Top 10 Ice Cream Flavours

[Tubby23]

1. Rum & Raisin
2. Cookies & Cream
3. Chocolate
4. Nutella
5. Baileys & Brownie
6. Choc Chip
7. Coffee
8. Caramilk
9. Peanut Butter
10. Vanilla

Tell me what you like.

 

[Webster]

1} Mint chocolate
2} Moose tracks
3} Neapolitan
4} Chocolate
5} Chocolate cookie dough
6} Strawberry
7} Rocky road
8} Cookies & Cream
9} Cherry
10} Blueberry

 

[Tubby23]

I'm an extremely strong believer that mint and chocolate do not belong together.
Mint on its own great, chocolate on its own great, the two of them together.... war crime

 

[TD]

Oh god.

I've had 100s of flavours and I'm not exaggerating.

I'm an ice cream fiend. I'll be back to this.

 

[Webster]

the two of them together.... war crime

*deadpans* Then I guess I'll be at the dock inside of the Hague for the crime of liking Mint Chocolate ice cream!

 

[Smacktard]

GOAT:

 

[Tubby23]

GOAT:
View attachment 3312

Absolutely incredible ice cream

 

[Crystal]

1.) Chocolate
2.) Swirl
3.) Vanilla
4.) Baskin Robins Gold Medal Ribon
5 -> 1,000,000.) Everything else.

 

[Smacktard]

Absolutely incredible ice cream

There's a golden gaytime beer too. I don't know what's more shocking -- that it tastes just like it, or that it's actually good.

 

[Tubby23]

There's a golden gaytime beer too. I don't know what's more shocking -- that it tastes just like it, or that it's actually good.

Yep have had many a gaytime brew, one of the few times IMO that turning something else good into a beer flavour has worked

 

[Fool's Requiem]

1. Strawberry
2-10. Anything else.

 

[TD]

Okay here's my attempt:

1) Banana Boat
2) Key Lime Pie
3) Salty Caramel Truffle
4) Birthday Cake
5) Blue Buried Treasure
6) S'mores
7) Coconut
8) Moon Mist
9) Wolf Paws
10) Mint Fudge Swirl

...you may not know what some of these are but I can elaborate if anyone is curious.

 

[Quagmire]

Moose Tracks

Mint Chocolate Chip

Cookies and Cream

Peanut Butter and Chocolate

Some sort of Fudge Chocolate

Bourbon Ball

Vanilla

Two milkshake shout outs: Churro, and Cinnamon Toast Crunch that Im sure would be great as ice cream


thats about it for me, strawberry is trash, as is rocky road, get those nuts out of my dessert. There are others I can enjoy, but not enough for a top 10 other than variations of what I've listed

 

[Tubby23]

Okay here's my attempt:

1) Banana Boat
2) Key Lime Pie
3) Salty Caramel Truffle
4) Birthday Cake
5) Blue Buried Treasure
6) S'mores
7) Coconut
8) Moon Mist
9) Wolf Paws
10) Mint Fudge Swirl

...you may not know what some of these are but I can elaborate if anyone is curious.

Tell me more about 5, 8 & 9

 

[Tubby23]

Moose Tracks

Mint Chocolate Chip

Cookies and Cream

Peanut Butter and Chocolate

Some sort of Fudge Chocolate

Bourbon Ball

Vanilla

Two milkshake shout outs: Churro, and Cinnamon Toast Crunch that Im sure would be great as ice cream


thats about it for me, strawberry is trash, as is rocky road, get those nuts out of my dessert. There are others I can enjoy, but not enough for a top 10 other than variations of what I've listed

What in the world is Moose Tracks

 

[TD]

Tell me more about 5, 8 & 9

Certainly.

Blue buried treasure is blueberry ice cream mixed with cream cheese icing. It also has white chocolate cups filled with blueberry and pomegranate.

Moon Mist is a mix of banana, grape, and bubblegum. Absurdly popular on the east coast of Canada.

Wolf Paws is vanilla ice cream but it has a delicious chocolate butter swirl and pieces of brownie.

 

[Tubby23]

I love the sound of the first and third one!

 

[TD]

What in the world is Moose Tracks

It's pretty popular in Canada too.

Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter cups and a fudge swirl.

 

[Tubby23]

Sounds nice.

* adds to ice cream bucket list *

 

[Foxy]

1. Mint Chocolate Chip
2. Coffee
3. Chocolate Peanut Butter
4. Banana Walnut
5. Rum Raisin
6. Pistachio with Dark Cherries (only found in Chinese Restaurants for some reason)
7. Butter Pecan
8. Dulce de Leche
9. Fresh Peach
10. Any good quality Chocolate

 

[Tubby23]

6. Pistachio with Dark Cherries (only found in Chinese Restaurants for some reason)

This is definitely in my Top 20. Over here I can get it at most ice cream shops

 

[Benzine]

Maple Syrup and Walnut flavoured ice cream is my fav. Chunks of walnuts.

Choc for the typical flavours.

Golden Gaytimes are called something else here but they're still great in my mind... but the reality is is that they're fucken terrible now.

One local one we have, is an ice cream version of a peanut slab chocolate bar. It's so good. Not my photo:




edit: my nana used to make licorice ice cream, and i really liked it. you couldn't have too much of it though.

i quite like ice cream too. one of my fondest memories is when i used to play cards and board games all day with my nana, and she was a terrible cook. one day i had ice cream for every single meal. so good as a kid.

 

[TD]

edit: my nana used to make licorice ice cream, and i really liked it. you couldn't have too much of it though.

I'm intrigued by this.
We talking red or black licorice?

 

[Tubby23]

Maple Syrup and Walnut flavoured ice cream is my fav. Chunks of walnuts.

Choc for the typical flavours.

Golden Gaytimes are called something else here but they're still great in my mind... but the reality is is that they're fucken terrible now.

One local one we have, is an ice cream version of a peanut slab chocolate bar. It's so good. Not my photo:

View attachment 3323


edit: my nana used to make licorice ice cream, and i really liked it. you couldn't have too much of it though.

i quite like ice cream too. one of my fondest memories is when i used to play cards and board games all day with my nana, and she was a terrible cook. one day i had ice cream for every single meal. so good as a kid.

You have so many good food products that we get and the Whittaker's chocolate and ice cream is top tier

 

[Benzine]

I'm intrigued by this.
We talking red or black licorice?

Black. The ice cream is lightly flavoured licorice, and there's actual licorice in there too.

You have so many good food products that we get and the Whittaker's chocolate and ice cream is top tier

We sure do, but shit here is EXPENSIVE.

 

[Tubby23]

Here it's relatively mid range, especially when considering that the blocks are generally larger than average blocks from Cadbury, Darrel Lea etc

 

[BigDaddy]

Certainly.

Blue buried treasure is blueberry ice cream mixed with cream cheese icing. It also has white chocolate cups filled with blueberry and pomegranate.

Moon Mist is a mix of banana, grape, and bubblegum. Absurdly popular on the east coast of Canada.

Wolf Paws is vanilla ice cream but it has a delicious chocolate butter swirl and pieces of brownie.

Those were the three I was curious about too. The first and third ones sound wonderful, but I think the less said about the second one the better.

I had moose tracks multiple times when I was in Wyoming a couple weeks ago. I think it's pretty popular in the more moose-populated areas of the U.S. I also had huckleberry a few times, which I discovered when I first went to Montana five years ago. They do huckleberry everything in the northwest: pie, ice cream, shakes, etc. It's kind of similar to blueberry. Early in the trip our group bought a small tub of huckleberry ice cream from the store, and funnily enough all the parlors we got it from after that couldn't match the store-bought one in flavor.

 

[Quagmire]

Certainly.

Blue buried treasure is blueberry ice cream mixed with cream cheese icing. It also has white chocolate cups filled with blueberry and pomegranate.

Moon Mist is a mix of banana, grape, and bubblegum. Absurdly popular on the east coast of Canada.

Wolf Paws is vanilla ice cream but it has a delicious chocolate butter swirl and pieces of brownie.

Wolf Pays sounds really good, the other two, yuck

 

[Christina]

Pralines and Cream
Butter pecan
Coffee
Cookies and cream
Mint chocolate
Blueberry cheesecake
Banana pudding

 

[Christina]

Also bonus, vanilla icecream on any warm pie or brownie!

 

[Crystal]

Also bonus, vanilla icecream on any warm pie or brownie!

True! Very very good!

 

[TD]

My new fascination: vanilla with a fruit flavoured hot sauce.

 

[shortkut]

French vanilla
Tahitian vanilla
Vanilla bean


I think I did this right

 

[VashTheStampede]

List taken from Hershey's Ice Cream, my preferred hand dipped ice cream.

1. Cookies & Cream
2. Strawberry Cheesecake
3. Strawberry
4. Roadrunner Raspberry
5. Orange Blossom
6. Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
7. Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle
8. Peach
9. Banana Pudding
10. Award Winning Chocolate