Alright, here's the gimmick

[Kat]

I expect Jawneh to continue saying he's a ritualist and Quagmire to be all WTF about it, resulting in Jawneh being lynched and everyone losing.

Jawneh claimed detective and is only saying the ritualist stuff to be silly. Wait, Quagmire knows Jawneh is telling the truth, right? Because he's the bell ringer?

It all comes down to whether they can convince Vash or maybe block his lynch by forcing a tie.

 

[canadaguy]

That's kind of the beauty. Every single person was telling the truth every single day. And that made them even more suspicious.

Except Jawneh

 

[dimmerwit]

Somebody finally killed me!!! That took way longer than expected.

Yo, Benzine! You're a bad guy!

You'd have been dead a lot earlier if I hadn't have protected you, which has turned out to mean nothing in this game.

 

[Aluse Cannon]

Jawneh claimed detective and is only saying the ritualist stuff to be silly. Wait, Quagmire knows Jawneh is telling the truth, right? Because he's the bell ringer?

It all comes down to whether they can convince Vash or maybe block his lynch by forcing a tie.

lmao I forgot that Quagmire bell rung Jawneh's role out. He literally knows everything.

 

[Aluse Cannon]

Vash may have figured it out.

 

[Zell 17]

Jawneh unfortunately checked Vash and Quagmire, and it came back as different team (Vash is a wolf today). So let's see what he does.

 

[Christina]

I'm going to have to read all this later.

 

[canadaguy]

Ahh it appears they've decided to be a bunch of pussies

 

[Kat]

I'm going to have to read all this later.

I hope you at least read the first post.

 

[Christina]

I hope you at least read the first post.

I did. I get what's going on now.

 

[Jon]

Quagmire: Has the solution

Jawneh: Confused as hell

Vash: Kill 'em all

Sums it up.

 

[dimmerwit]

Jawneh might be inbound with a logic bomb.

 

[Jon]

Quagmire already had the solution though...

 

[dimmerwit]

Nope, he voted Vash.

 

[Christina]

I love the idea of killing the one most proven roll.

 

[Jon]

Nope, he voted Vash.

I know... but... HE HAD THE RIGHT ANSWER!

This town deserves the Hiroshima level bomb it gets.

 

[dimmerwit]

I love how they found the solution and promptly chose to kill anyway.

We're great at this!

 

[Jon]

I love the idea of killing the one most proven roll.

And yet given this BS he's gonna come up wolf anyway. Even though Zell already confirmed he was the Gunner and there's no way to change that.

 

[dimmerwit]

The game is over at that point anyway.

 

[dimmerwit]

For Fallout New Vegas fans, this has basically been a real life Vault 11 experiment.

 

[Local Hero]

If I have learned anything from JRPGs it's that we must kill God.

This is a great interpretation actually

 

[Jon]

New meta game is the person lynched revives at the beginning of the next day and Vash dies in his/her place.

 

[canadaguy]

Ahh it appears they've decided to be a bunch of pussies

Or not.. Holy shit balls

 

[dimmerwit]

And would I have done any better?

God no!

 

[Quagmire]

I love how they found the solution and promptly chose to kill anyway.

We're great at this!

Village never changes

 

[Jon]

Village never changes

 

[VashTheStampede]

Yeah but Vash will think they're both trying to convince him to give them the win. And only one vote to lynch

That was 100% what I thought the endgame was about to be but after Quagmire's first post I flipped to completely believing they were both legit.

Bah.

 

[Kat]

That was 100% what I thought the endgame was about to be but after Quagmire's first post I flipped to completely believing they were both legit.

Bah.

I'm impressed you believed them so quickly. I wouldn't know what to believe. I thought you all would manage it right then, but then I refreshed the page and saw they had decided to kill you instead.

 

[Ben]

True meta is that the game ends in disappointment, just like real life.

 

[Jawneh]

That was 100% what I thought the endgame was about to be but after Quagmire's first post I flipped to completely believing they were both legit.

Bah.

You wanna hear something awful.

You probably don't, but here it goes.

After reading through the last day thread again, I completely blanked out on basically everything you and Quagmire were saying before I got onto the thread and started rambling nonsense lmao.

 

[VashTheStampede]

I'm impressed you believed them so quickly. I wouldn't know what to believe. I thought you all would manage it right then, but then I refreshed the page and saw they had decided to kill you instead.

I thought the gimmick was that the dead thread was pulling the strings and choosing kills and rolls and the only way to win was to stop adding to their ranks.

Close.

Bah.

 

[Aluse Cannon]

I thought the gimmick was that the dead thread was pulling the strings and choosing kills and rolls and the only way to win was to stop adding to their ranks.

Close.

Bah.

That would have been fun too

 

[Zell 17]

I thought the gimmick was that the dead thread was pulling the strings and choosing kills and rolls and the only way to win was to stop adding to their ranks.

Close.

Bah.

If I could have it over that would be it

 

[Quagmire]

True meta is that the game ends in disappointment, just like real life.

Or no one lies and everyone is truthful, especially on the internet

 

[Benzine]

i say we ban zell

 

[Jawneh]

Maybe @Ants! was right with reacting with sus to all my posts. Maybe I should've gotten nuked earlier lol.

 

[Ben]

If this was all some lesson to teach us not to kill so quickly, I'll have you know I resent lessons.

Should have listened to me with making Tommy test his Flower Child ability, but noooooooooo.

 

[Ben]

Or no one lies and everyone is truthful, especially on the internet

No one lies and everyone is truthful, until Vash shoots them.

 

[VashTheStampede]

If this was all some lesson to teach us not to kill so quickly, I'll have you know I resent lessons.

Should have listened to me with making Tommy test his Flower Child ability, but noooooooooo.

He seemed weirdly against the idea was my main issue with it

 

[Tommy Boy]

He seemed weirdly against the idea was my main issue with it

 

[Ben]

He seemed weirdly against the idea was my main issue with it

Should have been all the more reason to lynch him and test his claim. But I get that Christina got an opposite team read on me because apparently I was a wolf that night... So, kinda hard to argue you off that I guess.

I guess that's primarily why I'm minorly irked. I spent a fair bit of my day trying to think how the fuck I came up opposite team, knowing I wasn't. And it was all ultimately just a waste of brain power.

 

[VashTheStampede]

View attachment 20379

That's kind of my point though.

In retrospect obviously it's a bad read on my part.

 

[Quagmire]

View attachment 20379

Being with shortcut in jail last game seems to have rubbed off on vash

 

[dimmerwit]

And it was all ultimately just a waste of brain power.

Welcome to GWF Wolf!

 

[Aluse Cannon]

That's kind of my point though.

In retrospect obviously it's a bad read on my part.

Every read in this game was a bad read

 

[VashTheStampede]

Should have been all the more reason to lynch him and test his claim. But I get that Christina got an opposite team read on me because apparently I was a wolf that night... So, kinda hard to argue you off that I guess.

I guess that's primarily why I'm minorly irked. I spent a fair bit of my day trying to think how the fuck I came up opposite team, knowing I wasn't. And it was all ultimately just a waste of brain power.

Well another issue was that it appeared as if we would lose another 2 players if we WERE inactive and the best way to try and save ONE person was to get lucky and drop the nonexistent Cereal Killer.

But yeah, I understand how you feel on that second paragraph.

 

[Quagmire]

Well another issue was that it appeared as if we would lose another 2 players if we WERE inactive and the best way to try and save ONE person was to get lucky and drop the nonexistent Cereal Killer.

But yeah, I understand how you feel on that second paragraph.

Yeah the two kills night before, and then Jawehs idea of someone being all 3 killing roles made sense given how many and who was left. You already were a gunner

 

[Ben]

Welcome to GWF Wolf!

Yeah, you ain't wrong.

Well another issue was that it appeared as if we would lose another 2 players if we WERE inactive and the best way to try and save ONE person was to get lucky and drop the nonexistent Cereal Killer.

But yeah, I understand how you feel on that second paragraph.

It's all good. Definitely can't fault any reads for what they were knowing it was all ephemeral smoke, after the fact.

 

[Tommy Boy]

I guess that's primarily why I'm minorly irked. I spent a fair bit of my day trying to think how the fuck I came up opposite team, knowing I wasn't. And it was all ultimately just a waste of brain power.

I'm not mad because something was off since Day 2. I was annoyed I couldn't figure it out, but not really like upset or anything once I died. I figured it was something like Zell was the only wolf, but I couldn't figure out how the game would work unless he intentionally masked people's roles, which wouldn't work for seers, so I eliminated that idea from my thought process. Then I thought it had something to do with the dead thread, as I started noticing something was weird about which posts they were reacting to. Not that they spoiled it - if anything, they followed the rules of not reacting to critical posts too much to the point where I thought something was weird. Then I realized the language from the opening post of each day changed, specifically the win condition. I had been under the impression that people thought I was the fool because of my first couple posts, but knowing there was no Solo Non Violent, I kept that info to myself until relevant.

I thought about not going through with a lynch and would have fought harder if the math was working out in my head, but I knew what I was saying was the truth and for some compelling reason, I felt honesty with the others as well. I knew before Day 3 ended that no matter the fuckery, it would be revealed once I died and I could stop worrying about it. I was almost relieved to see that everyone was played, and Vash almost figured it out.

 

[Ben]

Ironic that pushing the usual impulse to not lynch on day 1, which I told myself I'd put aside and be more aggressive after the BenzAntine game, would have resulted in no deaths night 1 and probably given up the gimmick real fast.

Probably not actually transferable to regular game logic though.