Zell Wolf Game VII-2 MVP

[Zell 17]

Choose

@An Adequate Amount of Diggity
@Benzine
@Cole
@Dean
@Jawneh
@Jon
@Kat
@Local Hero
@Raine
@Raposuh
@shortkut
@Smacktard
@TD
@Tommy Boy
@Tubby23
@VashTheStampede

 

[A Maybe Baker]

I mean I did have the most effective "No U" implementation since @canadaguy flaggered the RK to kill himself.

But I might be leaning toward Tommy? He put in a lot of effort this game and it paid off. He seered the right people at the right time to seal the deal when it came down to it.

Willing to hear more thoughts on the matter though before I officially vote.

 

[Dean]

@Tommy Boy came in clutch with an impassioned plea of innocence and the best utilization of his seer role, so I have to pick him.

 

[Benzine]

I'm having a think and lean Tommy too... But, his searches actually weren't great (sorry Tommy). But he did make it easy for me to believe him, and that was a key moment really.

Kelly did a lot of work but I mostly didn't read his posts cause I'm extremely lazy.

Alu you were good too, and I easily believed you. I think the lack of pressure, due to the pressure, it was just so easy to believe the people with the claims that led to a path to victory. I think the threat of the res, the protection, with your role really helped to fuddle the wolves on killing Tommy (or you).

 

[Dean]

To be honest, Benzine, Kelly, and Alu were also good, and I mean, I had a pretty easy road with killing Raposuh, but I think we all worked together very well. I just think Tommy stood out.

 

[Zell 17]

It's Kelly or Dean for me. They herded the cats. Honestly what you guys got done on Day 2 was very impressive.

 

[shortkut]

I would say Tommy or benzine. I’ll ruminate on this before voting

 

[A Maybe Baker]

It's Kelly or Dean for me. They herded the cats. Honestly what you guys got done on Day 2 was very impressive.

Dean became very trustworthy thanks to Vash, that's for sure.

 

[Jon]

Whoops, didn't know this was up, said it in another chat. Tommy is my vote. Played everything perfectly and it was his info that gave the town the win. Clearly from a wolf's perspective.

Kelly muted me when I wasn't talking much, so that counted against him in my eyes for the MVP vote. That and I despised the method of info gathering, legit or not. So it's easily Tommy to me.

The only other person I'd consider is Vash, because that was funny AF.

 

[A Maybe Baker]

So far it's Tommy in a runaway and I haven't even voted yet.

 

[Benzine]

It's a team effort anyway, MVP doesn't have to be by some huge margin or anything.

 

[Jon]

It's a team effort anyway, MVP doesn't have to be by some huge margin or anything.

 

[Benzine]

If this is to mean that I think I should be MVP, I definitely am not. I helped to save Local on the first day, and was also dismissive about the idea of him being a wolf, let alone that there was an alpha. I was also highly suspect of shortkut, that could've steered us wrong (if things hadn't gone they way they did because of the players who played better).

 

[A Maybe Baker]

With Tommy being so far ahead I might actually vote Vash. Despite killing himself, he proved that no one should have been able to claim marksman and made one less person, who was previously sus, no longer sus.

It's dumb AF but that information really helped distill who could be what.

 

[shortkut]

The reason why I want to give it to Benzine is because of how passionately he defended Tommy. I firmly believe that his read of Tommy helped make Tommy more trustworthy than Raposuh

 

[Jon]

If this is to mean that I think I should be MVP, I definitely am not. I helped to save Local on the first day, and was also dismissive about the idea of him being a wolf, let alone that there was an alpha. I was also highly suspect of shortkut, that could've steered us wrong (if things hadn't gone they way they did because of the players who played better).

 

[A Maybe Baker]

The reason why I want to give it to Benzine is because of how passionately he defended Tommy. I firmly believe that his read of Tommy helped make Tommy more trustworthy than Raposuh

I think Tommy did a really good job of defending himself honestly. His whole "why would I go through this much effort as a wolf!" with his spreadsheet of data was like "lol yup, he's not a wolf" for me.

 

[Benzine]

I think Tommy did a really good job of defending himself honestly. His whole "why would I go through this much effort as a wolf!" with his spreadsheet of data was like "lol yup, he's not a wolf" for me.

Wait until you see my bell ringer power point.

 

[A Maybe Baker]

Wait until you see my bell ringer power point.

Slide 1:

What is a bell?
Answer: a ding dong noise maker


Slide 2:
How does it ding dong?
Answer: a bell ringer dings the dong

 

[finlandguy]

I mean, technically it was Benzines rez that sealed the deal. Being 2 behind after that was what made the difference before we even got to trying to dodge protections.

Idk if I can give it to Tommy from wolf POV. Thanks to the early kills, killing seers became secondary for our agenda. He helped persuade the town of himself, but we still had a shot even after that.

So I'll throw it to that other guy.

 

[shortkut]

So I'll throw it to that other guy.

Who me? All I did was badger Kat until she gave up the ruse

 

[A Maybe Baker]

I mean, technically it was Benzines rez that sealed the deal. Being 2 behind after that was what made the difference before we even got to trying to dodge protections.

Idk if I can give it to Tommy from wolf POV. Thanks to the early kills, killing seers became secondary for our agenda. He helped persuade the town of himself, but we still had a shot even after that.

So I'll throw it to that other guy.

Benzine did need to nail getting someone to rez, that's true. But Tommy's defense of himself made him the more trustworthy seer, and his read of Cole resulted in finding 2 wolves (Cole, and then Kat because Cole being "Regular Werewolf" outed her lie)

 

[shortkut]

Benzine did need to nail getting someone to rez, that's true. But Tommy's defense of himself made him the more trustworthy seer, and his read of Cole resulted in finding 2 wolves (Cole, and then Kat because Cole being "Regular Werewolf" outed her lie)

You’ve swayed me. Voting @Tommy Boy for mvp and skip

 

[A Maybe Baker]

You’ve swayed me. Voting @Tommy Boy for mvp and skip

I swayed myself as well and finally voted.


I will say, this was a fun one for me. Not having any power at all and just needing to go with what I could see in writing.

 

[A Maybe Baker]

Congrats on your MVP, @Tommy Boy

 

[shortkut]

I swayed myself as well and finally voted.


I will say, this was a fun one for me. Not having any power at all and just needing to go with what I could see in writing.

Same. I was utterly useless, more so than usual, and it was fun. Need more games where almost everyone is powerless

3 reg wolves + 1 alpha/extra kill
1 fool
1 hunter
1 doctor
1 spirit seer?
8 vanilla townies

 

[A Maybe Baker]

Same. I was utterly useless, more so than usual, and it was fun. Need more games where almost everyone is powerless

3 reg wolves + 1 alpha/extra kill
1 fool
1 hunter
1 doctor
1 spirit seer?
8 vanilla townies

This would be a fun one. Almost no powers.

@Cole would a game with these settings strike your fancy?

 

[Cole]

This would be a fun one. Almost no powers.

@Cole would a game with these settings strike your fancy?

I probably still won't play, but it would be more balanced. give the wolves one more specialty role and you might get a wolf win.

 

[VashTheStampede]

 

[Raine]

With Tommy being so far ahead I might actually vote Vash. Despite killing himself, he proved that no one should have been able to claim marksman and made one less person, who was previously sus, no longer sus.

It's dumb AF but that information really helped distill who could be what.

It's why I'm never mad at the Tubby Boy shenanigans, honestly. Even if they explode themselves they're revealing good information for the town.

Until someone does it at a super pivotal moment and costs their team the game, I suppose. I was super anxious @Jawneh was about to do that in the Illusionist game.

I think Tommy did a really good job of defending himself honestly. His whole "why would I go through this much effort as a wolf!" with his spreadsheet of data was like "lol yup, he's not a wolf" for me.

I eagerly await the day this blows up in your face the way it blew up in Voldemort's back on OG GW.

I believe in you, @Tommy Boy!

 

[Smacktard]

I voted Alu. His defense of himself and his effort toward trying to guide the town were the most convincing IMO. He helped net the town the win after that. After Day 2, all the wolves (minus one) were pretty much out in the open so aura seer was redundant IMO (no offense Tommy).

 

[A Maybe Baker]

I voted Alu. His defense of himself and his effort toward trying to guide the town were the most convincing IMO. He helped net the town the win after that. After Day 2, all the wolves (minus one) were pretty much out in the open so aura seer was redundant IMO (no offense Tommy).

My first ever MVP vote!

I had good words. Worded well this game.

 

[finlandguy]

Who me? All I did was badger Kat until she gave up the ruse

Benzine did need to nail getting someone to rez, that's true. But Tommy's defense of himself made him the more trustworthy seer, and his read of Cole resulted in finding 2 wolves (Cole, and then Kat because Cole being "Regular Werewolf" outed her lie)

That's why I said from wolf POV. Otherwise I'd probably gonwith Kelly since no matter the sus we couldn't get enough heat on him. Dean would be a better choice if he wasn't so wishy washy with his voting practices, but he also had the advantage of being proven invulnerable to Vash.

 

[Benzine]

Oh I know, I'm not taking it as offense or anything. But it was the best chance to say why I'm not the MVP.

 

[Jon]

I think this poll brings up a very important question:

When's the next game starting?!

 

[Tubby23]

I could potentially run it back on Aussie Dingo, wouldn't start until Saturday US time at earliest though.
Any of you cunts keen?

ETA: I just need to do a few balance fixes and role edits so will need the time to get it set up plus cricket takes out my whole Saturday