• Celebrating One Year of Revival!

    Come and join us in celebrating one year of GW's revival as GWF, share in some statistics and help us push towards the next twenty years! CLICK HERE

    We're also looking for suggestions for another community event we can put together that we can all enjoy! Come and give us some suggestions HERE
  • Our second year of the NFL Pick 'Em is open to join now. You can join directly here and get involved in the weekly threads over in the Picks forum.
  • If you are reading this message, congratulations! You are on the new server! You made it!!

Zell Wolf Not Zell Wolf 2 Day 4

Lynch 5

  • Alu

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Banana

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Fool's Requiem

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jon

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kat

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Smacktard

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Tommy Boy

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • VashTheStampede

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .

Smacktard

Connoisseur of fine video games
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
5,303
Me when banana is a wolf:
Shocked Snl GIF by Saturday Night Live
 

A Punched Face

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,758
Not as well. Feels like the wolves had victory in this game and it was stolen from them, honestly feel bad for them getting the headhunter target here is just unlucky.
I couldn't believe it was happening to be honest. I sat back and watched other people lead the charge up until people started moving away from him. And then for some reason no one was questioning me about why I really preferred ants over the obvious wolf choices of, well, all of them (sorry Vash and Banana, I knew you were wolves and just couldn't say anything about it)
 
I couldn't believe it was happening to be honest. I sat back and watched other people lead the charge up until people started moving away from him. And then for some reason no one was questioning me about why I really preferred ants over the obvious wolf choices of, well, all of them (sorry Vash and Banana, I knew you were wolves and just couldn't say anything about it)

You and I had the same problem of being "evil", well I was, but Ants got the same reading on both, but it seemed like Vash was a likely target and just kind of fell off. I thought for sure Vash or Banana was next, it is weird at how sometimes the town goes for and who they dont
 
I couldn't believe it was happening to be honest. I sat back and watched other people lead the charge up until people started moving away from him. And then for some reason no one was questioning me about why I really preferred ants over the obvious wolf choices of, well, all of them (sorry Vash and Banana, I knew you were wolves and just couldn't say anything about it)
I think a good part of it was people just wanting to honour Ants' withdrawal and not thinking about the game.
 
I was worried about that and then Jon coming back, we couldnt attack him and it was another townie vote
If Jon tagged Banana you could have killed him and then Tommy and nobody would ever know who Jon tagged. But if Ants wasn’t the HH Target I think you win anyways. 9 left after lynch, 8 after night kill. And now the village has to lynch Quagmire or Vash or else it’s GG. If they go Banana (hasn’t poisoned in eons) or Alu (Evil by dead Aura seer) the wolves win.

Lynching Banana is a wolf win because Vash can mute a townie and tie the vote the following day, and the wolves kill off Alu who almost certainly wouldn’t be protected by Kelly.
 

A Punched Face

puppy haver
Sucks
10K Post Club
Moderator
GW Elder
Messages
10,758
I think a good part of it was people just wanting to honour Ants' withdrawal and not thinking about the game.
People were voting for him before that! It was only after he said he was withdrawing until more moved away.

Also yeah I obviously knew he was a real seer because he was my target, so I knew Quagmire was really a wolf. I also knew his first read on Kat was real and therefore Vash was definitely a wolf (sorry FR!) and banana was obvious by the end as well.

But I wasn't about to say anything about that though.
 
People were voting for him before that! It was only after he said he was withdrawing until more moved away.

Also yeah I obviously knew he was a real seer because he was my target, so I knew Quagmire was really a wolf. I also knew his first read on Kat was real and therefore Vash was definitely a wolf (sorry FR!) and banana was obvious by the end as well.

But I wasn't about to say anything about that though.

I figured he was a seer early, but I could have been shamaned just like you were even if unlikely

I do notice how the last couple games people always say you're never much of a target and you kind of hide and then come out and go back and never catch heat for it
 

Smacktard

Connoisseur of fine video games
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
5,303
I just assumed everyone lied in this game
Most people if they're wolves just barely post.
You and I had the same problem of being "evil", well I was, but Ants got the same reading on both, but it seemed like Vash was a likely target and just kind of fell off. I thought for sure Vash or Banana was next, it is weird at how sometimes the town goes for and who they dont
I was sure Vash was evil, and I thought Quagmire was too. For some reason I was less sure on Alu. I figured Banana was the final wolf, or maybe Ants was the wolf and Banana really was the witch, but they were coupled together.

I first thought Alu or Kat were Cupid, but this didn't make sense. Really didn't think Alu was the headhunter, though.
 

Smacktard

Connoisseur of fine video games
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
5,303
I think this game is good evidence that Aura Seer is not nearly as OP as many think, and certainly having an aura seer call you evil isn’t a death sentence.

@Ants I’m sorry it got so stressful. That’s part of the hard part of wolf, especially when you are good you just want to say “WTF is wrong with you idiots!”
Aura Seer is OP in a game with bullets. This game had p much no bullets.
 
I think this game is good evidence that Aura Seer is not nearly as OP as many think, and certainly having an aura seer call you evil isn’t a death sentence.

@Ants I’m sorry it got so stressful. That’s part of the hard part of wolf, especially when you are good you just want to say “WTF is wrong with you idiots!”

We thought about killing him, I forget why we never did. Zell was our first target due to his knowledge of the game and detective role can be similarly dangerous as Seer. I do think it is a very strong role, wonder how it would have gone had @Local Hero not started the game off by taking this piss about being an aura seer as Ants wouldnt have had to come out so soon
 

Smacktard

Connoisseur of fine video games
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
5,303
If Jon tagged Banana you could have killed him and then Tommy and nobody would ever know who Jon tagged. But if Ants wasn’t the HH Target I think you win anyways. 9 left after lynch, 8 after night kill. And now the village has to lynch Quagmire or Vash or else it’s GG. If they go Banana (hasn’t poisoned in eons) or Alu (Evil by dead Aura seer) the wolves win.

Lynching Banana is a wolf win because Vash can mute a townie and tie the vote the following day, and the wolves kill off Alu who almost certainly wouldn’t be protected by Kelly.
FWIW I would've advocated for going after Vash the next day rather than Banana or someone else. Voodoo is too powerful the longer the game goes on.

Between my flag and Jon's avenger, I think there's a decent chance the town would've won if the head hadn't been hunted
 
FWIW I would've advocated for going after Vash the next day rather than Banana or someone else. Voodoo is too powerful the longer the game goes on.

Between my flag and Jon's avenger, I think there's a decent chance the town would've won if the head hadn't been hunted

Who were you planning on protecting if the game went on? We werent sure if you were covering yourself or not, I think we would have gone after you and rolled the dice as the more townies there are the greater odds you werent protecting yourself
 

Smacktard

Connoisseur of fine video games
GWF Sponsor
GW Elder
Messages
5,303
Who were you planning on protecting if the game went on? We werent sure if you were covering yourself or not, I think we would have gone after you and rolled the dice as the more townies there are the greater odds you werent protecting yourself
I said I'd flag Tommy. I wouldn't like about that, would I? :angel
 
I wanna see what everyone was saying in the dead thread
It wasn't that active. Also, I was still playing up my role as Preacher.

I'm not sure why Tommy ever bought it so readily though. He said I posted before it was known there was a Medium/Ritualist despite the fact that Benzine had told us he couldn't reveal information and that Tommy actually posted there before I did.
 
especially when you are good you just want to say “WTF is wrong with you idiots!”
That was it exactly, and I'm surprised at myself for getting so upset over it. I've been in a similar situation before where Vash was evil and I knew it somehow but Kat and Benzine kept saying I was super suspicious (for some reason) but I had a town role, but back then I took it in stride until Vash's marksman role claim proved false and got lynched. I'm thinking probably the difference between this game and that game is that back then things were going really good in my life off-screen, but this time I'm going through a lot of other shit and had an especially rough last couple of days and my mental fortitude for it just wasn't there this time.

Really didn't expect Alu to be the headhunter, and crazy to think if I held out then Quagmire would have been lynched, and he WAS the shaman wolf and I would have semi-believed Alu who was quite convincing. Banana probably would have been the next lynch though unless I deceived to check either Vash or FR next or if the wolves killed me next, but Kelly was probably most likely to be my next seer pick. And if we lynched Banana we probably would have lost if the next wolf kill evened the numbers.

Mad props to Quagmire for guessing my seer pick despite my best efforts to evade him, sorry to Kelly for not believing you (especially while getting upset about not being believed myself). And sorry to the wolves for taking away your win. I did want the town to win after they killed me but I never considered I might be the head hunters target. Yall played really great and if you won it would have been deserved.

I don't think I'll play wolf again though until things are going better for me and I feel sure enough in my own state of mind. Right now I know I'm compromised, and I don't want anyone to feel like they need to put on kiddy gloves with me or if I get a wolf role and people feel like they can't doubt me because of how I might react. But maybe sometime in the future I'll feel okay with playing again.
 
Back
Top Bottom