I think my relationship with this franchise is similar to yours,
@Ben. I saw the original in the cinema, and had to leave when Dennis Nedry got his comeuppance. But the first film is still in my top 5 favourite films of all time. The next two weren't as good, but much like the second Ghostbusters compared to the first, they're perfectly enjoyable films. I think I liked Jurassic World a bit more than you. I thought it was the best film in the franchise after the first one. Yes, elements of the story were recycled, but I thought the action was brought up to date enough and enough care was taken over it that it felt like a really good reboot. I thought Fallen Kingdom was almost irredeemably terrible. Completely soulless action followed by an awful "
check out this terrifying dinosaur that we spend two hours telling you is invincible but then just gets beaten by one of the standard dinosaurs" plot that you could see coming a mile away. Dominion was also, objectively, a bad film. But I think the fan service was done well enough that it was enjoyable. Still the second worst film of the six, though.
As for this trailer, I'm going to remain hopeful. I watch all films to enjoy them, and I enjoy Jurassic Park a lot generally speaking. I see the warning signs and I see the reasons for optimism with this. I do like the cast choices. Scarlett Johansson is just great generally, but I think Mahershala Ali is a really clever casting choice as well. I'll watch it, hopefully in the cinema, and initially at least I don't want to over analyse it.
I think the primary difference between us would be that I never wanted to leave the cinema. I was glued to it the whole time, watching people get eaten, literally like Tim eager for the goat to get devoured all "...
excellent"
.
I also certainly didn't
dislike Jurassic World. I might even put it as my third favorite of the 6, being;
- Jurassic Park
- The Lost World
- Jurassic World
- Jurassic Park 3
- Fallen Kingdom
- Dominion
I don't think it repeating the same general premise of the first park makes Jurassic World intrinsically bad by any means. As you said, they did a good job of extrapolating "what if they got the park operational" through to current day with updated technology. Even the premise of this huge genetics company not being happy with real dinosaurs and wanting to make something more exciting in the Indominus Rex makes perfect sense, those dumb bastards would totally do that.
I will be pleasantly happy if Rebirth lands as a new 3 or 4 for me. I have no delusions that it's going to knock the original two out of place, because there's just so much nostalgia there.
After losing my Jurassic Park virginity last year and watching the original trilogy I'll have to get to Jurassic World this year. That said I can't help but feel that skipping the latest two would be fine
I mean... They're
fine, but I think you'd have to go into them with the mindset that they're not really in the same ballpark as the Jurassic Park movies. Those two just became a vehicle for Chris Pratt to push his "I'm an action hero now!" rebranding. There are scenes that just have no real purpose.
I will say, the opening scene for Fallen Kingdom was
fucking amazing and I wish the entire movie had kept that vibe instead of pivoting to the
"super scary hybrid-dino" again with a side-plot of "cloned human".
Like, that opening hits close to the feel of the originals and I was
down.
It was honestly good up until they left the island and it shifted to
the Lockwood Manor. Maybe that's why I'm salty about it, because they essentially
replaced Richard Attenborough's character of John Hammond with "his secret business partner". Bullshit. Don't water down the actor/character's legacy. Shoehorning the whole
Maisey thing in there did not feel like it worked. Also the dumb
fucking military guy who tried to take a tooth from the Indoraptor, so they could pull "lol it's pretending to sleep" was cringe. Oh and the
I-Raptor being controlled by a laser pointer was also a dumb trope to employ, in my opinion.
Dominion was just... Bad. They did barely anything with the "dinosaurs on the mainland" and they don't
really seem to be causing a ton of a trouble... People just adapt to having them out there and it's whatever... Not like, devastation of raptors taking people's cattle, or the famous Procompsygnathus in the nursery scene. The particularly egregiously wtf scenes were
the pyroraptor unnecessarily diving into ice cold water when it could have just chased the fuckers or
Chris Pratt punching a Dilophosaurus... I would also say that they so obviously were trying to fuck with people's attachment to the original films, because at the very start we see
the T. Rex get killed by a "better dino" 65 million years ago. Even though the Rex that we know was the cloned one, it was still just a cheap way to make everyone resent he Giganotosaurus from the beginning. Inclusion of
Therizinosaurus was very cool because it's one of my favorite dinosaurs, but the concluding fight felt awkward. Also locusts were a dumb choice.