Margaritaville

[Local Hero]

@Mark please add @Quagmire at your convenience

 

[Local Hero]

Now that the partners are pretty much known, the vampire with be able to dodge them more easily.

 

[Mark]

@Mark please add @Quagmire at your convenience

I’ve added him.

 

[Quagmire]

Now that the partners are pretty much known, the vampire with be able to dodge them more easily.

But narrows down list for agency of who to try and lynch

Basically confirmed two townies that mob or vamp won't attack until the end

 

[Quagmire]

Yeah Im fine generally playing on phone, but running a game would be a rough experience

I don't like playing on my phone, I read a lot less

I plan to run a game around Xmas because I'll be in break and have a lot more computer access

 

[Local Hero]

I don't like playing on my phone, I read a lot less

I plan to run a game around Xmas because I'll be in break and have a lot more computer access

Running the game on my laptop is easy easier than my phone. Most of the errors I made were because of my phone (also just me).

 

[Local Hero]

@Mark

Never mind! Sorry

 

[Local Hero]

@Zell 17

 

[Mark]

@Mark

Never mind! Sorry

It’s all good. Just acknowledging this so I don’t revisit it later wondering what I missed.

 

[Local Hero]

Running the game on my laptop is easy easier than my phone. Most of the errors I made were because of my phone (also just me).

Impeccable timing on this one lol.

Yeah, making the posts right when I wake up and during the kids' bedtime are probably the worst times to do it.

 

[Quagmire]

 

[Mark]

Impeccable timing on this one lol.

Yeah, making the posts right when I wake up and during the kids' bedtime are probably the worst times to do it.

Could be worse… you could be trying to run a game from the opposite side of the world of most of your players like Benzine.

 

[Local Hero]

Could be worse… you could be trying to run a game from the opposite side of the world of most of your players like Benzine.

Benzine the goat

 

[Local Hero]

Soaking of... Benzine is dead, I didn't think I asked for dead thread access for him lol

 

[Mark]

Benzine the goat

A sleep deprived one, but one nonetheless.

Soaking of... Benzine is dead, I didn't think I asked for dead thread access for him lol

Nah, you got me to add him. Here’s your current list:

 

[Local Hero]

Also, Alu said he can see the thread but hasn't clicked on it yet because he's not a dirty cheater lol

 

[Local Hero]

Oh apparently I never asked for Zell, thought I did

 

[Local Hero]

@Mark for visibility. Zell needs access

 

[Mark]

Also, Alu said he can see the thread but hasn't clicked on it yet because he's not a dirty cheater lol

That’s… interesting. He had a full set of edited permissions, I bet I edited his user group instead of the admin one. My apologies. He should be blocked now.

Oh apparently I never asked for Zell, thought I did

This is probably why the GM’s prefer having a separate conversation thread going for that part, it’s less likely for that kinda stuff to happen.

@Mark for visibility. Zell needs access

He’s added.

 

[Local Hero]

@Zell 17 my bad, you're here now

 

[canadaguy]

Benzine the goat

He's good climbing?

 

[Local Hero]

He's good climbing?

 

[Quagmire]

He's good climbing?

 

[canadaguy]

@Local Hero sorry disappeared in here over the last couple days. Sickness tire through this house and its been an absolute shit show here

 

[Local Hero]

@Local Hero sorry disappeared in here over the last couple days. Sickness tire through this house and its been an absolute shit show here

 

[Local Hero]

So fools is protecting Vash and the mob and Vampire are both targeting Vash.

 

[Quagmire]

So fools is protecting Vash and the mob and Vampire are both targeting Vash.

 

[Benzine]

He's good climbing?

I reckon rock climbing might be one of the things I'm worst at. My body is not shaped for that.

 

[Local Hero]

If I do another game, big if, I think I'll buff vampire. If they attack someone being protected by doctor it should be a double kill (both converted)

If priest visits the vampire the priest dies (converted). Also priest only gets the confession if mob killed that night.

There was a lot of questions about the people killed by the vamp. Specifically, do they switch to the vampire's team? Maybe everyone who is converted and the vamp get their own chat so the dead player can help the vamp win?

Another mob role or two so they have more powers. Including mob seer.

Fewer town seers.

If judge picks wrongly, the person they judged dies no matter what, and the judge dies if they picked incorrectly (kind of like what I tried to do with Kat lol).

Please do let me know your thoughts

 

[Local Hero]

Also, we had a gunner with two shots, two armorers, one of which was kind of evil, and not a single damned shot was taken.

 

[Local Hero]

The armorer was the role I was probably most excited for.

 

[Quagmire]

If I do another game, big if, I think I'll buff vampire. If they attack someone being protected by doctor it should be a double kill (both converted)

If priest visits the vampire the priest dies (converted). Also priest only gets the confession if mob killed that night.

There was a lot of questions about the people killed by the vamp. Specifically, do they switch to the vampire's team? Maybe everyone who is converted and the vamp get their own chat so the dead player can help the vamp win?

Another mob role or two so they have more powers. Including mob seer.

Fewer town seers.

If judge picks wrongly, the person they judged dies no matter what, and the judge dies if they picked incorrectly (kind of like what I tried to do with Kat lol).

Please do let me know your thoughts

Maybe with the judge, if they choose to judge someone during the day, both die if they judge a townie, but if it is the result of no lynch, the town stops the lynching and turns on the Judge? Judge is kind of cool but it at the moment depends on no lynch

 

[Local Hero]

Maybe with the judge, if they choose to judge someone during the day, both die if they judge a townie, but if it is the result of no lynch, the town stops the lynching and turns on the Judge? Judge is kind of cool but it at the moment depends on no lynch

I think I'm confused, could you rephrase?

 

[Quagmire]

I think I'm confused, could you rephrase?

Judge can now judge someone before the day is over, similar to a priest, but if they are a townie, both die. If the judge gets to judge due to no lynching, only one death, either the judged (if bad) or the judge if they picked a townie. So townie still survives if judged due to no town lynching. Makes the judge less reliant on the poll, but higher risk to do it before a no lynch because the town could lose two people instead of 1.

 

[Local Hero]

Let me see if I have this straight.

If there's a vote going through to lynch, the judge can still use their ability to sentence a second person to death?

 

[Quagmire]

Let me see if I have this straight.

If there's a vote going through to lynch, the judge can still use their ability to sentence a second person to death?

Sort of, but they have to use it before the poll closes, and it has higher risk because it could potentially take out two townies (also would out them if they judged correctly)

Do something like XXXX Judges YYYY

The post no town lynchig, only one person is killed and town doesnt know who the judge is. Also limit to two judgements like it is now.

Make sense? Also probably would have it if they judge someone before the poll closes, they cant then use the post stalemate judgment power until the next day

Gives them a little more they can do, but comes with more risks if done out in the open

 

[Jon]

The armorer was the role I was probably most excited for.

It's just that Kut telegraphed I should be killed in this game.

 

[Jon]

Here's my issue at this point in the game. Withholding information is detrimental to the agency/town.

At this point, anyone not willing to admit their role should be suspect. No more alluding to roles, no more staying quiet.

Not saying that's necessarily the case here, but it feels obvious (which most things do when you're dead).

 

[Quagmire]

My judge targets switched around a lot

Zell, to Kut, to Tommy, back to Kut and finally Kat

Wish I had kept it on Kut, though did clear two townies who had been acting really weird

 

[Jon]

I loved the idea of the double agent. Having access to multiple powers and ability to win with either.

But it needs to be revamped. This open solicitation to both team, and having access to the mob chat is too much. They literally only care about killing the solo, then they cannot lose. Whoever wins, they win.

I wonder, @Local Hero, if you kind of make them like the WW Fan. They are agency with the agency power. If the mob attacks them, they "turn" the double agent and they get the power assigned to them as mob? And no access to mob chat until they are killed.

It just feels imbalanced. Like Kut has been honest the whole game because he can be. But he's openly playing against both teams. Mob has to know it too, but they can't kill him because it hurts their win chance. But as soon as mob looks dead, he outs them and wins with town? Feels OP.

 

[Jon]

Also, did I miss something? Everyone keeps talking about the explosive expert. Did we have one outside the dead body?

Who will not have planted anything?

Everyone keeps talking like town have an EA house booby trapped, but unless I missed something somewhere where the dead body set something via Local, or the person he was switched with, there is no booby trapped house.

 

[Quagmire]

I loved the idea of the double agent. Having access to multiple powers and ability to win with either.

But it needs to be revamped. This open solicitation to both team, and having access to the mob chat is too much. They literally only care about killing the solo, then they cannot lose. Whoever wins, they win.

I wonder, @Local Hero, if you kind of make them like the WW Fan. They are agency with the agency power. If the mob attacks them, they "turn" the double agent and they get the power assigned to them as mob? And no access to mob chat until they are killed.

It just feels imbalanced. Like Kut has been honest the whole game because he can be. But he's openly playing against both teams. Mob has to know it too, but they can't kill him because it hurts their win chance. But as soon as mob looks dead, he outs them and wins with town? Feels OP.

Maybe give the mob a chance to turn on the double agent, killing them and either bring back a dead mobster or they can choose someone within the remaining mob get an extra life or something

That way DA needs to stay quiet for longer

 

[Local Hero]

Also, did I miss something? Everyone keeps talking about the explosive expert. Did we have one outside the dead body?

Who will not have planted anything?

Everyone keeps talking like town have an EA house booby trapped, but unless I missed something somewhere where the dead body set something via Local, or the person he was switched with, there is no booby trapped house.

Tommy has claimed EE

 

[Quagmire]

Also, did I miss something? Everyone keeps talking about the explosive expert. Did we have one outside the dead body?

Who will not have planted anything?

Everyone keeps talking like town have an EA house booby trapped, but unless I missed something somewhere where the dead body set something via Local, or the person he was switched with, there is no booby trapped house.

Tommy is claiming that role

 

[Jon]

Maybe give the mob a chance to turn on the double agent, killing them and either bring back a dead mobster or they can choose someone within the remaining mob get an extra life or something

That way DA needs to stay quiet for longer

Not a bad idea either. Giving evils something like a revive.

I just don't know what's best for the DA. But they shouldn't get access to the chat and full participate in both.

 

[Jon]

Tommy has claimed EE

Tommy is claiming that role

Ahh, ok, I missed it.

I didn't read much of yesterday, and it shows lol.

 

[Quagmire]

I just don't know what's best for the DA. But they shouldn't get access to the chat and full participate in both.

I'm fine with that if and only if there is an upside for the mob to turn on the DA which means the DA needs to keep quiet

 

[Benzine]

@Zell 17 shall i host next or you? looking forward to interpreting the new roles

 

[Local Hero]

@Zell 17 shall i host next or you? looking forward to interpreting the new roles

Clearly not me

 

[Benzine]

Clearly not me

oh you can if you want?

it's not clear to me since i don't really read after i die