Sony PS3 in Need of GPU "Reballing"

[Fool's Requiem]

I have a backwards compatible PS3 that was capable of playing PS1 and PS2 games. Very handy if one wants to only have one system to play games for all 3 systems and basically upscale previous gen games to 1080 and using an HDMI cable.

Unfortunately mine has never really worked. Got it used forever ago, graphics started artifacting and I stopped using it in the hope I coul find someone who could fix it. I tested it out recently and it doesn't display anything anymore despite no yellow/orange light and having audio. Basic PS3 TS steps don't work.

Finally found a place that could take a look. They said the GPU needs to be "reballed". Told me it would cost 250 bucks (minus the 30 I paid for them to diagnose).

I could go any try my luck with another PS3, but backwards compatible PS3s are running 200+ on eBay and most of them are Japan imports. Plus, there's no telling how long those last before needing reballing, too.

Thoughts? I really don't want to hold onto 3 systems if I can keep one that plays all three, especially since neither the PS2 nor PS1 can use HDMI without mods and/or extra equipment. I can technically play PS1 games on my computer as emulators allow reading straight off the disc, but PS2 games are left in the dust in that regard.

Thoughts? I could get a slim PS2 and PS3 (already have the small PS1), but it's still extra stuff taking up space and more cables and controllers I need to keep track of, including whatever devices I get to upscale the two older systems to HDMI and 1080.

I'm not doing the reballing myself. If it was just a simple resoldering, I'd do it, solder kits are cheap and I know how to solder. However, reballing is something completely different, based on the video I linked, and I cannot do that.

Thoughts?

Edit: They said they could buy it off me for parts for $20, but I feel like I could get more on eBay and that doesn't really solve my dilemma.

 

[Raine]

If the shop guarantees their work, and the BC PS3 is something you definitely want, $250 seems reasonable considering the alternative would be a similarly priced secondhand unit that may or may not have the same issue (eventually)? But only if they guarantee their work, i.e., you only pay if they don't fuck up and deliver a functioning console. $20 "for parts" is not a particularly good look for their outfit at face value, though.

Personally I have a slim of all three mothballed in the garage. I'd pull out the PS3 and use that if I wanted to play a PS3 game, otherwise, I'm content just running an emulator for most PS1/PS2 games. Lots of nice bells and whistles available to make the experience better than just a simple HDMI hookup. Plus I backed up a decent chunk of it many years ago anyway, in the event I got lazy and the dreaded disc rot came a knockin'. Or y'know, a flood or some shit.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

I might find a way to back up my games in the event of potential disc rot, but I would prefer to not use an emulator if I can. I see so many mods which are basically "remove the disc drive and stick an SD card reader in it's place" mods. I'm not doing that to my Dreamcast unless the disc drive no longer works.

I want to recheck with them as my console wasn't getting the yellow/orange light signifying an issue. I don't know if the GPU can die and still not give out the "something is fucked" light.

 

[Smacktard]

One thing I've always wondered about the PS3 fats -- once you get them fixed from an external source, will they not really break down again?

I ordered a refurbed PS3 Slim earlier this year because I had an early model Slim that has some issues and would crash whenever I tried to play God of War: Ascension.

Thought about getting a PS3Fat but was too worried about further issues down the road.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

I don't know if I anticipate using it so much that the work done becomes undone. I just want a working PS3 that let's me play games from 3 console generations.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Guess I find out in 3-4 weeks if reballing fixes the issue.

 

[Raine]

One thing I've always wondered about the PS3 fats -- once you get them fixed from an external source, will they not really break down again?

Can't say I've ever really been curious enough to look into it, but from a practical standpoint: If it's just something like shoddy construction, e.g., insufficient/improper soldering, incorrect/insufficient thermal paste, then doing a teardown and redoing those should result in a good (/permanent) lifespan.

But if, say, the solder/paste/warping/whatever failure is caused by poor design - not enough ventilation or a strong enough heatsink or something - like with the original X360, then you would probably expect the issue to reoccur.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Update: Repair methods failed. Offered to take it off my hands for parts and sell me another backwards compatible unit for 300 (I'm assuming that's after the trade in cost for a non working parts bin unit).

Based on prices on eBay, 300 is about the amount for a [advertised] working unit. There are some that are slightly below 300 (after shipping), but this place has a money back guarantee policy and it would be muuuuuuch easier to return the unit if it doesn't work.

 

[Raine]

Sucks about the console still not working. Honestly, ease of returns is the only reason I still patronize GameStop, so I definitely agree in leaning towards that option.

That being said I'm extraordinarily wary by nature, so I would personally drag along a couple games - a CD, a single-layer DVD, a dual-layer DVD and a BD - and have them test it in-store before walking out with it. Double check which model it is too, depending on whether you want the emotion engine or the software emulation variety of compatibility.

 

[Kat]

One thing I've always wondered about the PS3 fats -- once you get them fixed from an external source, will they not really break down again?

Do the fat ones have reliability issues? I have a slim PS3 that's never had any repairs done and still works fine.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Do the fat ones have reliability issues? I have a slim PS3 that's never had any repairs done and still works fine.

Even as I was buying the replacement, the guy at the store was sure to point out that there is always the chance that they will fail. Big issue is that heat ends up causing issues. One thing I've noticed can be done is redoing the thermal paste. I've also seen replacing the power supply and putting in an SSD helps.

Once my 30 day "warranty" for my "new" PS3 ends, I'm going in and doing anything and everything I can to make sure I don't encounter issues later on.

 

[Smacktard]

Do the fat ones have reliability issues? I have a slim PS3 that's never had any repairs done and still works fine.

Yeah the fats are notorious for being unreliable. After those, the earliest model slims have some problems too. But later models and the super slims work pretty well. I think the super slims' wifi cards tend to go bust fairly frequently though. Later model slims are apparently the most reliable models.