Ben Wulf 1 - Day Phase #1

[Kat]

@Jon any particular reason you're voting for Alu?

 

[Quagmire]

Unless we have a second gunner, which I doubt while having 2 apparent detectives, the only day test we'd have would be a priest, which could end in disaster while proving nothing unless dimmerwit is a wolf and the priest chooses them.

I meant more in terms of lynching

 

[A PineSol Scent]

I meant more in terms of lynching

Day 1 lunch is still a bit of a risk when what we know is "potentially not town" and there's a potential fool or headhunter around, but it is an option.

 

[A PineSol Scent]

Lunch lol.

 

[Jawneh]

You know, I could be the ritualist for real this time.

 

[Quagmire]

Lunch lol.

I also frequently mistype or voice to text Miss hears Lynch as lunch

 

[Quagmire]

Day 1 lunch is still a bit of a risk when what we know is "potentially not town" and there's a potential fool or headhunter around, but it is an option.

Odds are low we hit a game over lunch on day one, but I know it has happened

 

[Quagmire]

And damn voice to text at it again

 

[Quagmire]

Also not saying I think we should definitely Lynch someone, more of a getting a conversation going as I normally err on the side of caution

 

[Christina]

I gave away my role in my first post. I'm the Red Lady.

Who did you visit?

You know, I could be the ritualist for real this time.

Haven't you already done that? Pretend to be ritualist and end up really being a ritualist.

 

[Jon]

@Jon any particular reason you're voting for Alu?

Because I’m simply choosing to believe Zell is a detective like you said and I’m playing law of averages that dimmerwit is town aligned this time and Alu is a bad boy.

I do not typically vote day one though so no idea if that’ll hold.

 

[dimmerwit]

Who did you visit?

Nobody. Night 1 visits are too risky and give no information if I visit a baddie.

 

[Quagmire]

Because I’m simply choosing to believe Zell is a detective like you said and I’m playing law of averages that dimmerwit is town aligned this time and Alu is a bad boy.

I do not typically vote day one though so no idea if that’ll hold.

Law of averages also would say we are unlikely to have two detectives

 

[Quagmire]

Nobody. Night 1 visits are too risky and give no information if I visit a baddie.

Yep, forgot who it was even though it was just a couple games ago visited someone on night one and ended up being the dead body

 

[A PineSol Scent]

Law of averages also would say we are unlikely to have two detectives

That's actually not that crazy with 4 strong roles to be honest. But yes it's certainly possible Zell is lying.

 

[dimmerwit]

TIL there are 4 strong roles.

 

[A PineSol Scent]

There can only be 1 speak with the dead role and 1 jailer type role, which leaves only:

Bully, Gunner, Detective to fill in 2 roles if both of the 1 only roles are taken up.

 

[A PineSol Scent]

Actually that makes it fairly likely there's a duplicate role to be honest.

 

[Quagmire]

There can only be 1 speak with the dead role and 1 jailer type role, which leaves only:

Bully, Gunner, Detective to fill in 2 roles if both of the 1 only roles are taken up.

I didn't think about that there couldn't be duplicate Jailer type roles or talk with the Dead

 

[canadaguy]

TIL there are 4 strong roles.

Wait till you see what else the first post contains

 

[Christina]

I suppose it is possible that alu and dimmer are wolf and solo type. Meaning we really can't miss if we kill one. We'll unless the solo is a fool.

 

[canadaguy]

Imagine Ben went to all this trouble making this fancy first post, and everyone just skips right over it

 

[canadaguy]

I suppose it is possible that alu and dimmer are wolf and solo type. Meaning we really can't miss if we kill one. We'll unless the solo is a fool.

It's also possible that's not the case and we can really miss badly

 

[Quagmire]

Wait till you see what else the first post contains

Hey now , not all of us like to read everything

 

[Jawneh]

Haven't you already done that? Pretend to be ritualist and end up really being a ritualist.

Nope. Ever since the bit started I've never actually been one. Not even during the choose your own adventure wolf.

... though I did manifest the latent power of "ritualist wolf", but that's simply due to my natural born talent.

 

[Christina]

It's also possible that's not the case and we can really miss badly

Let's break it down. If Zell is on the up and up.

Combos could be:
Wolf and solokiller
Wolf and solo non violent
Wolf and townie
Solo killer and solo non violent
Solo killer and townie
Solo non violent and townie.

Not bad odds of hitting something not town.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Imagine Ben went to all this trouble making this fancy first post, and everyone just skips right over it

Hey now , not all of us like to read everything

 

[A PineSol Scent]

Let's break it down. If Zell is on the up and up.

Combos could be:
Wolf and solokiller
Wolf and solo non violent
Wolf and townie
Solo killer and solo non violent
Solo killer and townie
Solo non violent and townie.

Not bad odds of hitting something not town.

And if he's on the down and down all is for naught and we go down a rabbit hole of potentially killing 2 townies.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

Townies needlessly killing townies?

I just can't see it.

 

[Fool's Requiem]

 

[Fool's Requiem]

I wish I was Priest. Would be perfect time to do a funny.

Edit. words

 

[canadaguy]

Let's break it down. If Zell is on the up and up.

Combos could be:
Wolf and solokiller
Wolf and solo non violent
Wolf and townie
Solo killer and solo non violent
Solo killer and townie
Solo non violent and townie.

Not bad odds of hitting something not town.

Except not every scenario is equally likely.

The scenarios with a townie are far more likely to be the one we are in.

 

[canadaguy]

Hey now , not all of us like to read everything

There's pictures for people like you and shortkut then

 

[Tommy Boy]

I loved this show and wish it didn't go away. Just speed it up slightly, lose the Muppet charade/fake storyline stuff, keep it going. It was a great concept.

Had Tommy Boy posted? I see he's voted, though could just be doing a meme vote with planning to join in later

So I'm going to operate on the assumption that Local was telling the truth about his read and that cg and Smacktard are on different teams, meaning cg could be solo or village. I am leaning village currently, and will take that into consideration this evening.

 

[Tommy Boy]

Also, thank you @VashTheStampede for proving the comedy option probably works half the time at least

 

[canadaguy]

So I'm going to operate on the assumption that Local was telling the truth about his read and that cg and Smacktard are on different teams, meaning cg could be solo or village. I am leaning village currently, and will take that into consideration this evening.

Would it help if I played you a song?

 

[Tommy Boy]

 

[Quagmire]

I can, I just don't!

 

[Kat]

View attachment 23597

Fake news, I was #4 and not the gunner. =[

 

[Christina]

Except not every scenario is equally likely.

The scenarios with a townie are far more likely to be the one we are in.

So we either need another seer to give us more information, another townie to kill somebody, or we need to use the information we have to make our best guess.

Dimmerwit is claiming Red Lady which is a good place to hide. Especially if you are not making any claims on anybody being good. Zell is claiming seer. If Zell is a bad guy, he's going to have to work for it at least. Dimmerwit is put up a non passenger roll that will mean he'll have to put some work into his lie, if it is one. And Alu doesn't even have a lie yet if he's a badong to see what work he wants to put into this.

I'm leaning Alu, because if you are going to be a badong in this town, you are going to have to work hard at it. No free rides.

 

[Kat]

I'm leaning Alu, because if you are going to be a badong in this town, you are going to have to work hard at it. No free rides.

I agree. @A Punched Face let's see a role claim.

Even though he'll just claim to be a farmer or some nonsense and everybody will believe him.

 

[A PineSol Scent]

I agree. @A Punched Face let's see a role claim.

Even though he'll just claim to be a farmer or some nonsense and everybody will believe him.

I can be proven by tomorrow. I have actual actions I can take in this game, unlike the last.

 

[Jawneh]

@Jon can you shoot a person? Preferably not me. Only Vash had permission and he foiled it already.

 

[canadaguy]

So we either need another seer to give us more information, another townie to kill somebody, or we need to use the information we have to make our best guess.

Dimmerwit is claiming Red Lady which is a good place to hide. Especially if you are not making any claims on anybody being good. Zell is claiming seer. If Zell is a bad guy, he's going to have to work for it at least. Dimmerwit is put up a non passenger roll that will mean he'll have to put some work into his lie, if it is one. And Alu doesn't even have a lie yet if he's a badong to see what work he wants to put into this.

I'm leaning Alu, because if you are going to be a badong in this town, you are going to have to work hard at it. No free rides.

And your role is what exactly?

I agree. @A Punched Face let's see a role claim.

Even though he'll just claim to be a farmer or some nonsense and everybody will believe him.

And your role is what exactly?

 

[A PineSol Scent]

It's not always a great move to our everyone's roles on day 1 to give the wolves and SK easy and prime targets. We already have 1 definite target out there in Vash.

 

[Jon]

@Jon can you shoot a person? Preferably not me. Only Vash had permission and he foiled it already.

I am not capable of any actions currently unfortunately. I am an unconfirmable village role sadly.

 

[Quagmire]

I can be proven by tomorrow. I have actual actions I can take in this game, unlike the last.

We could prove you tonight with a good ol barbecue and lynching

 

[Quagmire]

@Jon can you shoot a person? Preferably not me. Only Vash had permission and he foiled it already.

 

[Kat]

We could prove you tonight with a good ol barbecue and lynching

Arsonist confirmed.

 

[Quagmire]

Arsonist confirmed.

It's cold here, we need heat, preferably not my skin though