 100% wolves.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Jon says he thinks FR is a wolf when he's clearly been trying to help the town. FR's never put in this much effort as a wolf before when he was on my team as a wolf (3 times!), but I've seen him work hard as a townie before. Jon says he thinks Tubby is a wolf, but indicates he's going to vote for FR instead of Tubby.

I tend to not know what to do when playing wolf. Like Tommy, I'm not good at lying. I can't do the "I know I'm good, so all I need to do is prove it" thing when I'm a baddy. It's going to make every time I play as wolf/solo killer a pain in the ass for me and a potential liability for the wolves.

Nah Jon revealed himself when he instantly said I was the serial killer and not a wolf. And Jawneh backed him. Tubby is the other wolf and shortkut is dumb.

I don't know how I missed that, can you link it? I went through the threads numerous times looking for stuff.

@VashTheStampede I'm sorry, dude, I almost swapped to voting Jon a million times, but was constantly worried about falling for a wolf ploy like I did in the very first Wolf game I played in the old forum. I was right at the very beginning of the last day, but each time kut posted, it made it made me more convinced he was trying to trick me into switching votes so he could win.

 

[Kat]

I don't know I thought it was pretty clear honestly. I mean, the only people who fight claiming in every game are always 100% wolves.

I think this is a coincidence and Jon really doesn't like to role claim, regardless of team.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

I also feel like I let the people down who said I was going to carry the game.

 

[A Maybe Baker]

I also feel like I let the people down who said I was going to carry the game.

You tried, and honestly it was pretty well done. Can't get them all.

 

[Zell 17]

I tend to not know what to do when playing wolf. Like Tommy, I'm not good at lying. I can't do the "I know I'm good, so all I need to do is prove it" thing when I'm a baddy. It's going to make every time I play as wolf/solo killer a pain in the ass for me and a potential liability for the wolves.

I don't know how I missed that, can you link it? I went through the threads numerous times looking for stuff.

@VashTheStampede I'm sorry, dude, I almost swapped to voting Jon a million times, but was constantly worried about falling for a wolf ploy like I did in the very first Wolf game I played in the old forum. I was right at the very beginning of the last day, but each time kut posted, it made it made me more convinced he was trying to trick me into switching votes so he could win.

Wolf - fewer roles version - Day 2

As usual, the role dictionary can be found here: https://gwforums.com/threads/zell-wolf-role-dictionary-and-hall-of-fame.427/ And here's the list of players: @Local Hero @canadaguy @Fool's Requiem @Raine @Smacktard @A Somer Special @shortkut @Benzine @Jon @Zell 17 @Tommy Boy @Jawneh @Tubby23...

gwforums.com

Wolf - fewer roles version - Day 2

As usual, the role dictionary can be found here: https://gwforums.com/threads/zell-wolf-role-dictionary-and-hall-of-fame.427/ And here's the list of players: @Local Hero @canadaguy @Fool's Requiem @Raine @Smacktard @A Somer Special @shortkut @Benzine @Jon @Zell 17 @Tommy Boy @Jawneh @Tubby23...

gwforums.com

 

[VashTheStampede]

@VashTheStampede I'm sorry, dude, I almost swapped to voting Jon a million times, but was constantly worried about falling for a wolf ploy like I did in the very first Wolf game I played in the old forum. I was right at the very beginning of the last day, but each time kut posted, it made it made me more convinced he was trying to trick me into switching votes so he could win.

Shoot, don't apologize, you did great, man. You were the only one I was 100% convinced was on my side. And with how much I overthink myself into analysis paralysis, that's impressive.

Honestly overall I'm pretty happy with how the game turned out. Even with completely blowing it at the last second, it was the best I think I've done. Of course, by the time I started firing there really wasn't any pressure because it looked like a hopeless cause.

The previous game had convinced me that I'm shit at this game, so bagging a couple kills was huge for my state of mind.

 

[TD]

One other thing I'll say (although I know recent overall activity is a factor), I feel like activity is higher when everyone has a role that at least does something, even if minor.

 

[Tommy Boy]

I also feel like I let the people down who said I was going to carry the game.

Nope, I switched my vote off you twice. You had believable logic. You stopped getting mad and more or less kept explaining your points. I think you did real good dude.

 

[Kat]

Have we had a Marksman kill two evils with their two shots before? I feel like that deserves a new badge.

 

[finlandguy]

I think this is a coincidence and Jon really doesn't like to role claim, regardless of team.

I'm the same until later in the game when it serves a purpose other than "hey, I'm this unless I'm lying".

 

[Kat]

I also feel like I let the people down who said I was going to carry the game.

Nobody can blame you for finding kut suspicious.

 

[finlandguy]

Have we had a Marksman kill two evils with their two shots before? I feel like that deserves a new badge.

Oh oh, me me! *points at badge*

 

[Zell 17]

I put up a new sign up thread for those who want to keep the momentum rolling

 

[VashTheStampede]

Have we had a Marksman kill two evils with their two shots before? I feel like that deserves a new badge.

Pretty sure Jawneh pulled it off on two separate occasions.

 

[TD]

Have we had a Marksman kill two evils with their two shots before? I feel like that deserves a new badge.

I know Jawneh did it.

He's got the Robin Hood badge for it but it looks like someone gave it to Vash already.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Nobody can blame you for finding kut suspicious.

On the other hand, HE FUCKING TOLD US

 

[finlandguy]

Technically the Robin Hood was supposed to be for doing the double double with both gunner and marksman, but I'm not one to prevent others from getting more shiny badges. It's the spirit that counts.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Technically the Robin Hood was supposed to be for doing the double double with both gunner and marksman, but I'm not one to prevent others from getting more shiny badges. It's the spirit that counts.

Oh shit, thats true.

I don't want to be accused of stolen valor.

 

[Smacktard]

I also feel like I let the people down who said I was going to carry the game.

You're dead to me.

Nah jk I absolutely would've voted shortkut and lost the game for the town lolz. You did well. The odds were stacked against town in the end. We all fucked up too much.

Speaking of fucking up, can wolves tell me now why the picked me Night 1? Was it the gif I used?

 

[TD]

I like how Vash removed the other Marksman badge from his display.

 

[VashTheStampede]

I like how Vash removed the other Marksman badge from his display.

Until I earn it again

 

[shortkut]

@Tubby23

10​

Confusion Wolf

@Kat did tubby choose to use his ability or did the other wolves use it for him? In other games, the specific wolf needs to choose to use their ability and his was used twice

Edit: finished reading the post

 

[Jon]

What did everybody think of not having any seers? Would you want to play a game like that again or would you prefer to have at least one or two seers?

I was thinking for the next game, I'd have a couple seers but also have wolf roles that make them not trustworthy (like wolf shaman and trickster). I think it'd give people more to talk about but still keep things interesting.

I think it was fun!

I think this is a coincidence and Jon really doesn't like to role claim, regardless of team.

THANK YOU! You're the only one that seems to understand this is me regardless. ive done it for both village and wolf and have explained my reasoning numerous times over, even though it's constantly garnered me heat.

Speaking of fucking up, can wolves tell me now why the picked me Night 1? Was it the gif I used?

Literally a hunch on Jawneh's part. He brought it up and we just agreed. no reason not to at that point. We had no inkling to your role.

 

[A Maybe Baker]

@Kat did tubby choose to use his ability or did the other wolves use it for him? In other games, the specific wolf needs to choose to use their ability and his was used twice

I see you're continuing to not read the posts even after the game ends.

 

[Jon]

@Kat did tubby choose to use his ability or did the other wolves use it for him? In other games, the specific wolf needs to choose to use their ability and his was used twice

She let us vote for his power usage.

 

[finlandguy]

Oh shit, thats true.

I don't want to be accused of stolen valor.

No worries. The bullseye one is for you at least.

 

[Smacktard]

Literally a hunch on Jawneh's part. He brought it up and we just agreed. no reason not to at that point. We had no inkling to your role.

Confirmed, @Jawneh seeking revenge for being koala clawed

 

[shortkut]

Confirmed, @Jawneh seeking revenge for being koala clawed

You’d be pissed for getting chlamydia too

 

[Smacktard]

You’d be pissed for getting chlamydia too

Of course. I damn near attacked everyone around me when I found out I was positive

 

[finlandguy]

Confirmed, @Jawneh seeking revenge for being koala clawed

Hey, more often than not I've been good on my hunch on you. This time around it was in reverse, but it still stands to my teams advantage.

 

[canadaguy]

Hey all sorry for going AWOL, got wrapped up in a bunch of stuff

Bravo Jon

 

[shortkut]

Hey all sorry for going AWOL, got wrapped up in a bunch of stuff

Bravo Jon

I thought tubby was the MVP. Jon didn’t do much, it was just fool and I not trusting each other