It only works if someone gets at least 4
Maybe the best option here is for all the good guys to... Not vote at all?
If Fool's is the one with the Loud Voice potion, if the Acolytes only have 3 votes, they can't hit the 4 vote threshold by themselves... If there's no secondary vote for them to fall back on, I assume that gives canadaguy no options.
@Ants! Can you clarify that for Fanatic to work someone has to have at least 1 vote? They can't just pick from anyone if the rest of us are at 0, right?
We run the risk of the acolytes winning this way. Because they can potentially get a controlling vote against Zell tomorrow. Guaranteed acolyte win if Tommy happens to be town.
Maybe the best option here is for all the good guys to... Not vote at all?
If Fool's is the one with the Loud Voice potion, if the Acolytes only have 3 votes, they can't hit the 4 vote threshold by themselves... If there's no secondary vote for them to fall back on, I assume that gives canadaguy no options.
@Ants! Can you clarify that for Fanatic to work someone has to have at least 1 vote? They can't just pick from anyone if the rest of us are at 0, right?
His power only works if the person with the most votes meets the minimum threshold for a witch hunt. The second highest can be any number.
Maybe the best option here is for all the good guys to... Not vote at all?
If Fool's is the one with the Loud Voice potion, if the Acolytes only have 3 votes, they can't hit the 4 vote threshold by themselves... If there's no secondary vote for them to fall back on, I assume that gives canadaguy no options.
@Ants! Can you clarify that for Fanatic to work someone has to have at least 1 vote? They can't just pick from anyone if the rest of us are at 0, right?
I'm saying if we don't vote and thus not lynch anyone we run the risk of the acolytes controlling the game.
It's entirely possible for them to have at least one loud potion they bought at night.
Maybe the best option here is for all the good guys to... Not vote at all?
If Fool's is the one with the Loud Voice potion, if the Acolytes only have 3 votes, they can't hit the 4 vote threshold by themselves... If there's no secondary vote for them to fall back on, I assume that gives canadaguy no options.
@Ants! Can you clarify that for Fanatic to work someone has to have at least 1 vote? They can't just pick from anyone if the rest of us are at 0, right?
Maybe it's a gamble, but otherwise they're guaranteed to kill Zell or anyone else they want. I don't see any way to control who the second highest vote is, we could only make it a tie where he gets to pick, or no vote at all.
If they do, they've already won.
I agree 100% with this.
If the assassin dies, do I get my money back?
Here's the thing... he's playing to his win condition too. He's still got as much a chance as anyone. So he's going to say that because he needs us convinced so we don't lynch him. Almost ALWAYS in a kingmaker scenario for the SK, they choose to align with the wolves. So I wouldn't bank too much on his willingness to help us. I'm positive if the acolytes were outed he'd play to them too.
You can but nobody else
Sweet. I kill that old man
lol, only a 20% chance of that happening.
I assume it's very unlikely Zell is winning by managing to be the last person alive. That's why I said it's smelling kingmakery.
It's you and Zell silly
Innocent? You might not be an acolyte, but I've seen what you've done to your neighbors goats next door.
What you never put on a production of Goat Hamlet?
