Wolf Christmas Party at Nakatomi Plaza Day 3

[Jawneh]

Even though us wolves played kind of freely without good plans, though Fool's made a nice hit on Jon before he was gone, it did end up being super stacked against the evils.

Although maybe if Jon didn't die right away the game would've been better for the evils? I do have to complain about the judge being able to judge at any point during the day and not at the end of the day.

Special Agent John "Kat" McClane is another thing too. Maybe too overpowered. We did get an attempt on her, but didn't get the 1/7 after.

I still had fun counting ducks!

 

[VashTheStampede]

You have killed enough townies for multiple life times, your revenge thirst is quenched for you and generations of your family

Ughhhhh

 

[dimmerwit]

I've been talking about the SK all this time and nobody corrected me yet until you did just now lol

I did say earlier that all your kills would only work if the person killed was on the other team, and so it was impossible for there to be more than one baddie left.

So you definitely nailed 3 baddies, it was just a question of if there were two real Tricksters or if one was the solo disguised. Then I finally read the description and with a wolf kill last night it could only have been the latter.

 

[Quagmire]

Although maybe if Jon didn't die right away the game would've been better for the evils? I do have to complain about the judge being able to judge at any point during the day and not at the end of the day.

It is a risk reward thing, judging before the day is over risks killing the judge AND the person if that person is a townie. Where at end of day at most one person can die

Special Agent John "Kat" McClane is another thing too. Maybe too overpowered. We did get an attempt on her, but didn't get the 1/7 after.

Yeah I will probably turn that to 1/4. I just thought about locations in the movie

 

[A Fifth of a Million]

I love how you were like not dropping a gun, but then Ants was like I want to kill and you were easily swayed

It was the combination of that and the realization that he used up all his powers. Seemed lower risk to either have him kill another baddie or to prove FR to me, especially with FRs claimed role.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Being banished from the game and not even being able to participate in dead thread was a massive drag, but I'm sure it was funny for some of y'all

 

[Ants!]

When FR posted the Uno Reverse gif as his last message in the Warden chat, I thought "oh that must mean he's good and I'm about to die instead. Oh well, no regrets, I had fun!"

And then I wake up this morning and find out he was bad after all.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

would like to play a wolf game where we don't get extremely unlucky early on with random kills. I wouldn't have played that any differently as a townie save for the BS role claim while jailed. Had to claim a role there, there was no reason not to. Felt Defender was a solid role claim for a Wolf.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

When FR posted the Uno Reverse gif as his last message in the Warden chat, I thought "oh that must mean he's good and I'm about to die instead. Oh well, no regrets, I had fun!"

And then I wake up this morning and find out he was bad after all.

had to do that JUST in case Trickster Wolf somehow impacted Warden kill attempts. Don't think a Trickster Wolf has ever been put in this position. Still don't know if it would because Jon just had to be SK.

 

[Christina]

My request would be for Hans to be a little more powerful. I got a choice up front but after that had no ability to really do anything extra.

 

[Quagmire]

Being banished from the game and not even being able to participate in dead thread was a massive drag, but I'm sure it was funny for some of y'all

Learn trigger discipline!

 

[Christina]

Learn trigger discipline!

That's no fun!

 

[dimmerwit]

I was about to splash, then Vash attacked and Ants judged.

 

[Quagmire]

My request would be for Hans to be a little more powerful. I got a choice up front but after that had no ability to really do anything extra.

I didnt really have anything good for him he was pretty much a direct Alpha Wolf

And Special Agent needs to be nerfed a little

 

[Jawneh]

Being banished from the game and not even being able to participate in dead thread was a massive drag, but I'm sure it was funny for some of y'all

I honestly didn't even realize what was going on with you lol. Okay, Vash is a gunner, but... he's not really here anymore? Though technically worked in the wolves favor so I wasn't poking that during the game.

 

[dimmerwit]

Vash could have come back by blocking a lynch. He would have lost his second bullet though.

 

[Christina]

They didn't even try and lynch anybody so that Vash could make a return. That's what I didn't understand. Could have out Ants up for Vash to save or something just to get him out of limbo and have better numbers encase things went side ways.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Vash could have come back by blocking a lynch. He would have lost his second bullet though.

There wasn't an attempted lynch for me to stop.

 

[VashTheStampede]

They didn't even try and lynch anybody so that Vash could make a return. That's what I didn't understand. Could have out Ants up for Vash to save or something just to get him out of limbo and have better numbers encase things went side ways.

Honestly no one else probably even knew the role

 

[Jawneh]

It is a risk reward thing, judging before the day is over risks killing the judge AND the person if that person is a townie. Where at end of day at most one person can die

I would still argue to keep it at the end of the day thanks to being able to use it twice. I don't think it made any difference this game, as there were no lynches after judgeings, but it could've been much worse very fast if folks also got a lynch off.

That is my opinion though. Could be totally different if the judge chooses wrong and suddenly it's a big swing the other way. This game it just ended up being nearly completely worse case scenario for the evils.

 

[A Fifth of a Million]

Honestly no one else probably even knew the role

I had 0 idea. We did a lot of driving around the past couple days and I get motion sickness if I stare at my phone for too long in a moving car.

 

[VashTheStampede]

I had 0 idea. We did a lot of driving around the past couple days and I get motion sickness if I stare at my phone for too long in a moving car.

It wasn't an indictment of anyone, just makes sense. Why would anyone go and read a role of someone after they've "died"?

 

[Ants!]

Quagmire did keep mentioning that Vash could come back. I should have looked deeper into that but I didn't because I just assumed he was referring to one of the talk-to-dead roles that could revive people.

I hadn't read everything. I'm sorry for that.

 

[VashTheStampede]

Quagmire did keep mentioning that Vash could come back. I should have looked deeper into that but I didn't because I just assumed he was referring to one of the talk-to-dead roles that could revive people.

I hadn't read everything. I'm sorry for that.

I was losing my mind on the last day because you kept acting like I didn't exist. Tried tipping you off through reactions lol

 

[VashTheStampede]

It was basically my personal hell and Quagmire is basically Mephisto

 

[Quagmire]

I would still argue to keep it at the end of the day thanks to being able to use it twice. I don't think it made any difference this game, as there were no lynches after judgeings, but it could've been much worse very fast if folks also got a lynch off.

That is my opinion though. Could be totally different if the judge chooses wrong and suddenly it's a big swing the other way. This game it just ended up being nearly completely worse case scenario for the evils.

Fair point, or maybe make it like shadow wolf have to do it 12 hrs before game is over

It was looking good for you all after the first night

They probably are leaning towards they got the real Trickster wolf

Special Agent is gonna kill someone who is good

Doctor is protecting a wolf

The warden forgot to try and jail anyone

The Seer didnt do anything night 0 (and has picked two goods but one is obvious-ish (probably for comparison) and the other is gonna get killed by the special agent)

The Loudmouth has selected special agent

Though the last one does make it so the town doesnt lynch the SA

Though if she were protected by someone or protecting someone and berserked SA would sacrifice themself

 

[Ants!]

I was losing my mind on the last day because you kept acting like I didn't exist. Tried tipping you off through reactions lol

He did.

But what did he do?

 

[dimmerwit]

I'll admit that I read the role but didn't even consider the idea of deliberately lynching someone to bring Vash back.

Oops.

 

[VashTheStampede]

It worked out for the best

 

[Ants!]

Needs to be a tag group for people who don't like to be tagged.

(Just kidding don't really do that)

 

[Quagmire]

Quagmire did keep mentioning that Vash could come back. I should have looked deeper into that but I didn't because I just assumed he was referring to one of the talk-to-dead roles that could revive people.

I hadn't read everything. I'm sorry for that.

No one reads including me

Especially for a game that we are all very familiar with and a lot of these roles there were just small tweaks and our brain just tells us oh we know this role and we know everything we need

 

[Quagmire]

It worked out for the best

Would have been funny if you saved Jawneh and the town lost

 

[Jawneh]

Would have been funny if you saved Jawneh and the town lost

Sadly, there was no way I could anymore after Fool's was also gone and no solo killer. Not enough townie roles that could self-destruct, three known townies who knew each other, McClane plot armor, and warden.

But it would've been very amusing though lol. And I definitely would've tried to capitalize on that to gain cred.

 

[Quagmire]

Sadly, there was no way I could anymore after Fool's was also gone and no solo killer. Not enough townie roles that could self-destruct, three known townies who knew each other, McClane plot armor, and warden.

But it would've been very amusing though lol. And I definitely would've tried to capitalize on that to gain cred.

John McClane is not to be underestimated, nor Judge Reinhold

 

[dimmerwit]

 

[Ants!]

I'll probably do a second round of my game soon, but I'm going to give others a chance to do theirs first because mine was so recent and I still need to workshop it a little more.

 

[Ants!]

What does goose mean? Is that the trickster?

 

[Fool's Requiem]

What does goose mean? Is that the trickster?

Goose is the Serial Killer, basically.

Goose is also a kingmaker.

 

[Ants!]

Goose is the Serial Killer, basically.

Goose is also a kingmaker.

He's also dead.

 

[A Fifth of a Million]

 

[Quagmire]

What does goose mean?

The most majestic and regal of the avian animal kingdom

 

[Jon]

Oh, it's over? Who won? What happened? I haven't read anything since I was killed.

 

[shortkut]

Oh, it's over? Who won? What happened? I haven't read anything since I was killed.

The party goers won

 

[Jon]

The party goers won

I dunno what that means. I'm assuming an inside joke for those that paid attention.

 

[shortkut]

I dunno what that means. I'm assuming an inside joke for those that paid attention.

No, the terrorists lost. The party goers won

 

[Ants!]

 

[Ben]

Did Kat murder me, or did the wolves vote to kill me? Or both and she just did it first?

 

[dimmerwit]

Did Kat murder me, or did the wolves vote to kill me? Or both and she just did it first?

I'm sure I read that somewhere, but I just checked and couldn't see that so maybe I'm confusing it with something else. @Quagmire could help.

Either way Kat killed you. Even if the wolves targeted you that would come first.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Did Kat murder me, or did the wolves vote to kill me? Or both and she just did it first?

we voted to kill Kat, but afterward, we were told to vote on a number between 1 and 7 because Kat had some kind of diversion role but she wouldn't be successful if we guessed correctly. I was the only one to replay and said 5.

 

[dimmerwit]

You know, I remember reading about all that now that you mention it. I think I just wrote the wrong three letter name.

Sorry Ben, I can't seem to stop killing you even on a spreadsheet.